Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
Night Attacks and Accusation
Livestock are attacked at night, and a warning about schoolchildren heightens concern. Suspicion falls on George after another animal is killed and a threatening letter is attributed to him.
Key Events
-
Livestock Attacks Begin — A series of night attacks leaves livestock mutilated and dead.
Location: Great Wyrley
-
Wounds Examined — Investigators conclude the wounds could cause fatal bleeding but need not have been made with a knife.
Location: Great Wyrley
-
Threatening Police Note — A note warns of a planned assault on schoolchildren.
Location: Police station
-
George Becomes a Suspect — After another animal is killed, police turn their attention to George, the vicar's son. Characters: George, Rev Shapurji Edalji
Location: Great Wyrley
-
Letter Attributed to George — A letter attributed to George appears to threaten children. Characters: George
Location: Great Wyrley
A Conviction Under Question
George is convicted and portrayed as a threat to animals and children. Years later, Arthur becomes involved in the case and listens to George describe the harassment endured by his family.
Key Events
-
George Is Convicted — George is convicted, and the judgment portrays him as a danger to animals and children. Characters: George
Location: Great Wyrley
-
Arthur Meets Jean — Years later, Arthur meets Jean after being urged to find a new pursuit. Characters: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Jean Leckie
Location: Unspecified
-
Arthur Takes Up George's Case — Arthur becomes involved in George's case and hears his account of the family's harassment. Characters: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, George
Location: Unspecified
-
Family Harassment Recounted — George recounts anonymous threats, a menacing message on a milk churn, and a false death telegram. Characters: George, Rev Shapurji Edalji, Charlotte Edalji
Location: The Edalji family home
Doubts and Hidden Threats
Arthur questions whether George's eyesight and experience fit the crimes, while learning that a local blacksmith also received threatening letters. The family recalls an intrusion and a missing doll, adding further uncertainty to the case.
Key Events
-
George Rejects Culprit Hunt — George says he focused on proving his innocence rather than identifying the culprit. Characters: George
Location: Unspecified
-
Arthur Questions the Case — Arthur weighs George's poor eyesight, scholarly work, and lack of livestock experience against the crimes. Characters: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, George
Location: Unspecified
-
Blacksmith Also Threatened — Arthur learns that threatening letters were sent to a local blacksmith, suggesting others were targeted. Characters: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
Location: Great Wyrley
-
Home Intrusion Recalled — The family recalls an intruder on the day of Maud's confirmation and the disappearance of her favourite doll. Characters: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, George, Rev Shapurji Edalji, Charlotte Edalji
Location: The Edalji family home
Evidence in Great Wyrley
Arthur and Woodie travel to Great Wyrley under the pretext of inspecting church masonry. They examine letters and consider whether differing handwriting may have been intended to mislead investigators; the supplied plot does not establish the investigation's final outcome.
Key Events
-
Disguised Journey to Wyrley — Arthur and Woodie travel to Great Wyrley, presenting their purpose as an inspection of church masonry. Characters: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Woodie
Location: Great Wyrley
-
Letters and Handwriting Examined — They examine letters and consider whether different handwriting was used to mislead investigators. Characters: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Woodie
Location: Great Wyrley