Plot Analysis Summary
A household's sudden discovery of valuable paintings exposes greed, loyalty, and Abby's decisive claim to independence.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
Rumors Reach Massachusetts
Davenport and Rosen pursue paintings connected to a little-known deceased artist. A telegram alerts the Haggett household, while Abby's memories contrast with the family's dismissive opinion.
Key Events
-
Artworks Attract Outside Interest — Davenport and rival dealer Rosen set out after learning that valuable paintings may exist in Massachusetts. Characters: Maxwell Davenport, Rosen
Location: New York
-
Telegram Reaches The Household — The impoverished household receives notice of Davenport's planned visit. Characters: Dr. Milton Haggett, Abby
Location: Haggett home
-
The Artist Is Misjudged — Milton regards the deceased artist as a failed incompetent, while Abby remembers him fondly. Characters: Dr. Milton Haggett, Abby
Location: Haggett home
-
Warren Visits The House — Warren arrives while working as a paperhanger and seeks help with his courtship. Characters: Warren Creamer, Abby
Location: Haggett home
Dealers Circle The House
A false identity allows one dealer to buy paintings cheaply from Milton. Rosen then makes a larger offer, and Abby protects the portrait in her possession.
Key Events
-
Warren Is Thrown Out — Warren's marriage intentions are rejected by members of the household, ending his visit angrily. Characters: Warren Creamer, Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
-
Tallant's False Identity — A dealer presents himself as Davenport and gives Milton one hundred dollars. Characters: Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
-
Painting Sold For Medical Debt — Milton gives away a painting that had been used to stop leaks in the chicken house. Characters: Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
-
A Second Painting Is Purchased — The dealer buys another painting after learning that its reverse side was used as a canvas. Characters: Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
-
Abby Guards The Portrait — Abby reveals that she owns a portrait painted shortly before the artist died but refuses to sell it. Characters: Abby
Location: Haggett home
-
Rosen Makes A Larger Offer — Rosen offers Milton one thousand dollars for any paintings in the house. Characters: Rosen, Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
The Fortune Is Revealed
Davenport identifies himself and reveals that the paintings may be worth tens of thousands. A museum telegram drives the household into a frantic search.
Key Events
-
Davenport Reveals Their Value — Davenport identifies himself and explains that the paintings may be worth tens of thousands of dollars. Characters: Maxwell Davenport, Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
-
Museum Offer Arrives — A museum telegram offers the household a substantial sum for the paintings. Characters: Dr. Milton Haggett, Maxwell Davenport
Location: Haggett home
-
The House Becomes A Search Ground — The household conducts a desperate search for more canvases. Characters: Dr. Milton Haggett, Abby
Location: Haggett home
-
The Bonfire Is Remembered — The search collapses when it is revealed that a bundle of canvases was thrown into a bonfire years earlier. Characters: Dr. Milton Haggett, Abby
Location: Haggett home
Abby Claims The Trunk
The household learns that many canvases were burned, but Abby reveals that she saved seventeen. Milton's attempt to seize them creates the central confrontation.
Key Events
-
The Portrait Is Undervalued — Milton and other household members try to obtain Abby's portrait for fifty dollars. Characters: Abby, Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
-
Abby Exposes The Saved Canvases — Abby denounces the household and reveals that she saved seventeen canvases from the fire. Characters: Abby, Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
-
Milton Seizes The Trunk — Milton grabs the canvases from Abby's trunk in a desperate attempt to control their value. Characters: Abby, Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
-
Abby Claims Legal Ownership — Abby says she married the artist on his deathbed and is his legal widow, making Milton relent. Characters: Abby, Dr. Milton Haggett
Location: Haggett home
Departure With The Paintings
Abby's claim to be the artist's legal widow forces Milton to release the canvases. She leaves for Chicago while Warren's future plans are also secured.
Key Events
-
Abby Leaves For Chicago — Abby departs for Chicago with the valuable paintings and considers their future. Characters: Abby
Location: Train to Chicago
-
Warren Plans A Future — Warren and his partner plan their future while Abby travels with the paintings. Characters: Warren Creamer, Abby
Location: Train to Chicago