Plot Analysis Summary
A musician abandons his career after a family crisis and regains his artistic voice through persistence, family encouragement, and friendship.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Cornet Finds Its Band
Red moves to New York and finds work with Wil Paradise. He then forms The Five Pennies with several musician friends and reaches a peak of popularity.
Key Events
-
Red Moves to New York — Red Nichols leaves his small town and seeks work as a cornet player in New York. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: New York City
-
Work in Paradise's Band — Red finds work in the band led by Wil Paradise. Characters: Red Nichols, Wil Paradise
Location: New York City
-
The Five Pennies Form — Red and his musician friends form their own Dixieland band. Characters: Red Nichols, Jimmy Dorsey, Glenn Miller, Artie Schutt, Dave Tough
Location: New York City
-
The Band Gains Popularity — The Five Pennies become increasingly popular. Characters: Red Nichols, Jimmy Dorsey, Glenn Miller, Artie Schutt, Dave Tough
Location: Performance venue
The Horn Falls Silent
Dorothy contracts polio, devastating Red and changing the family's future. Red throws his treasured horn into San Francisco Bay, and the family leaves the music business.
Key Events
-
Dorothy Contracts Polio — Red's young daughter contracts polio, devastating the family. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Nichols family home
-
Red Throws Away His Horn — Overwhelmed by the illness, Red throws his treasured horn into the bay. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: San Francisco Bay
-
The Family Leaves Music — The family leaves the music business and moves to Los Angeles. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Los Angeles
Learning to Play Again
In Los Angeles, Red works in the shipyards while the family supports Dorothy's recovery. Dorothy later learns about Red's career and persuades him to attempt a comeback.
Key Events
-
Red Works in Shipyards — Red works in the shipyards while the family supports Dorothy's recovery. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Los Angeles shipyards
-
Dorothy Learns Red's Past — As a teenager, Dorothy learns about her father's former music career. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Los Angeles
-
A Comeback Is Proposed — Dorothy persuades Red to attempt a musical comeback. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Nichols family home
-
The First Attempts Fail — Red's first attempts to play again are miserable failures. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Los Angeles
-
Red Resumes Practice — After listening to his family, Red practices until his skill returns. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Los Angeles
The New Five Pennies
Red's early attempts to play are failures, but practice restores his skill. Tony Valani then secures a small-club performance for the newly named New Five Pennies.
Key Events
-
Tony Arranges a Gig — Red's old friend Tony Valani secures him a small-club performance. Characters: Red Nichols, Tony Valani
Location: Los Angeles club
-
The New Five Pennies — Red prepares to perform with a group he names the New Five Pennies. Characters: Red Nichols, Tony Valani
Location: Small club
-
Red Faces the Empty Audience — Red is disappointed when he sees none of his old friends in the audience. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Small club
-
The Comeback Begins — Red nervously opens the show despite fearing that he will split his lip. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Small club stage
A Reunion in Music
Red begins the comeback show in fear, believing his old friends are absent. Louis Armstrong and the others appear, and the final performance becomes a joyful family and musical reunion.
Key Events
-
The Comeback Begins — Red nervously opens the show despite fearing that he will split his lip. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Small club stage
-
Louis Appears — Louis Armstrong and Red's friends are revealed when the lights come up. Characters: Red Nichols, Louis Armstrong
Location: Small club
-
A Surprise on the Floor — A surprise brings Dorothy onto the dance floor without her cane. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Small club dance floor
-
The Family Dance — Dorothy asks Red to dance while the song about the little penny is sung. Characters: Red Nichols
Location: Small club dance floor
-
Glory Hallelujah Reunion — Red plays Glory Hallelujah as Louis and his friends join the musical reunion. Characters: Red Nichols, Louis Armstrong, Jimmy Dorsey, Glenn Miller, Artie Schutt, Dave Tough
Location: Small club stage