Plot Analysis Summary
A legal drama exploring justice, familial duty, and the pursuit of truth through a wrongful murder accusation.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
The Bomsite Tragedy
A young girl's disappearance and subsequent murder at an abandoned bomsite trigger a police investigation. Circumstantial evidence quickly implicates a local taxi driver, setting the legal machinery in motion.
Key Events
-
Bomsite Encounter — A young girl leads a taxi driver to a bomsite, taunting him before running off. Characters: Peter Tanner
Location: Abandoned bombsite
-
Murder Discovery — The girl is found murdered while singing, witnessed by a local resident. Characters: Geoffrey Tanner
Location: Bomb-site
-
Police Interrogation — The taxi driver is questioned and arrested based on circumstantial evidence. Characters: Peter Tanner
Location: Scotland Yard
Legal Mobilization
The accused's wife struggles to find representation until junior counsel Peter Tanner takes the case. Peter visits the imprisoned driver, believes his innocence, and prepares for the upcoming trial.
Key Events
-
Police Interrogation — The taxi driver is questioned and arrested based on circumstantial evidence. Characters: Peter Tanner
Location: Scotland Yard
-
Legal Mobilization — The driver's wife seeks legal help, eventually winning the sympathy of junior counsel Peter Tanner. Characters: Peter Tanner
Location: Law office
-
Defense Acceptance — Peter Tanner visits the accused, believes his innocence, and takes the case. Characters: Peter Tanner
Location: Prison
-
Trial Commencement — The trial begins with Peter Tanner opposing his father, Geoffrey Tanner, as prosecuting counsel. Characters: Peter Tanner, Geoffrey Tanner
Location: Old Bailey
-
Defender's Resolve — Peter Tanner commits fully to the defense after verifying the accused's protestations. Characters: Peter Tanner
Location: Prison
Courtroom Confrontation
The trial begins at the Old Bailey with Peter Tanner opposing his father, Geoffrey Tanner. The prosecution presents strong circumstantial evidence, swaying jurors and putting the defense on the back foot.
Key Events
-
Trial Commencement — The trial begins with Peter Tanner opposing his father, Geoffrey Tanner, as prosecuting counsel. Characters: Peter Tanner, Geoffrey Tanner
Location: Old Bailey
-
Prosecution Strategy — Geoffrey Tanner presents circumstantial evidence, swaying jurors toward guilt. Characters: Geoffrey Tanner
Location: Old Bailey
-
Witness Testimony — Prosecution witness Horace Clifford testifies, strengthening the case against the defendant. Characters: Horace Clifford
Location: Old Bailey
-
Juror Reactions — Jurors express belief in guilt early, increasing pressure on the defense. Characters: Peter Tanner, Geoffrey Tanner
Location: Old Bailey
-
Recess Investigation — During a recess, Peter Tanner observes Clifford giving a sweet to a young girl. Characters: Peter Tanner, Horace Clifford
Location: Courthouse exterior
-
Prosecution Confidence — Geoffrey Tanner expresses confidence in the prosecution's case before the recess. Characters: Geoffrey Tanner
Location: Old Bailey
Truth and Redemption
During a recess, Peter Tanner discovers a critical flaw in the prosecution's witness testimony. He uses a strategic cross-examination and a musical cue to break the witness, leading to the defendant's acquittal.
Key Events
-
Recess Investigation — During a recess, Peter Tanner observes Clifford giving a sweet to a young girl. Characters: Peter Tanner, Horace Clifford
Location: Courthouse exterior
-
Sweet Identification — Peter identifies the sweet as identical to the one found on the victim. Characters: Peter Tanner
Location: Courthouse exterior
-
Musical Setup — Peter instructs a street musician to play 'Oranges and Lemons' to trigger Clifford's memory. Characters: Peter Tanner, Horace Clifford
Location: Old Bailey
-
Cross-Examination — Peter Tanner confronts Clifford with the sweets during intense cross-examination. Characters: Peter Tanner, Horace Clifford
Location: Old Bailey
-
Psychological Breakdown — Clifford breaks down under pressure, admitting his role in the evidence chain. Characters: Peter Tanner, Horace Clifford
Location: Old Bailey
-
Verdict Announced — The court clears the accused following Clifford's collapse and retracted testimony. Characters: Peter Tanner, Geoffrey Tanner
Location: Old Bailey
-
Family Reunion — The acquitted driver is reunited with his wife, marking the story's emotional conclusion. Characters: Peter Tanner
Location: Courthouse steps
-
Legal Reflection — Peter and Geoffrey reflect on the trial's outcome, acknowledging the complexity of justice. Characters: Peter Tanner, Geoffrey Tanner
Location: Law chambers
-
Evidence Chain Broken — The prosecution's physical evidence is invalidated when Clifford's testimony collapses. Characters: Horace Clifford
Location: Old Bailey
-
Witness Tracking — Peter Tanner follows Clifford outside the courthouse to observe his behavior firsthand. Characters: Peter Tanner, Horace Clifford
Location: London streets
-
Case Resolution — The trial concludes with the defendant cleared, resolving the legal and familial tensions. Characters: Peter Tanner, Geoffrey Tanner, Horace Clifford
Location: Old Bailey
Only a British cabdriver's (Richard Attenborough) wife (Cathy O'Donnell) and lawyer (Derek Farr) believe him innocent of killing a little girl.