Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
The Hospital Story
Diane arrives at the hospital with an arm wound and claims an unknown assailant attempted a carjacking. She says the assailant shot her three children.
Key Events
-
Nighttime Hospital Arrival — Diane drives to the hospital after a shooting on 19 May 1983. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: McKenzie-Willamette Hospital, Springfield, Oregon
-
Arm Gunshot Wound — Diane arrives with a gunshot wound to her arm. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: McKenzie-Willamette Hospital
-
Carjacking Account — Diane claims an unknown assailant attempted to carjack her. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: McKenzie-Willamette Hospital
-
Children Reportedly Shot — Diane claims the unknown assailant shot her three children. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: Springfield, Oregon
-
Fatal Hospital Outcome — One child is described as dead on arrival after the shooting. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: McKenzie-Willamette Hospital
-
Paralysis After Shooting — Diane's son is described as paralyzed because of the gunshot. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: McKenzie-Willamette Hospital
Survival And Suspicion
The shooting leaves one child dead, one paralyzed, and the eldest temporarily unable to speak. The eldest later recovers enough to testify against Diane.
Key Events
-
Paralysis After Shooting — Diane's son is described as paralyzed because of the gunshot. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: McKenzie-Willamette Hospital
-
Temporary Loss Of Speech — The eldest daughter temporarily loses speech after a stroke. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: McKenzie-Willamette Hospital
-
Witness Recovery — The eldest daughter recovers sufficiently to become a court witness. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: McKenzie-Willamette Hospital
-
Investigation Turns Inward — The shooting account becomes the basis for a case against Diane. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: Springfield, Oregon
-
Prosecution Begins — Frank prosecutes Diane in the criminal case. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
-
Court Witness Testimony — The surviving eldest daughter serves as a witness against Diane. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
The Prosecutor's Case
Frank Joziak prosecutes Diane in court. The case challenges her account and relies on testimony from the surviving eldest daughter.
Key Events
-
Court Witness Testimony — The surviving eldest daughter serves as a witness against Diane. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
-
Diane's Account Challenged — The prosecution challenges Diane's claim about an unknown assailant. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
-
Song Evidence Introduced — The prosecution plays Duran Duran's song for the jury. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
-
Motivation Argument — The prosecution uses Diane's song choice to argue motivation. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
-
Murder Charge Considered — The trial considers Diane's responsibility for the fatal shooting. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
-
Attempted Murder Charge — The case also addresses the shooting of the surviving children. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
Verdict And Consequences
The prosecution plays Duran Duran's song to argue that Diane's choice of music demonstrated motivation. Diane is convicted of murder and attempted murder.
Key Events
-
Attempted Murder Charge — The case also addresses the shooting of the surviving children. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
-
Guilty Verdict — Diane is convicted of murder and attempted murder. Characters: Diane Downs, Frank Joziak
Location: Court
-
Life Imprisonment — Diane receives a life sentence in prison. Characters: Diane Downs
Location: Court
-
Surviving Children Need Placement — The two surviving children require a new family after the case. Characters: Frank Joziak
Location: Oregon
-
Adoption By Prosecutor — Frank Joziak and his wife adopt Diane's two surviving children. Characters: Frank Joziak
Location: Oregon
A peculiar and disturbing case catches the attention of the police when a young mother and her children, all severely injured, show up in a hospital's emergency room.