Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
The Refused Defense
Masao is arrested for Kiku Watanabe's robbery and murder while insisting he is innocent. Kiriko seeks Otsuka's help, but he refuses, and Keiichi Abe's attempt to help does not prevent Masao's conviction.
Key Events
-
Masao Arrested — Masao is arrested for the robbery and murder of moneylender Kiku Watanabe. Characters: Masao Yanagida, Kiku Watanabe
Location: Unspecified
-
Masao Maintains His Innocence — Masao insists he did not commit the crime, although the evidence appears convincing. Characters: Masao Yanagida
Location: Unspecified
-
Kiriko Seeks Otsuka — Kiriko travels to Tokyo and begs Otsuka to defend Masao. Characters: Kiriko Yanagida, Kinzo Otsuka
Location: Tokyo
-
Otsuka Refuses the Case — Otsuka declines, citing his workload and the high cost. Characters: Kiriko Yanagida, Kinzo Otsuka
Location: Tokyo
-
Abe Tries to Help — Journalist Keiichi Abe tries to help with Masao's case. Characters: Keiichi Abe, Masao Yanagida
Location: Unspecified
-
Masao Is Convicted — Masao is convicted despite insisting he is innocent. Characters: Masao Yanagida
Location: Unspecified
A Death Without Appeal
Masao dies in prison while his appeal is pending. Kiriko is left with the knowledge that her brother died branded a murderer.
Key Events
-
Masao Dies in Prison — Masao dies in prison while his appeal is pending. Characters: Masao Yanagida
Location: Prison
-
Kiriko Bears the Loss — Kiriko is left knowing her brother died branded a murderer. Characters: Kiriko Yanagida, Masao Yanagida
Location: Unspecified
The Left-Handed Clue
Years later, Otsuka studies Masao's case records and finds inconsistencies in the wounds. He concludes that the actual killer was left-handed, as a hotel manager is arrested for Kenji Sugiura's murder.
Key Events
-
Otsuka Reopens the Case — Years later, Otsuka studies the records from Masao's case. Characters: Kinzo Otsuka, Masao Yanagida
Location: Unspecified
-
Wounds Suggest a Left-Handed Killer — Otsuka finds inconsistencies in the wounds and concludes the killer was left-handed. Characters: Kinzo Otsuka, Masao Yanagida
Location: Unspecified
-
Manager Arrested for Sugiura Murder — A hotel manager is arrested for Kenji Sugiura's murder; Kiriko was at the scene. Characters: Kenji Sugiura, Kiriko Yanagida
Location: Unspecified
-
Kiriko Conceals What She Saw — Kiriko denies knowing the manager and hides what she saw and a key lighter. Characters: Kiriko Yanagida
Location: Unspecified
The Hidden Lighter
Kiriko conceals what she saw at the scene and a key lighter, despite having promised to testify for the manager. Otsuka connects the murders and hopes the lighter can help the manager and illuminate Masao's case.
Key Events
-
Otsuka Connects the Murders — Otsuka believes the two murders were committed by the same left-handed person. Characters: Kinzo Otsuka, Masao Yanagida, Kenji Sugiura
Location: Unspecified
-
Abe Challenges Kiriko's Silence — Abe warns Kiriko that her silence could condemn another innocent person. Characters: Keiichi Abe, Kiriko Yanagida
Location: Unspecified
-
Kiriko Agrees to Help — After Otsuka pleads with her, Kiriko agrees to give him the lighter and testify. Characters: Kiriko Yanagida, Kinzo Otsuka
Location: Unspecified
An Unresolved Accusation
Abe warns Kiriko that her silence could condemn another innocent person, and she agrees to provide the lighter and testify. She later accuses Otsuka before the prosecutor, and the transcript ends with the manager's case and Otsuka's consequences uncertain.
Key Events
-
Kiriko Accuses Otsuka — Kiriko tells the prosecutor Otsuka pressured her to lie and sexually assaulted her. Characters: Kiriko Yanagida, Kinzo Otsuka, Prosecutor
Location: Unspecified
-
Otsuka Does Not Defend Himself — When confronted with Kiriko's account, Otsuka offers no defense. Characters: Kinzo Otsuka, Prosecutor
Location: Unspecified
-
Outcome Remains Uncertain — After weeks without news of Kiriko, the manager's case and Otsuka's consequences remain unresolved. Characters: Kiriko Yanagida, Kinzo Otsuka
Location: Unspecified