Plot Analysis Summary
A novelist struggles between unrequited longing and an affair shaped by artistic projection, attraction, and emotional cruelty.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Voyage Toward Judgment
A plagiarism lawsuit sends the novelist across the Atlantic to appear at a New York trial. During the voyage, meeting Ellen creates an unexpected emotional focus.
Key Events
-
Plagiarism Lawsuit Begins — An author sues the novelist, claiming that parts of Rebecca were plagiarised.
Location: 1945
-
Decision to Travel — The novelist boards a ship to travel to New York for the trial.
Location: Departure point
-
Transatlantic Ship — The voyage provides the setting for the novelist's meeting with Ellen Doubleday.
Location: Ship
-
Meeting Ellen Doubleday — The novelist meets Ellen Doubleday during the voyage to New York. Characters: Ellen Doubleday
Location: Ship
-
Ellen Makes An Impression — Ellen's glamour and elegance immediately captivate the novelist. Characters: Ellen Doubleday
Location: Ship
-
Friendship Develops — A close friendship develops between the two women during the journey. Characters: Ellen Doubleday
Location: Ship
The Pain Of Rejection
A close friendship with Ellen becomes emotionally unequal when Ellen recognises the novelist's romantic feelings. Ellen's honest refusal leaves the novelist frustrated and wounded.
Key Events
-
Feelings Become Clear — Ellen realises that the novelist has romantic feelings for her. Characters: Ellen Doubleday
Location: Ship
-
Ellen Rejects Romance — Ellen says she supports love without censure but cannot return the feelings because she is heterosexual. Characters: Ellen Doubleday
Location: Ship
-
Arrival In New York — The journey ends as the novelist reaches New York for the appearance at the trial.
Location: New York
-
Trial Appearance — The novelist attends the trial concerning the plagiarism claim involving Rebecca.
Location: Trial setting
A Play Born From Longing
The rejection is transformed into September Tide, a play about forbidden love. The mother-in-law character reflects the novelist's feelings toward Ellen.
Key Events
-
September Tide Is Written — After the rejection, the novelist writes the play September Tide.
Location: Writing setting
-
Forbidden Love Play — The play depicts forbidden love between a young man and his mother-in-law.
Location: Writing setting
-
Ellen Inspires Character — The mother-in-law character is understood by the novelist as being based on Ellen. Characters: Ellen Doubleday
Location: Writing setting
-
Gertrude Joins The Play — Gertrude Lawrence is cast as the mother-in-law in September Tide. Characters: Gertrude Lawrence
Location: Theatre setting
Charisma And Transgression
Gertrude is cast in the play and initially judged harshly. Her confidence and charisma gradually attract the novelist, changing hostility into desire.
Key Events
-
Gertrude Joins The Play — Gertrude Lawrence is cast as the mother-in-law in September Tide. Characters: Gertrude Lawrence
Location: Theatre setting
-
Gertrude's Reputation — Gertrude is described as a confident bisexual actress with a brash and sexually uninhibited image. Characters: Gertrude Lawrence
Location: Theatre setting
-
Initial Judgment — The novelist initially regards Gertrude as brash and slutty. Characters: Gertrude Lawrence
Location: Theatre setting
-
Charisma Changes Perception — The novelist becomes increasingly drawn to Gertrude's charisma. Characters: Gertrude Lawrence
Location: Theatre setting
-
Affair Begins — The growing attraction between the novelist and Gertrude develops into an affair. Characters: Gertrude Lawrence
Location: Theatre setting
Two Attachments Collide
An affair with Gertrude develops while the novelist continues longing for unavailable Ellen. The conflicting attachments produce cruelty, emotional instability, and an unresolved ending.
Key Events
-
Longing For Ellen — The novelist continues to pine for Ellen, who remains unavailable romantically. Characters: Ellen Doubleday
Location: New York
-
Cruel Dismissal Of Gertrude — Despite the affair, the novelist treats Gertrude with cruel dismissiveness. Characters: Gertrude Lawrence
Location: Theatre setting
-
Competing Feelings Intensify — The novelist remains divided between longing for Ellen and attraction to Gertrude. Characters: Ellen Doubleday, Gertrude Lawrence
Location: Theatre setting
-
Emotional Impasse — The story closes on unresolved emotional conflict between two contrasting attachments. Characters: Ellen Doubleday, Gertrude Lawrence
Location: Theatre setting