Plot Analysis Summary
Jenny seeks an honest marriage with Kitty while confronting family expectations, secrecy, and eventual parental acceptance.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Secret Love
Jenny hides her five-year relationship with Kitty behind a roommate story. Her parents continue pushing her toward marriage with men.
Key Events
-
Cleveland Family Setting — Jenny lives within a conservative Catholic family in Cleveland. Characters: Jenny, Eddie, Rose, Anne
Location: Cleveland, Ohio
-
The Roommate Cover — Jenny presents Kitty as her roommate to conceal their five-year partnership. Characters: Jenny, Kitty, Eddie, Rose, Anne
Location: Family home
-
Marriage Pressure — Her parents remind Jenny about marriage, children, and her biological clock. Characters: Jenny, Eddie, Rose
Location: Family home
-
Dates With Men — Eddie and Rose try to fix Jenny up with men. Characters: Jenny, Eddie, Rose
Location: Cleveland
-
Jenny Wants A Family — Jenny realizes she wants marriage and a family with Kitty. Characters: Jenny, Kitty
Location: Cleveland
The Proposal And Truth
Jenny decides that she wants marriage and a family, then proposes to Kitty. She chooses to reveal both their relationship and their engagement to her family.
Key Events
-
Jenny Wants A Family — Jenny realizes she wants marriage and a family with Kitty. Characters: Jenny, Kitty
Location: Cleveland
-
The Proposal — Jenny proposes to Kitty after deciding to build a family together. Characters: Jenny, Kitty
Location: Cleveland
-
Coming Out Decision — Jenny decides to tell her family that Kitty is her fiancée. Characters: Jenny, Kitty
Location: Cleveland
-
Family Revelation — Jenny reveals both her sexuality and her engagement to Kitty. Characters: Jenny, Kitty, Eddie, Rose, Anne
Location: Family home
-
Parental Shock — Eddie and Rose are taken aback by Jenny's revelation. Characters: Jenny, Eddie, Rose
Location: Family home
Family Wounds
The revelation shocks Eddie and Rose, while Anne feels betrayed by Jenny's years of secrecy. Jenny begins repairing the relationship with Anne by asking her to be maid of honor.
Key Events
-
Parental Shock — Eddie and Rose are taken aback by Jenny's revelation. Characters: Jenny, Eddie, Rose
Location: Family home
-
Anne Feels Betrayed — Anne focuses on Jenny's years of lying rather than her sexuality. Characters: Jenny, Anne
Location: Family home
-
Maid Of Honor Request — Jenny asks Anne to be her maid of honor, beginning their reconciliation. Characters: Jenny, Anne
Location: Family home
-
Public Honesty — Jenny refuses her parents' demand that she remain closeted before their friends. Characters: Jenny, Eddie, Rose
Location: Family home
-
Fight With Eddie — Jenny's refusal causes a major fight with her father. Characters: Jenny, Eddie
Location: Family home
Refusing The Closet
Jenny refuses to hide her engagement from her parents' friends. Her insistence on honesty causes a major fight with Eddie and leads her parents to reject the wedding.
Key Events
-
Fight With Eddie — Jenny's refusal causes a major fight with her father. Characters: Jenny, Eddie
Location: Family home
-
Wedding Refusal — Jenny's parents initially refuse to attend the wedding. Characters: Jenny, Kitty, Eddie, Rose
Location: Family home
-
Rose Reconsiders — Rose realizes Jenny remains the daughter she has always been proud of. Characters: Jenny, Rose
Location: Family home
-
Rose Accepts Wedding — Rose agrees to attend Jenny and Kitty's wedding. Characters: Jenny, Kitty, Rose
Location: Family home
Walking Toward Acceptance
Rose recognizes that Jenny is still the daughter she has always loved and agrees to attend. Eddie changes his mind on the wedding day, allowing both parents to walk Jenny down the aisle.
Key Events
-
Eddie Changes Course — Eddie has a talk on the wedding day and finally agrees to go. Characters: Jenny, Eddie
Location: Cleveland
-
Parents Walk Jenny — Both parents walk Jenny down the aisle while Kitty awaits her. Characters: Jenny, Eddie, Rose, Kitty, Anne
Location: Wedding venue
-
Jenny And Kitty Marry — Jenny and Kitty's wedding becomes a public family milestone. Characters: Jenny, Kitty, Eddie, Rose, Anne
Location: Wedding venue
-
Family With New Baby — A closing photograph shows the whole family, including Jenny, Kitty, and their new baby. Characters: Jenny, Kitty, Eddie, Rose, Anne
Location: Closing credits