Plot Analysis Summary
Ernie Davis rises from a difficult childhood to athletic greatness while confronting racial exclusion, threats, illness, and an early death.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
From Family Roots to Football
Ernie grows up in Pennsylvania under the guidance of Willie 'Pops' Davis. After relocating to Elmira, he discovers exceptional talent as a running back and leads his school to a state championship.
Key Events
-
Childhood in Pennsylvania — Ernie grows up with extended family and receives guidance from his maternal grandfather. Characters: Ernie Davis, Willie 'Pops' Davis
Location: Pennsylvania
-
Family Relocation — Ernie relocates to Elmira after his mother remarries and can raise him there. Characters: Ernie Davis
Location: Pennsylvania
-
Small Fry Football — Ernie enrolls in a Small Fry Football League and excels as a running back. Characters: Ernie Davis
Location: Elmira
-
State Championship Rise — Ernie leads Elmira Free Academy to a state championship. Characters: Ernie Davis
Location: Elmira Free Academy
The Syracuse Calling
Ben Schwartzwalder identifies Ernie as the answer to Syracuse's need for a new running back. With Jim Brown assisting the recruiting visit, Ernie commits to Syracuse and begins his varsity career.
Key Events
-
Recruiting Search — Schwartzwalder studies Ernie's footage while seeking a running back after Brown's senior season. Characters: Ben Schwartzwalder, Jim Brown
Location: Syracuse University
-
Recruiting Visit — Schwartzwalder and Brown visit Ernie and his family to recruit him to Syracuse. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder, Jim Brown
Location: Elmira
-
Syracuse Commitment — Ernie accepts the recruiting effort and commits to Syracuse. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Elmira
-
Varsity Breakthrough — Ernie excels for Syracuse's varsity team at the beginning of the 1959 season. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Syracuse University
The Threatened Championship
Ernie helps Syracuse complete an undefeated regular season and reach the Cotton Bowl. Threatening letters create a grave danger, but Ernie and Schwartzwalder refuse to let the threats keep him from playing.
Key Events
-
Winning Regular Season — Ernie helps Syracuse win several games during an undefeated regular season. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: College football stadiums
-
UCLA Victory — Syracuse defeats UCLA and completes the regular season undefeated. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: College football stadium
-
Cotton Bowl Decision — The team chooses to face the second-ranked Texas Longhorns in the Cotton Bowl. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Syracuse University
-
Threatening Letters — University officials receive threats against Ernie if he plays in the Cotton Bowl. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Syracuse University
-
Defying the Threats — Ernie and Schwartzwalder defy the threats and proceed with the game. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Cotton Bowl Stadium
A Victory Against Resistance
Despite an injured leg and biased officiating, Ernie scores the decisive touchdown against Texas. Syracuse wins its first national championship, and the team responds to Ernie's exclusion from the banquet with solidarity.
Key Events
-
Injured Bowl Performance — Ernie attempts to lead Syracuse despite an injured leg and biased officiating. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Cotton Bowl Stadium
-
Championship Touchdown — Ernie scores a crucial touchdown that preserves Syracuse's lead. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Cotton Bowl Stadium
-
National Championship — Syracuse defeats Texas and wins its first national championship. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Cotton Bowl Stadium
-
Banquet Solidarity — When Ernie and some teammates are excluded, the Syracuse team leaves in solidarity. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Postgame banquet
Fame, Illness, and Farewell
Ernie wins the Heisman Trophy and signs with the Cleveland Browns, but health concerns lead to a leukemia diagnosis. His coach and professional team honor him before the epilogue records his death at twenty-three.
Key Events
-
Heisman Trophy — In 1961, Ernie wins the Heisman Trophy after his senior college season. Characters: Ernie Davis
Location: New York
-
Professional Contract — Ernie becomes a professional athlete and signs with the Cleveland Browns. Characters: Ernie Davis
Location: Cleveland
-
Medical Testing — Health concerns lead Ernie to the hospital for medical testing. Characters: Ernie Davis
Location: Hospital
-
Leukemia Announcement — Ernie announces publicly that he has been diagnosed with leukemia. Characters: Ernie Davis
Location: Press conference
-
Recruiting Trip — Schwartzwalder asks Ernie to join a recruiting trip after his diagnosis. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Recruiting visit
-
Final Team Honor — The Cleveland Browns let Ernie suit up and run out with the team before a televised game. Characters: Ernie Davis
Location: Cleveland Browns stadium
-
Syracuse Decision — Schwartzwalder tells Ernie that the highly regarded prospect has chosen Syracuse. Characters: Ernie Davis, Ben Schwartzwalder
Location: Cleveland Browns stadium
-
Death at Twenty-Three — The epilogue states that Ernie died on May 18, 1963, at age twenty-three. Characters: Ernie Davis
Location: United States