Plot Analysis Summary
The documentary traces a pioneering legal career, a landmark legacy in gender equality, and the subject's transformation into a public icon.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
Education Against the Odds
The documentary follows the subject from her Brooklyn beginnings through Cornell and law school. Her experience as one of very few women in her Harvard class establishes the gender barriers surrounding her career.
Key Events
-
Brooklyn Birth — The documentary traces the subject's birth into a first-generation American Jewish family.
Location: Brooklyn, New York
-
Cornell Education — The subject earns a bachelor's degree and meets her future husband while studying at Cornell.
Location: Cornell University
-
Law School Barriers — The subject attends Harvard Law School when women are a tiny minority in her class.
Location: Harvard Law School
-
Columbia Graduation — She transfers to Columbia Law School and graduates while her husband builds a tax-law career.
Location: Columbia Law School
Building a Legal Challenge
After graduating from Columbia, she teaches law and takes on cases challenging gender discrimination. The cases include unequal treatment affecting both a woman in the Air Force and a single father seeking benefits.
Key Events
-
Law Professor — After graduating, she teaches law at Rutgers and Columbia.
Location: Rutgers Law School and Columbia Law School
-
Gender Bias Litigation — She argues cases challenging gender discrimination before a skeptical, all-male Supreme Court.
Location: United States Supreme Court
-
Frontiero Case — Among the cases she represents is a woman's challenge to housing discrimination in the Air Force.
Location: United States Air Force housing context
-
Single Father Benefits — She represents a single father denied benefits ordinarily paid only to single mothers.
Location: Social Security benefits system
From Appeals Court to Supreme Court
The film recounts her nomination to the federal appeals court and later Supreme Court confirmation. Her direct answers at the hearings precede a 96-to-3 confirmation vote.
Key Events
-
Federal Appeals Appointment — After nomination by President Jimmy Carter, she is confirmed to the federal appeals court in 1980.
Location: United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
-
Supreme Court Confirmation — She answers questions about abortion and discrimination and is confirmed by a 96-to-3 vote.
Location: Senate confirmation hearings
A Landmark and a Public Icon
The documentary discusses the VMI ruling and its importance to women who attended the formerly all-male institution. It also traces the growth of the Notorious R.B.G. following and her playful public image.
Key Events
-
VMI Gender Equality Ruling — The film discusses the 1996 decision permitting women to enroll at the previously all-male Virginia Military Institute.
Location: United States Supreme Court
-
Notorious R.B.G. Following — A 2015 book and Tumblr help turn her into a pop-culture icon, a nickname she embraces good-naturedly.
Location: Online and popular culture
-
Opera and Scalia Banter — The film shows playful banter with the cameo figure and notes their shared love of opera. Characters: Self
Location: Not specified
Dissent and Endurance
The film considers criticism of her public remarks, the court's conservative shift, and her increasingly forceful dissents. It closes on her continued work through serious illness and her stated standard for remaining in office.
Key Events
-
Dissents and Public Criticism — The film addresses criticism of her campaign comments about Trump and her increasingly forceful dissents as the court shifts rightward.
Location: United States Supreme Court
-
Work Through Illness — In her eighties and after surviving two cancers, she continues working and says she will serve while able to do the job with integrity.
Location: Supreme Court and gym