Plot Analysis Summary
A pacifist-minded sailor struggles to reconcile love, conscience, military duty, and the cost of courage during World War II.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
Love Before Deployment
Susan faces jealousy and emotional conflict while the protagonist receives a naval call-up. Their love is acknowledged, but Susan refuses to break her engagement.
Key Events
-
Engagement Under Strain — Susan becomes jealous when her fiancé flirts with a client's daughter to secure business. Characters: Susan Cahill
Location: Madison Avenue advertising agency
-
Long Island Dinner Invitation — Susan accepts an invitation to dinner from the agency artist. Characters: Susan Cahill
Location: Long Island
-
Conflicted Lunch Date — Disturbed by his feelings, Susan nevertheless accepts a lunch date for the following day. Characters: Susan Cahill
Location: Long Island
-
Military Call-Up — A telegram orders the agency artist to report for active naval duty.
Location: Advertising agency
-
Family Introduction — Susan meets the protagonist's mother and learns about his marriage hopes and military call-up. Characters: Susan Cahill
Location: The protagonist's family home
-
Love Without Marriage — Susan admits she loves him but refuses to break her existing engagement. Characters: Susan Cahill
Location: The protagonist's family home
Duty Across the Pacific
The protagonist joins the destroyer and encounters disputes over compassion, military discipline, and his pacifist background. Susan is brought to San Francisco for a brief reunion.
Key Events
-
Unattended Departure — The naval destroyer departs for San Francisco without anyone seeing the new sailor off.
Location: Brooklyn Navy Yard
-
Survivors Rescued — The ship rescues three survivors from a sunken German submarine.
Location: At sea
-
Humanity Challenged — Humanitarian treatment of the rescued survivors creates a conflict over military conduct.
Location: USS Poe
-
San Francisco Reunion — Lt. Blanchard contacts Susan, helping bring her to San Francisco during the protagonist's liberty. Characters: Susan Cahill, Lt. Blanchard
Location: San Francisco
-
Marriage Agreement — Susan and the protagonist agree to marry immediately after their reunion. Characters: Susan Cahill, Lt. Blanchard
Location: San Francisco
-
Loss at Pebble Beach — Susan's sister receives notification that her husband has been killed in action. Characters: Susan Cahill
Location: Pebble Beach
Trial Under Fire
A hesitation during an aircraft encounter damages the protagonist's standing among the crew. He later helps dispose of an unexploded bomb and receives recognition at a funeral service.
Key Events
-
Marriage Deferred — Marriage is postponed until the protagonist safely returns from duty. Characters: Susan Cahill
Location: Pebble Beach
-
Air Recognition Crisis — The gunners request permission to fire at an approaching aircraft, but the command is delayed.
Location: Aleutian Islands
-
Assignment Reversal — After admitting he froze, the protagonist is reassigned to damage control.
Location: USS Poe
-
Unexploded Bomb — During a Japanese air attack, an unexploded bomb crashes through the deck.
Location: USS Poe
-
Bomb Thrown Overboard — The protagonist and a chief petty officer throw the unexploded bomb overboard.
Location: USS Poe
-
Captain's Funeral Tribute — At a funeral service, the captain states that the crew may have died without the rescue effort.
Location: USS Poe
The Cost of Courage
Violence at Dutch Harbor forces the protagonist to confront his own anger. A rescue mission on a Japanese-held island leads to combat, sacrifice, and personal transformation.
Key Events
-
Dutch Harbor Brawl — A quarrel between naval sailors and merchant mariners becomes a violent brawl.
Location: Dutch Harbor
-
Natural Anger Admitted — The protagonist tells Lt. Blanchard he felt an urge to kill, and the doctor reassures him that the reaction was natural. Characters: Lt. Blanchard
Location: USS Poe
-
Rescue Mission Begins — The protagonist volunteers to lead a dangerous mission to rescue stranded airmen and their photographs.
Location: Japanese-held island
-
Beach Ambush — Japanese soldiers cut off the rescue party, prompting a request for ship-based fire support.
Location: Island beach
-
Friend Mortally Wounded — A friend kills an attacking soldier, is wounded, and dies before reaching the ship.
Location: Island beach
-
Return With Portrait — The protagonist returns to Susan carrying a completed portrait intended for his friend's daughter. Characters: Susan Cahill
Location: Susan's home