Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
Death at the Investment Office
A mysterious man leaves the Garfield Investment Company after asking for a match and the time. A dead man is found, while bankruptcy and a suspect identification widen the investigation.
Key Events
-
Office Exit — A man leaves the investment company office and encounters the janitor on the stairs.
Location: Garfield Investment Company stairs
-
The Time Question — The departing man asks for a match and the time, then leaves without answering a question.
Location: Garfield Investment Company stairs
-
A Body Discovered — The janitor finds a dead man inside the investment company office.
Location: Garfield Investment Company office
-
Newspaper Inquiry — A Chronicle newspaperman arrives to speak with the inspector and first questions the watching officer.
Location: Garfield Investment Company
-
The Company Collapses — The investigation reveals that the investment company declared bankruptcy that morning.
Location: Garfield Investment Company
-
Suspect Identified — The janitor recognizes the man who left the office in the police records.
Location: Police records room
The Trial's Impossible Contradiction
The janitor maintains his testimony in court. Medical witnesses claim that the accused has been deaf and mute since birth, creating the central contradiction.
Key Events
-
Suspect Identified — The janitor recognizes the man who left the office in the police records.
Location: Police records room
-
Trial Testimony — The janitor maintains his account of what he saw and heard during the trial.
Location: Courtroom
-
Conflicting Medical Claims — Two doctors testify that the accused has been deaf and mute since birth.
Location: Courtroom
-
A Romantic Subplot — Jerry Crane is in love with an attractive female colleague at the Chronicle. Characters: Jerry Crane
Location: Chronicle newsroom
Newspaper Curiosity
Jerry Crane becomes involved through the Chronicle and warns a colleague about the strange accused man. A broker offers a potentially important hint for money.
Key Events
-
A Romantic Subplot — Jerry Crane is in love with an attractive female colleague at the Chronicle. Characters: Jerry Crane
Location: Chronicle newsroom
-
A Strange Impression — Jerry Crane feels that the mysterious accused man is strange and warns his colleague against visiting him. Characters: Jerry Crane
Location: Chronicle newsroom
-
The Broker's Hint — A young broker says he possesses a hint but will reveal it only for enough money.
Location: Brokerage office
-
A Visit Before Eight — The accused man visits the young broker before the scheduled evening newspaper visit.
Location: Young broker's office
-
The House Interview — A Chronicle newspaperman arrives at the house to investigate the mysterious accused man.
Location: The accused man's house
Questions Inside the House
A newspaper visit to the accused man's house produces another time question after a victim is seen. The parallel romantic story continues beside the investigation.
Key Events
-
The House Interview — A Chronicle newspaperman arrives at the house to investigate the mysterious accused man.
Location: The accused man's house
-
Another Time Question — After seeing another victim, the accused man again asks what time it is.
Location: The accused man's house
-
Love and Suspicion — The newspaper investigation develops alongside the romantic story involving Jerry Crane and a colleague. Characters: Jerry Crane
Location: Chronicle newsroom
-
Skepticism and Fascination — One newspaperman remains skeptical, while Jerry Crane becomes fascinated by the mysterious accused man. Characters: Jerry Crane
Location: Chronicle newsroom
-
The Article Series — Jerry Crane writes a series of articles about the mysterious accused man. Characters: Jerry Crane
Location: Chronicle newsroom
Piano and the Third Death
Jerry Crane writes articles while the investigation focuses on whether the accused can hear piano music. A third dead man appears the next morning, sharply escalating the mystery.
Key Events
-
The Article Series — Jerry Crane writes a series of articles about the mysterious accused man. Characters: Jerry Crane
Location: Chronicle newsroom
-
Piano Evidence — During a house visit, the inspector believes he sees the accused man hear piano music.
Location: The accused man's house
-
A Third Victim — The next morning, a third dead man is added to the case.
Location: Unspecified crime scene
-
The Mystery Escalates — The new death intensifies the unresolved mystery surrounding the accused man and the newspaper investigation. Characters: Jerry Crane
Location: Chronicle newsroom