Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
The Coded Music Boxes
Three music boxes carry a hidden message about stolen Bank of England plates and are sold at auction. Emery's account of an attempted theft draws Holmes and Watson into the case.
Key Events
-
The Plates' Hidden Message — John Davidson encodes the plates' hiding place in three music-box melodies.
Location: Dartmoor prison
-
Boxes Sold at Auction — Different buyers purchase the three boxes, each playing a subtly different tune.
Location: Auction
-
Emery Seeks Advice — Emery reports an attempted theft of a cheap box while more valuable boxes were left behind. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson, Julian 'Stinky' Emery
Location: Holmes and Watson's flat
-
Holmes Inspects the Collection — Emery shows Holmes and Watson his collection after describing the burglary attempt. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson, Julian 'Stinky' Emery
Location: Emery's house
-
Courtney Seeks the Box — Courtney tries to buy the auctioned box, but Emery refuses to sell it. Characters: Julian 'Stinky' Emery, Mrs. Hilda Courtney
Location: Emery's house
A Murder and a Disguise
Courtney fails to buy Emery's box, and Emery is murdered. Holmes follows the other buyers and recognizes that a supposed maid stole another box by locking a child away.
Key Events
-
Emery Is Murdered — After Courtney's request is refused, an accomplice who has entered the house murders Emery. Characters: Julian 'Stinky' Emery, Mrs. Hilda Courtney
Location: Emery's house
-
Holmes Tracks the Buyers — Emery's murder intensifies Holmes's interest, and he investigates the other box buyers. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson
Location: London
-
The Disguised Maid — Holmes and Watson arrive as Courtney, disguised as a maid, leaves on a supposed shopping errand. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson, Mrs. Hilda Courtney
Location: Second buyer's house
-
The Child's Box Is Stolen — Holmes realizes Courtney locked a child in a closet so she could steal the box. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Mrs. Hilda Courtney
Location: Second buyer's house
-
Holmes Acquires a Box — Holmes obtains the third box and examines its unusual musical notes. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson
Location: London
The Cipher and the Trap
Holmes deciphers the musical notes and learns from Scotland Yard that all three boxes are needed to find the plates. A clue at the ransacked flat leads him to Courtney, whose accomplices trap him in a gas-filled warehouse.
Key Events
-
Holmes Acquires a Box — Holmes obtains the third box and examines its unusual musical notes. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson
Location: London
-
Notes Become a Cipher — Holmes discovers that the variant notes correspond to letters of the alphabet. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson
Location: Holmes and Watson's flat
-
Scotland Yard Explains the Plates — Scotland Yard informs Holmes about the stolen plates; all three boxes are needed to decode the message. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Commissioner of Scotland Yard
Location: Scotland Yard
-
The Flat Is Ransacked — Holmes and Watson find their flat ransacked; a cigarette with distinctive tobacco remains as a clue. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson
Location: Holmes and Watson's flat
-
Tobacco Leads to Courtney — Holmes traces the tobacco to Courtney and confronts her. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Mrs. Hilda Courtney
Location: London
-
Holmes Trapped in Warehouse — Courtney's accomplices handcuff Holmes, hang him from a rafter, and leave poison gas filling the room. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Mrs. Hilda Courtney
Location: Warehouse
-
Courtney Steals Watson's Box — While Holmes is in danger at the warehouse, Courtney visits the flat and steals the box from Watson. Characters: Dr. John H. Watson, Mrs. Hilda Courtney
Location: Holmes and Watson's flat
The Museum Pursuit
Holmes survives, and Watson's quotation helps him infer the plates' hiding place. Courtney's gang finds the plates at Dr. Samuel Johnson's house museum, but Holmes and Scotland Yard intervene, arresting the group and recovering the plates.
Key Events
-
Holmes Escapes the Gas — Holmes narrowly escapes the warehouse after being left in the gas-filled room. Characters: Sherlock Holmes
Location: Warehouse
-
Watson's Quotation Gives a Clue — Watson casually quotes Dr. Samuel Johnson, prompting Holmes to infer where the plates are hidden. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson
Location: Holmes and Watson's flat
-
The Gang Finds the Plates — Courtney and her gang join a tour group, slip away, and locate the plates inside a bookshelf. Characters: Mrs. Hilda Courtney, Tour Guide
Location: Dr. Samuel Johnson's house museum
-
Holmes Foils the Theft — Holmes ambushes Courtney's group; Scotland Yard officers arrest them and the plates are returned to the bank. Characters: Sherlock Holmes, Dr. John H. Watson, Mrs. Hilda Courtney, Commissioner of Scotland Yard
Location: Dr. Samuel Johnson's house museum