Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Reluctant Arrival
Claire and Sarah move from Chicago to Mattawa, where Claire starts work at the local high school. Sarah resists the town and her mother's presence at school.
Key Events
-
Move to Mattawa — Claire and Sarah move from Chicago to the small town of Mattawa. Characters: Claire Porter, Sarah Porter
Location: Mattawa
-
New School Position — Claire becomes vice principal at the local high school. Characters: Claire Porter
Location: Local high school
-
Sarah Rejects Mattawa — Sarah mocks the town and asks not to enter school with Claire. Characters: Claire Porter, Sarah Porter
Location: Local high school
The Team's Invitation
Sarah earns a place on the undefeated school team and is invited to Maddie's house. Claire worries about the unsupervised gathering, but Sarah insists she will be fine.
Key Events
-
Team Acceptance — Sarah earns a place on the school's undefeated team. Characters: Sarah Porter, Ruth 'Coach' Simmons, Kat Simmons, Maddie
Location: Local high school
-
Invitation to Maddie's House — The team invites Sarah to an evening of bonding at Maddie's house. Characters: Sarah Porter, Kat Simmons, Maddie
Location: Maddie's house
-
Claire Sets Curfew — Claire worries about the unsupervised gathering and sets an 11:00 p.m. curfew. Characters: Claire Porter, Sarah Porter
Location: Claire's home
-
Sarah Leaves for Gathering — Sarah attends the gathering, where the students later say she brings a large vodka bottle. Characters: Sarah Porter, Kat Simmons, Maddie
Location: Maddie's house
Disappearance at Night
Sarah does not return by curfew, and her phone messages go unanswered. Claire contacts the school and an investigation begins with conflicting accounts from the teammates.
Key Events
-
Sarah Is Pressured to Drink — The students later claim Sarah drinks heavily by herself and insults the town. Characters: Sarah Porter, Kat Simmons, Maddie
Location: Maddie's house
-
Sarah Goes Outside — Kat says she tells Sarah to get some air before Sarah disappears from the porch. Characters: Sarah Porter, Kat Simmons, Maddie
Location: Maddie's house porch
-
Sarah Fails to Return — Sarah does not return by curfew or answer Claire's messages. Characters: Claire Porter, Sarah Porter
Location: Claire's home
-
Claire Starts Searching — Claire contacts the school and begins searching for Sarah with investigators. Characters: Claire Porter, Sheriff Doug Mosley, Rick Watchorn
Location: Mattawa
-
Teammates Are Questioned — Doug questions the teammates about Sarah's drinking and disappearance. Characters: Sheriff Doug Mosley, Kat Simmons, Maddie, Claire Porter
Location: Local high school
-
Statements Trouble Claire — Claire hears the girls' account and believes it does not match Sarah. Characters: Claire Porter, Sheriff Doug Mosley, Rick Watchorn, Kat Simmons, Maddie
Location: Local high school
A Troubling Discovery
The community searches the surrounding area until Ruth finds Sarah injured, cold, and confused. Sarah's account provides a lead, but the town begins treating her as dead.
Key Events
-
Community Search Begins — The community divides into groups and searches the surrounding area. Characters: Claire Porter, Ruth 'Coach' Simmons, Sheriff Doug Mosley, Rick Watchorn
Location: Surrounding area
-
Sarah Is Found Injured — Ruth discovers Sarah injured, cold, and confused during the search. Characters: Sarah Porter, Ruth 'Coach' Simmons
Location: Surrounding area
-
Sarah Describes Her Confusion — Sarah says she fell, woke without knowing where she was, and walked for some time. Characters: Sarah Porter, Ruth 'Coach' Simmons, Claire Porter
Location: Surrounding area
-
Town Assumes Sarah Dead — Claire confronts a town that already treats Sarah as dead despite Sarah being found alive. Characters: Claire Porter, Sarah Porter
Location: Mattawa
-
Funeral Services Offered — A funeral-home director offers services, and Claire angrily says there is no body. Characters: Claire Porter
Location: Funeral home
The Confession Unfinished
Claire rejects the funeral-home assumptions and leaves her job. A video leads her to confront a teammate, who admits that Sarah was forced to drink and blindfolded before the confession is cut short.
Key Events
-
Funeral Services Offered — A funeral-home director offers services, and Claire angrily says there is no body. Characters: Claire Porter
Location: Funeral home
-
Claire Leaves Her Job — Claire quits her vice-principal job after being urged to take paid leave. Characters: Claire Porter
Location: Local high school
-
Video Reveals New Evidence — Claire receives a video and confronts a teammate about what happened. Characters: Claire Porter, Kat Simmons
Location: Claire's home
-
Initiation Confession — The teammate admits the girls forced Sarah to drink and blindfolded her before the confession cuts off. Characters: Claire Porter, Kat Simmons, Sarah Porter, Maddie
Location: Unknown interview location
A mother's worst nightmare comes true when her teenage daughter goes missing.