Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
The Verdict Without Certainty
Kim Seok Hyeon presides over a murder trial involving a missing woman. He issues a not-guilty verdict because the prosecution cannot prove that she is dead, provoking public outrage.
Key Events
-
Murder Trial Opens — A defendant is tried for killing a woman who disappeared two years earlier. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon
Location: Courtroom
-
Proof of Death Missing — The court cannot convict because there is no proof that the missing woman is dead. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon
Location: Courtroom
-
Not Guilty Verdict — Kim Seok Hyeon announces a not-guilty verdict despite evidence suggesting guilt. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon
Location: Courtroom
-
Public Outrage — The verdict causes public outrage, while Kim defends objective certainty. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon
Location: Public and judicial sphere
-
Judicial Responsibility Grows — Kim Seok Hyeon takes on greater judicial responsibility after the controversial verdict. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Court Chief
Location: Judicial office
The Pattern of Parallel Lives
Kim discusses parallel lives with Bae Yun Kyeong, then confronts the death of professor Shon Gi-cheol. Medical findings and matching dates make the theory personally threatening.
Key Events
-
Parallel Lives Discussed — Kim and Bae discuss the theory that unrelated people may share similar life patterns. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Bae Yun Kyeong
Location: Private discussion setting
-
Professor Found Dead — Professor Shon Gi-cheol is found dead after writing about parallel lives. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Shon Gi-cheol
Location: Shon Gi-cheol's residence
-
Death Cause Examined — The examination concludes that Shon died from malnutrition and starvation at seven in the morning. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Shon Gi-cheol
Location: Medical examination setting
-
Parallel Pattern Recognized — Kim realizes that crucial dates may align through an apparent time difference. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Shon Gi-cheol
Location: Judicial office
-
Threatening Call — Kim Seok Hyeon receives a threatening call after recognizing the parallel pattern. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon
Location: Kim Seok Hyeon's residence
Records Beneath the Verdict
After receiving a threat, Kim examines Han Sang-joon's old family-murder case. Contradictory records, a possible escape, and Jeong Min Soo's death expose weaknesses in the official narrative.
Key Events
-
Family Comes Under Threat — The danger extends from Kim Seok Hyeon to his own family. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Kim Ye-jin
Location: Kim Seok Hyeon's home
-
Old Case Reopened — Kim investigates the old case involving Han Sang-joon's murdered family. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Han Sang-joon
Location: Judicial records office
-
Records Contradict Official Story — Contradictory arrest dates and mismatched evidence undermine the accepted account. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Han Sang-joon
Location: Records office
-
Former Detective Explains Escape — A former detective suggests that the official suspect may have escaped custody. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Detective Bae
Location: Investigation setting
-
Aide Listed Among Victims — Kim learns that Han's aide, Jeong Min Soo, was among the victims. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Han Sang-joon, Jeong Min Soo
Location: Case investigation setting
The Judicial Cover-Up
Crime-scene evidence conflicts with the accepted account of the murders. Kim accuses former prosecutor Lee Kang-seong of fabricating a verdict to protect the judiciary.
Key Events
-
Crime Scene Evidence Conflicts — Evidence suggests Han was strangled while other victims suffered gunshot wounds. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Han Sang-joon
Location: Crime scene records
-
Official Suspect Questioned — The differing injuries make the official suspect an unlikely killer. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Han Sang-joon
Location: Investigation setting
-
Judicial Cover-Up Alleged — Kim accuses Lee Kang-seong of fabricating the verdict to protect judicial reputation. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Lee Kang-seong, Han Sang-joon
Location: Judicial office
Danger at the Home
Kim Ye-jin is placed in danger at Kim's home, while a detective reports that Jang Soo Yeong was seen nearby. The available account ends before the confrontation is resolved.
Key Events
-
Kim Ye-jin Placed In Danger — Kim Ye-jin is placed in danger at Kim Seok Hyeon's home. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Kim Ye-jin, Jang Soo Yeong
Location: Kim Seok Hyeon's home
-
Detective Reports Nearby Sighting — The Detective reports that Jang Soo Yeong was seen nearby before the account ends. Characters: Kim Seok Hyeon, Kim Ye-jin, Jang Soo Yeong, Detective Bae
Location: Outside Kim Seok Hyeon's home
A young man finds out that he is living a completely identical life to another man who lived decades ago. And when his wife is murdered the same way as the previous man's, he decides to dig into the older case to find clues about who was the murderer this time.