A core member of the Midnight Society. In The Tale of the Crimson Clown, he wrote a poem for Samantha that his brother Tucker used to blackmail him. Gary narrates his story to the group and is typically the character who closes the society meetings in the first run by throwing water on the fire.
Gary and Frank share a leadership dynamic within the Midnight Society.
Gary mentors Tucker across seasons, guiding him from a new member to a key investigator.
Gary and Betty Ann are trusted allies within the Midnight Society during the first three seasons.
Gary and Kristen share a long-standing friendship and leadership dynamic in the early group.
Gary and Vange form a strong alliance in the revival era, collaborating on investigations.
Gary and Kiki maintain a steady alliance as core group members in the first three seasons.
Gary and Stig maintain a steady alliance as core members in the later seasons.
Gary mentors Tucker across seasons, guiding him from a new member to a key investigator.
Gary and David are long-standing allies and co-leaders in the early Midnight Society.
Gary and Quinn form a reliable partnership in the revival era.
Gary and Eric share a brief but foundational alliance as early group members.
Gary and Andy share a supportive alliance as group members in the revival era.
Gary and Megan maintain a consistent alliance as core members in the later seasons.
Gary guides the Waif Kid through the ancient mystery.
Gary narrates the story of Rush Keegan's heroic quest.
Explore the full interactive character relationship map of Are You Afraid of the Dark?