Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
The Disfigured Victim
A woman is shot at the remote cottage, and Inspector Gregory begins investigating. The damaged face makes identification immediately uncertain.
Key Events
-
Rosehill Cottage — The remote cottage is established as the murder scene.
Location: Remote Surrey cottage
-
Shotgun Murder Reported — A woman is murdered by two shotgun blasts at the cottage. Characters: Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Gregory Takes the Case — Inspector Gregory is called in to investigate the killing. Characters: Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Body Found Disfigured — The two blasts leave the victim's face badly disfigured. Characters: Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Victim Appears To Be Ann — The murdered woman appears to be Ann Rogers. Characters: Inspector Gregory, Howard Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Howard Examines the Body — Howard looks for a physical mark that could identify his wife. Characters: Howard Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage
The Missing Birthmark
Howard examines the body for a birthmark that could establish whether it is Ann. The missing mark disrupts the first identification and strengthens suspicion around Howard.
Key Events
-
Howard Examines the Body — Howard looks for a physical mark that could identify his wife. Characters: Howard Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Birthmark Evidence — Howard expects a birthmark to prove the body's identity. Characters: Howard Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Birthmark Is Missing — The expected birthmark is not present on the body. Characters: Howard Rogers, Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Howard Becomes Chief Suspect — Gregory initially considers Howard the chief murder suspect. Characters: Inspector Gregory, Howard Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Howard's Alibi Investigated — Gregory examines Howard's alibi against the murder accusation. Characters: Inspector Gregory, Howard Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Alibi Clears Howard — Howard's alibi proves that he is innocent of the murder. Characters: Inspector Gregory, Howard Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage
Ann Returns
Howard's alibi clears him, but Ann's sudden appearance creates a sharper identity mystery. Gregory must reconsider the relationship between the living woman and the dead body.
Key Events
-
Alibi Clears Howard — Howard's alibi proves that he is innocent of the murder. Characters: Inspector Gregory, Howard Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Ann Suddenly Appears — Ann suddenly appears while the victim's identity remains uncertain. Characters: Ann Rogers, Howard Rogers, Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Identity Mystery Deepens — Ann's appearance makes the identity of the murdered woman more doubtful. Characters: Ann Rogers, Howard Rogers, Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Missing Friend Becomes Relevant — A missing friend becomes important to identifying the dead woman. Characters: Inspector Gregory, Ann Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Search Broadens — The investigation expands beyond the initial murder-suspect theory. Characters: Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Ann's Motives Questioned — Ann's motivations become suspect during the investigation. Characters: Ann Rogers, Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
The Hidden Truth
The investigation broadens as Ann's motives become suspect and a missing friend becomes relevant. The case centers on which woman knows the truth.
Key Events
-
Ann's Motives Questioned — Ann's motivations become suspect during the investigation. Characters: Ann Rogers, Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
One Woman Knows the Truth — The investigation suggests that one of the women knows what happened. Characters: Ann Rogers, Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Identity Evidence Reconsidered — The conflicting evidence forces the identity question to be reconsidered. Characters: Ann Rogers, Howard Rogers, Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Truth Remains Concealed — The central truth remains tied to the women's hidden knowledge. Characters: Ann Rogers, Inspector Gregory
Location: Rosehill Cottage
-
Unresolved Identity Question — The case closes around the unresolved identity of the murdered woman. Characters: Inspector Gregory, Ann Rogers, Howard Rogers
Location: Rosehill Cottage