Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
The Guitar Wish
A young songwriter discovers an expensive guitar in a music shop and becomes excited by it. She asks Robin to buy it, but Robin immediately refuses.
Key Events
-
Songwriter Introduced — Robin is established as a mother connected to a young songwriter. Characters: Robin
Location: Unspecified setting
-
Music Shop Visit — A young songwriter visits a music shop and looks at instruments. Characters: Robin
Location: Music shop
-
Expensive Guitar Found — The young songwriter discovers an excellent but expensive guitar. Characters: Robin
Location: Music shop
-
Guitar Excitement — The discovery creates excitement around the desired guitar. Characters: Robin
Location: Music shop
-
Request To Mother — The young songwriter asks Robin to buy the guitar. Characters: Robin
Location: Music shop
-
Immediate Refusal — Robin responds with an emphatic refusal to buy it. Characters: Robin
Location: Music shop
A Door To 1979
Robin's refusal leads into a recollection of her youth. The story returns to 1979, when the Olds Cutlass was her first car.
Key Events
-
Immediate Refusal — Robin responds with an emphatic refusal to buy it. Characters: Robin
Location: Music shop
-
Mother Reflects — Robin begins reminiscing after refusing the request. Characters: Robin
Location: Recollection
-
Memory Returns — The story shifts back to Robin's experience in 1979. Characters: Robin
Location: 1979 recollection
-
Olds Cutlass Remembered — Robin remembers receiving an Olds Cutlass as her first car. Characters: Robin
Location: 1979 recollection
-
First Car Significance — The Olds Cutlass is presented as an important youthful memory. Characters: Robin
Location: 1979 recollection
-
Happiness Recalled — Robin's memory connects a desired possession with personal happiness. Characters: Robin
Location: 1979 recollection
The Meaning Of Happiness
Robin remembers the emotional importance of the Cutlass and recalls her father's belief that another person's happiness should bring happiness to him. The memory connects her past with the present request.
Key Events
-
Happiness Recalled — Robin's memory connects a desired possession with personal happiness. Characters: Robin
Location: 1979 recollection
-
Father's Saying Recalled — Robin remembers her father's statement about happiness making him happy. Characters: Robin
Location: 1979 recollection
-
Past And Present Connect — Robin's past desire is implicitly connected to the present guitar request. Characters: Robin
Location: Recollection
-
Maternal Hesitation — Robin's remembered experience creates uncertainty about her refusal. Characters: Robin
Location: Unspecified setting
-
Refusal Reconsidered — Robin begins reconsidering whether to reject the young songwriter's wish. Characters: Robin
Location: Unspecified setting
-
Memory Guides Choice — Robin's memory of the Cutlass informs her present decision. Characters: Robin
Location: Unspecified setting
A Mother Reconsiders
Robin begins to reconsider her emphatic refusal as the guitar request takes on personal meaning. The ending leaves open the possibility that she will change her mind.
Key Events
-
Memory Guides Choice — Robin's memory of the Cutlass informs her present decision. Characters: Robin
Location: Unspecified setting
-
Wish Gains Weight — The guitar request becomes tied to an emotional memory of youth. Characters: Robin
Location: Unspecified setting
-
Possible Change Of Mind — The narrative suggests that Robin may change her mind. Characters: Robin
Location: Unspecified setting
-
Mother Weighs Happiness — Robin weighs the cost of the guitar against her child's happiness. Characters: Robin
Location: Unspecified setting
-
Wish Awaits Answer — The story closes on the possibility that Robin will accept the wish. Characters: Robin
Location: Unspecified setting