Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
A Case Begins in Court
The opening moves from a Christmas visit and news of a justice's death to Riley's defense of Anderson. The court begins the trial and addresses Anderson's communication impairments.
Key Events
-
Christmas Visit to the Justice — A young woman visits a justice, receives a gift, and leaves.
Location: The justice's residence
-
News of the Justice's Death — A report announces the justice's death and mentions his failing health.
Location: News report
-
Riley Handles Anderson's Case — Public defender Riley represents Anderson, a homeless man accused of murder. Characters: Kathleen Riley, Carl Wayne Anderson
Location: Criminal court
-
Trial Opens — The criminal trial begins with Riley defending Anderson and Stella prosecuting. Characters: Kathleen Riley, Carl Wayne Anderson, Charlie Stella
Location: Courtroom
-
Communication Assistance Provided — The court notes Anderson's hearing and speech impairments and provides assistance. Characters: Carl Wayne Anderson
Location: Courtroom
Evidence Against Anderson
Stella questions prospective jurors, and the prosecution presents forensic evidence connecting a knife to the fatal wound. Riley struggles to challenge the case and pursues details about the testing.
Key Events
-
Jury Selection Begins — Stella questions prospective jurors, including Sanger, about their views on capital punishment. Characters: Charlie Stella, Eddie Sanger
Location: Courtroom
-
Knife Evidence Presented — The prosecution presents forensic evidence connecting Anderson's knife to the fatal wound. Characters: Kathleen Riley, Carl Wayne Anderson, Charlie Stella
Location: Courtroom
-
Riley Challenges the Case — Riley struggles to challenge the prosecution and finds little support for Anderson's account. Characters: Kathleen Riley, Carl Wayne Anderson
Location: Courtroom
-
Traces Found on the Knife — Riley learns the knife also carried human tissue and a partial hair follicle. Characters: Kathleen Riley, Carl Wayne Anderson
Location: Trial proceedings
-
Riley Seeks Testing Details — Riley seeks further information about the forensic testing. Characters: Kathleen Riley
Location: Trial proceedings
A Lead and an Ethical Limit
A cuff link and the victim's connection to Gray's office suggest another suspect. Riley refuses to break the law to pursue the lead, then tells the judge that Michael may identify the killer and asks for more time.
Key Events
-
Cuff Link Lead Emerges — A cuff link and the victim's work in Gray's office suggest another suspect may exist. Characters: Kathleen Riley, Paul Gray
Location: Government office connection
-
Riley Refuses Illegal Pursuit — Riley refuses to break the law to pursue the lead, despite the risk to Anderson. Characters: Kathleen Riley
Location: Investigation
-
Michael Contacts Riley — Michael contacts Riley and may be able to identify the killer. Characters: Kathleen Riley, Michael
Location: Unspecified
-
Riley Requests More Time — Riley tells the judge about Michael and asks for more time. Characters: Kathleen Riley
Location: Courtroom
-
Judge Questions Riley's Case — The judge questions Riley's case and warns her against sacrificing her integrity. Characters: Kathleen Riley
Location: Courtroom
Anderson's Testimony
Riley calls Anderson to testify, and he describes a wartime killing and a troubled personal history. The available dialogue ends during his testimony without giving the trial's outcome.
Key Events
-
Anderson Takes the Stand — Riley calls Anderson to testify in his own defense. Characters: Kathleen Riley, Carl Wayne Anderson
Location: Courtroom
-
Anderson Admits a Wartime Killing — Anderson admits killing someone while serving as a soldier in Vietnam. Characters: Carl Wayne Anderson
Location: Courtroom
-
Anderson Explains His Past — He recounts psychiatric hospitalization, a lost marriage, and an abandoned building dream. Characters: Carl Wayne Anderson
Location: Courtroom
-
A Reason to Kill — Anderson says he believed he needed a reason to kill and wanted a different life. Characters: Carl Wayne Anderson
Location: Courtroom
-
Testimony Ends Mid-Account — The available dialogue ends during Anderson's testimony, before the trial outcome is given. Characters: Kathleen Riley, Carl Wayne Anderson
Location: Courtroom