Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
The Sea Takes Everything
The SS Crescent Star strikes a mine and sinks almost immediately. Holmes inherits command over an impossibly overcrowded lifeboat without any way to send an SOS.
Key Events
-
The Mine Strike — The SS Crescent Star strikes a derelict mine in the Atlantic. Characters: Alec Holmes
Location: Atlantic Ocean
-
The Liner Sinks — The luxury liner sinks in seven minutes, leaving survivors in the sea. Characters: Alec Holmes
Location: Atlantic Ocean
-
Command Changes Hands — The dying captain passes command to executive officer Alec Holmes. Characters: Alec Holmes
Location: Overcrowded lifeboat
-
No SOS Possible — Holmes learns that both transmitters were destroyed before an SOS could be sent. Characters: Alec Holmes
Location: Lifeboat
-
The Lifeboat Overflows — Twenty-seven survivors and a dog crowd into a boat built for nine. Characters: Alec Holmes, Edith Middleton
Location: Atlantic Ocean
Weight Of The Living
Holmes tries to organize shifts and keep the boat afloat. The distance to Africa and the boat's weight make survival appear nearly impossible.
Key Events
-
Shifts In The Water — Holmes organizes shifts between people in the water and those inside the boat. Characters: Alec Holmes, Edith Middleton
Location: Lifeboat beside the sea
-
The Boat Is Swamped — Edith enters the water, while Mr. Hayden's failure to follow instructions swamps the boat. Characters: Alec Holmes, Edith Middleton
Location: Lifeboat
-
Africa Seems Impossible — Holmes and Kelly discuss the impossibility of rowing the overloaded boat to Africa. Characters: Alec Holmes, Frank Kelly
Location: Lifeboat
-
Kelly Demands Sacrifice — Kelly tells Holmes that some tenants must be evicted if anyone is to survive. Characters: Alec Holmes, Frank Kelly
Location: Lifeboat
Kelly's Terrible Counsel
Kelly argues that some passengers must be sacrificed, but Holmes initially rejects the idea. Kelly later gives his own life as the storm approaches.
Key Events
-
A False Light — A reported light proves useless when the survivors fire a flare and receive no response. Characters: Alec Holmes
Location: Open sea
-
A Death In The Water — Mr. Wilson, who had been in the water, is discovered dead. Characters: Alec Holmes
Location: Beside the lifeboat
-
The Storm Approaches — Kelly warns that a major storm is approaching and urges Holmes to save those he can. Characters: Alec Holmes, Frank Kelly
Location: Lifeboat
-
Kelly Sacrifices Himself — Kelly jumps overboard after calling on Holmes to save the people he can. Characters: Alec Holmes, Frank Kelly
Location: Lifeboat
The Arithmetic Of Sacrifice
Holmes accepts responsibility for choosing who will die, rejecting the traditional rule of women and children first. McKinley dies resisting the first order, while Edith questions the morality of the survivors chosen.
Key Events
-
The First Ejection — Holmes orders McKinley to slip an unconscious woman overboard; McKinley protests. Characters: Alec Holmes, Will McKinley
Location: Lifeboat
-
McKinley Follows Her — McKinley goes overboard to receive the unconscious woman in his arms and dies with her. Characters: Alec Holmes, Will McKinley
Location: Beside the lifeboat
-
Holmes Chooses Survivors — Holmes continues sending people overboard until only those able to row and a young boy remain. Characters: Alec Holmes, Edith Middleton
Location: Lifeboat
-
Edith Questions Morality — Edith questions why supposedly wicked survivors remain while accomplished passengers were sacrificed. Characters: Alec Holmes, Edith Middleton
Location: Lifeboat
-
Faroni Attacks Holmes — Faroni demands that Holmes return for the others and wounds him with a thrown switchblade. Characters: Alec Holmes, Michael Faroni
Location: Lifeboat
Rescue And Judgment
Faroni attacks Holmes, and Holmes kills him with a flare gun. After the storm crossing, rescue arrives, but Holmes is repudiated and left facing the moral and legal consequences of his decisions.
Key Events
-
Faroni Is Shot — Holmes refuses to turn back, and Faroni is shot dead with a flare gun. Characters: Alec Holmes, Michael Faroni
Location: Lifeboat
-
The Nightmare Crossing — The survivors row relentlessly through the storm toward Africa. Characters: Alec Holmes, Edith Middleton
Location: Stormy Atlantic Ocean
-
Holmes Gives Up Water — Because of his infected shoulder wound, Holmes refuses water and relinquishes command. Characters: Alec Holmes
Location: Lifeboat
-
The Rescue Ship Appears — A foghorn sounds and a ship emerges to rescue the lifeboat's survivors. Characters: Alec Holmes, Edith Middleton
Location: Fog-covered sea
-
Holmes Faces Judgment — Most survivors repudiate Holmes as he boards, while the empty lifeboat drifts beneath the trial question. Characters: Alec Holmes, Edith Middleton
Location: Rescue ship and drifting lifeboat