Plot Analysis Summary
A Hollywood sound adaptation of Dickens's novel that reshapes Miss Havisham's characterization, causality, and death.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
A Dickensian Sound Experiment
The film adapts Charles Dickens's 1861 novel and becomes its first sound version. Universal Studios produces the film in Hollywood with mostly American actors.
Key Events
-
Dickens Novel Adaptation — The film adapts Charles Dickens's 1861 novel of the same title.
-
First Sound Version — The production is identified as the novel's first sound-film adaptation.
-
Hollywood Production — Universal Studios produced the adaptation in Hollywood with mostly American actors.
Location: Hollywood
The Principal Characters
Pip, Estella, Miss Havisham, and Jaggers are identified through the credited cast. Pip's misfortunes are specifically connected with Estella and Miss Havisham.
Key Events
-
Hollywood Production — Universal Studios produced the adaptation in Hollywood with mostly American actors.
Location: Hollywood
-
Stuart Walker Directs — Stuart Walker directed the 1934 adaptation.
-
Pip Introduced — Phillips Holmes plays Pip, the adaptation's central identified character. Characters: Pip
-
Estella Introduced — Jane Wyatt plays Estella, who is connected to Pip's misfortunes. Characters: Estella
A Rewritten Miss Havisham
The adaptation makes Miss Havisham more eccentric than insane and changes her presentation by removing the novel's constant bridal veil.
Key Events
-
Miss Havisham Appears — Miss Havisham is linked to Pip's misfortunes involving Estella. Characters: Miss Havisham, Pip, Estella
-
Jaggers Cast — Francis L. Sullivan plays Jaggers in this adaptation. Characters: Jaggers
-
Eccentric Miss Havisham — The film presents Miss Havisham as more eccentric than insane. Characters: Miss Havisham
Altered Fate And Reception
Miss Havisham dies offscreen from natural causes instead of dying in a fire. The film is subsequently judged inferior to the 1946 David Lean version.
Key Events
-
No Constant Bridal Veil — Unlike the novel, Miss Havisham does not constantly wear her bridal veil. Characters: Miss Havisham
-
Natural Death Offscreen — Miss Havisham dies offscreen from natural causes rather than in a fire. Characters: Miss Havisham
-
Altered Causality — The film reduces Miss Havisham's apparent responsibility for Pip's misfortunes with Estella. Characters: Pip, Estella, Miss Havisham
-
Critical Comparison — Critics consider this version inferior to the 1946 David Lean adaptation.