Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
The Conviction Takes Hold
A police officer is murdered at a speakeasy, and information leads police to Frank. He admits that a suspect stayed at his home but denies the murder, yet he is convicted and sentenced to 99 years.
Key Events
-
Chicago Violence Forms the Backdrop — Chicago's history of violence frames the murder case.
Location: Chicago
-
Officer Murdered at Speakeasy — A police officer is murdered at Wanda's speakeasy in 1932. Characters: Wanda Skutnik
Location: Wanda Skutnik's speakeasy
-
Frank Arrested — Information linking Frank to a suspect leads police to arrest him. Characters: Frank W. Wiecek
Location: Chicago
-
Frank Denies the Murder — Frank admits the suspect stayed at his home but denies involvement. Characters: Frank W. Wiecek
Location: Police custody
-
Ninety-Nine-Year Sentence — Frank is convicted and sentenced to 99 years in prison. Characters: Frank W. Wiecek
Location: Court
A Reporter Reopens the Case
Years later, McNeal hears Frank's claims about the identification and his trial. Tillie continues to believe in her son's innocence as McNeal shifts from skepticism toward a fact-based investigation.
Key Events
-
McNeal Takes Up the Case — Years later, McNeal investigates Frank's conviction and hears his account. Characters: P.J. 'Jim' McNeal, Frank W. Wiecek
Location: Prison
-
Frank Challenges the Identification — Frank says Wanda identified him after initially failing to recognize him. Characters: Frank W. Wiecek, Wanda Skutnik
Location: Prison
-
Tillie Believes Her Son — Tillie continues to believe Frank is innocent. Characters: Tillie Wiecek, Frank W. Wiecek
Location: Chicago
-
McNeal Recommits to Facts — After considering a sympathetic angle, McNeal recommits to investigating the facts. Characters: P.J. 'Jim' McNeal, Frank W. Wiecek
Location: Chicago
Pressure Against the Inquiry
Frank refuses to falsely confess or accuse another person in exchange for a possible release. As McNeal's reporting draws attention, officials object to renewed scrutiny and pressure grows to end the campaign.
Key Events
-
Frank Rejects False Confession — Frank refuses to falsely confess or accuse another person for a possible release. Characters: Frank W. Wiecek, P.J. 'Jim' McNeal
Location: Prison
-
Public Scrutiny Draws Objections — Officials argue that renewed scrutiny could undermine confidence in courts and police. Characters: P.J. 'Jim' McNeal
Location: Chicago
-
McNeal Defends the Inquiry — McNeal argues that a wrongful conviction must be challenged. Characters: P.J. 'Jim' McNeal
Location: Chicago
The Pardon Effort Stalls
The group believes Wanda's cooperation is necessary but concludes it cannot compel her to speak. They withdraw the pardon request rather than risk Frank's future parole prospects, and McNeal tells Tillie the hearings will be called off.
Key Events
-
Wanda's Cooperation Becomes Crucial — The group believes it cannot make its case to pardon authorities without Wanda. Characters: Wanda Skutnik, P.J. 'Jim' McNeal, Frank W. Wiecek
Location: Chicago
-
Pardon Request Withdrawn — Unable to compel Wanda to speak, the group withdraws the request to protect Frank's parole prospects. Characters: P.J. 'Jim' McNeal, Frank W. Wiecek
Location: Chicago
-
McNeal Delivers the Setback — McNeal tells Tillie the hearings are canceled and no pardon is possible. Characters: P.J. 'Jim' McNeal, Tillie Wiecek
Location: Tillie's home