Plot Analysis Summary
A tragic exploration of colonial legacy, legal rigidity, and cultural prejudice surrounding an unjust execution.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
Arrest and Sentencing
Two young Englishmen are arrested in Penang for drug trafficking and immediately face the death penalty. The legal system moves swiftly, establishing the high stakes and irreversible trajectory of the case.
Key Events
-
Arrest in Penang — Two Englishmen are detained for drug trafficking. Location: Penang, Malaysia
-
Drug Trafficking Charges — Formal charges are filed against the defendants. Location: Penang Court
-
Death Penalty Sentencing — Judges impose the death penalty on both men. Location: Penang Court
-
Penang Colony Setting — Former British colony backdrop for the crisis. Location: Penang, Malaysia
-
Thatcher's Britain — Distant political era contrasting with Penang. Location: United Kingdom
-
Drug Evidence — Physical proof leading to the arrest. Location: Penang Police Station
-
Death Warrants — Legal instruments authorizing execution. Location: Penang Court
-
Play Adaptation Origin — Michael Wall's 1989 play establishes the narrative. Location: Royal Exchange Theatre
-
BBC ScreenPlay Broadcast — 1990 TV movie adaptation reaches audiences. Location: Television Studio
-
True Story Inspiration — Barlow and Chambers execution grounds the plot. Location: Historical Archives
Journey to the Colony
Relatives depart from Britain and travel to Penang, driven by hope to rescue their loved ones. The transition from home to a foreign jurisdiction highlights the cultural and geographical distance.
Key Events
-
Relatives Departure — Family members leave Britain to seek help. Location: United Kingdom
-
Arrival in Penang — Families arrive in the former British colony. Location: Penang, Malaysia
-
Travel Documents — Credentials enabling the families' journey. Location: United Kingdom
Futile Campaign
Families engage in diplomatic and legal appeals, only to encounter bureaucratic resistance and underlying prejudice. Their efforts gradually reveal deep-seated racism and the limits of their influence.
Key Events
-
Initial Authority Meetings — Families begin formal appeals to officials. Location: Government Offices
-
Diplomatic Interventions — Attempts to leverage colonial ties for clemency. Location: Consulate
-
Legal Strategy Shifts — Families explore alternative legal pathways. Location: Law Offices
-
Appeal Petitions — Formal requests submitted to local officials. Location: Government Offices
Inevitable Resolution
The realization of futility sets in as authorities remain unmoved. The narrative culminates in the execution, leaving the question of true barbarism unresolved but deeply felt.
Key Events
-
Racism Exposure — Prejudiced attitudes surface during interactions. Location: Public Spaces
-
Futility Realization — Families recognize their efforts are hopeless. Location: Hotel Rooms
-
Final Appeals Denied — Official communications confirm no clemency. Location: Government Offices
-
Execution Preparation — Prisoners are readied for the death penalty. Location: Prison Cells
-
Inevitable End — The boys face their fate without rescue. Location: Execution Chamber
Amongst Barbarians is set far away from Margaret Thatcher's Britain in Penang, Malaysia, a former British colony, where two young Englishmen have been arrested for drug trafficking. As they both face the death penalty, their relatives travel to Penang to come to their rescue. However, they soon find out that there is nothing they can do to save the boys' lives. In the course of their futile attempts at influencing the authorities, their racism becomes more than apparent. The question which is never made explicit is of course who the real barbarians are. Wall's play is based on a true story and featured David Jason's first straight acting role on TV.
