Plot Analysis Summary
Joan and Tom's growing attraction becomes tangled in concealed identities, an apartment misunderstanding, and Joan's angry response to a humiliating revelation.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
Mistaken First Impressions
Joan's work and audition antics introduce her unpredictable circumstances. Tom's complications intersect with Joan when he mistakes her for someone from his past, and the two arrange another meeting.
Key Events
-
Earthly Routines Introduced — The opening contrasts orderly planetary movements with unpredictable human routines.
Location: Earth
-
Joan Spills on a Dress — Distracted by a passing girl, Joan accidentally spills something on a woman's dress. Characters: Joan Howell
Location: Unspecified
-
Audition Disguise — Joan imitates a Japanese governess as part of an elaborate audition act. Characters: Joan Howell
Location: Audition
-
Tom's Domestic Complications — Tom, a wealthy man, deals with romantic and domestic complications. Characters: Tom Milford
Location: Unspecified
-
Tom Mistakes Joan — Their paths cross when Tom mistakes Joan for someone he has encountered before. Characters: Joan Howell, Tom Milford
Location: Unspecified
-
An Awkward Evening — They share an evening while evading questions about their names and circumstances. Characters: Joan Howell, Tom Milford
Location: Unspecified
Trouble in the Apartment
Tom discovers Joan in his apartment, where she becomes entangled with his home and possessions. Harvey's concern about valuable paintings raises the stakes, but Tom persuades him not to call the police yet.
Key Events
-
Another Date Arranged — Despite their evasions, Joan and Tom agree to meet again. Characters: Joan Howell, Tom Milford
Location: Unspecified
-
Joan in Tom's Apartment — Tom discovers Joan has ended up in his apartment; Joan becomes entangled with the home and its possessions. Characters: Joan Howell, Tom Milford
Location: Tom's apartment
-
Paintings Cause Alarm — Harvey worries about the valuable paintings, while Joan does not know their worth and considers them ridiculous. Characters: Joan Howell, Tom Milford, Harvey Granson
Location: Tom's apartment
-
Police Call Delayed — Tom persuades Harvey to give him more time instead of calling the police. Characters: Tom Milford, Harvey Granson
Location: Tom's apartment
An Elaborate Dinner
Joan conceals the truth about herself as she grows closer to Tom and tries to impress him. With Audrey's help, she attempts to prepare duck à l'orange, while the pair's deceptions and mishaps deepen the confusion.
Key Events
-
Joan Tries to Impress Tom — As they grow closer, Joan hides the truth about herself and tries to impress Tom. Characters: Joan Howell, Tom Milford
Location: Unspecified
-
Dinner Preparations — Joan invites Tom to dinner and attempts to prepare his favorite dish with Audrey's help. Characters: Joan Howell, Audrey, Tom Milford
Location: Unspecified
-
Deception Compounds — Their deceptions and mishaps create growing confusion between Joan and Tom. Characters: Joan Howell, Tom Milford
Location: Unspecified
The Name Revealed
Joan learns that O'Shea is actually Tom Milford and feels humiliated and furious. Audrey reminds her of Joan's own actions in Tom's apartment, but Joan remains intent on getting even.
Key Events
-
O'Shea Revealed as Tom — Joan discovers that the man she knew as O'Shea is actually Tom Milford. Characters: Joan Howell, Tom Milford
Location: Unspecified
-
Joan Plans Her Response — Humiliated and angry, Joan keeps the next date and resolves to find a way to get even; the outcome is unresolved. Characters: Joan Howell, Tom Milford, Audrey
Location: Unspecified