Plot Analysis Summary
A family drama follows Michael and those around him as war, protest, generational conflict, and social change reshape their lives.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Family Faces Change
The Herlihy family is introduced through ordinary domestic interactions and Michael's excellent report card. Michael's plans for college begin a conflict with Bill over independence, work, and education.
Key Events
-
The Herlihy Family Introduced — The film introduces the Herlihy family amid the optimism and uncertainty of the 1960s. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Katie Herlihy, Brian Herlihy, Bill Herlihy, Mary Herlihy
Location: Herlihy family home
-
Michael Receives Excellent Grades — Michael's excellent report card becomes part of the family's everyday interaction. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Bill Herlihy, Mary Herlihy
Location: Herlihy family home
-
Sibling Teasing at Home — Michael and his siblings exchange everyday teasing as the family routine is established. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Katie Herlihy, Brian Herlihy
Location: Herlihy family home
-
College Plans Create Tension — Michael's plans for college intensify his disagreement with Bill about independence and education. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Bill Herlihy
Location: Herlihy family home
Lessons Against the War
At Loyola, Michael attends Father Daniel Berrigan's civics class and encounters opposition to the undeclared war in Vietnam. His assumptions are challenged as he learns more and moves toward protest.
Key Events
-
Michael Arrives at Loyola — Michael begins college at Loyola and encounters new political ideas. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Father Daniel Berrigan
Location: Loyola
-
Antiwar Civics Class — Father Daniel Berrigan teaches against the undeclared war in Vietnam. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Father Daniel Berrigan
Location: Loyola classroom
-
Protest Encouragement — The priest encourages students to participate in social protest. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Father Daniel Berrigan
Location: Loyola classroom
-
Michael Questions the War — Michael learns more about Vietnam and confronts assumptions from his upbringing. Characters: Michael Herlihy
Location: Loyola
War Enters the Home
Brian returns in uniform and announces that he is going back to Vietnam. His argument with Michael over duty and intervention exposes the personal cost of the war, while the family also worries about Katie.
Key Events
-
Brian Returns in Uniform — Brian returns home in uniform, bringing the war directly into the family. Characters: Brian Herlihy, Michael Herlihy, Bill Herlihy, Mary Herlihy
Location: Herlihy family home
-
Brian Announces His Return — Brian tells the family that he is going back to Vietnam. Characters: Brian Herlihy, Michael Herlihy, Bill Herlihy, Mary Herlihy
Location: Herlihy family home
-
Brothers Debate Military Duty — Brian defends military duty while Michael questions the American intervention. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Brian Herlihy
Location: Herlihy family home
-
Family Worries About Katie — The family worries about Katie's whereabouts and her baby while political tensions deepen. Characters: Katie Herlihy, Michael Herlihy, Brian Herlihy, Bill Herlihy, Mary Herlihy
Location: Herlihy family home
Protest Meets Authority
Political campaigning, counterculture, and antiwar opposition intensify. Michael and Sarah join a protest where police confront demonstrators, making the public conflict more immediate.
Key Events
-
Political Change Spreads — Political campaigning, counterculture, and opposition to the war increasingly shape the characters' world. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Sarah Weinstock, Kenny Klein
Location: Public political spaces
-
Michael and Sarah Join Protest — Michael and Sarah participate in a protest against the war. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Sarah Weinstock
Location: Public protest
-
Police Confront Demonstrators — Police confront demonstrators as the crowd chants that the whole world is watching. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Sarah Weinstock
Location: Public protest
Testimony Without Closure
Brian struggles to describe his experience at a veterans gathering and reveals how far his understanding has changed. Federal agents seek Kenny while draft proceedings continue, leaving the characters and society unsettled.
Key Events
-
Brian Appears at Veterans Gathering — Brian appears at a public gathering of veterans after his return from Vietnam. Characters: Brian Herlihy
Location: Public veterans gathering
-
Brian Is Asked to Speak — Brian is asked to speak publicly about his experience of the war. Characters: Brian Herlihy
Location: Public veterans gathering
-
Brian Reconsiders the War — Brian recalls once imagining the war as a game his side could win, then struggles to explain his experience. Characters: Brian Herlihy
Location: Public veterans gathering
-
Federal Agents Seek Kenny — Federal agents approach Sarah while looking for Kenny Klein. Characters: Sarah Weinstock, Kenny Klein
Location: Public setting
-
Draft Proceedings Continue — Draft proceedings continue for young men facing military service. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Brian Herlihy, Kenny Klein
Location: Draft proceedings
-
Unsettled Family and Nation — The story closes with unresolved personal costs from war, protest, and social change. Characters: Michael Herlihy, Katie Herlihy, Brian Herlihy, Bill Herlihy, Mary Herlihy, Sarah Weinstock, Kenny Klein
Location: The characters' surrounding communities