Plot Analysis Summary
A grieving father's violent mission forces a defense attorney to confront justice, political corruption, and his own hidden wrongdoing.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Family Breaks Apart
Roy is introduced through a criminal bail argument before witnessing the Fertig family's distress. Stevie's death destroys the family and leaves Harry searching for religious meaning.
Key Events
-
Bail Argument for Misconduct — Roy argues for reduced bail for a police lieutenant accused of misconduct. Characters: Roy Bleakie
Location: Courtroom
-
Corruption Record Exposed — The prosecutor cites the lieutenant's dismissal for bribes and arrest with cocaine and cash. Characters: Roy Bleakie
Location: Courtroom
-
Family Under Strain — Roy sees Harry and Sarah struggling as Stevie suffers from a persistent fever. Characters: Roy Bleakie, Harry Fertig, Sarah Fertig, Stevie Fertig
Location: Fertig home
-
Stevie's Persistent Fever — Stevie remains ill while Harry and Sarah face growing fear and helplessness. Characters: Harry Fertig, Sarah Fertig, Stevie Fertig
Location: Fertig home
-
Stevie Dies — Stevie dies, and the loss destroys Harry and Sarah's family. Characters: Harry Fertig, Sarah Fertig, Stevie Fertig
Location: Hospital
A Command in Grief
Harry interprets Stevie's death as a divine command to correct a terrible wrong. His refusal of hospital treatment culminates in shootings and surrender.
Key Events
-
Harry Finds Divine Meaning — Harry becomes convinced that the tragedy commands him to correct a terrible wrong. Characters: Harry Fertig
Location: Fertig home
-
Refusing Hospital Treatment — Harry refuses to accept the hospital staff's treatment of Stevie. Characters: Harry Fertig, Sarah Fertig
Location: Clement Hospital
-
Clement Hospital Shooting — Harry shoots a clerk, a nurse, and a doctor at Clement Hospital. Characters: Harry Fertig
Location: Clement Hospital
-
Harry Surrenders — After the shootings, Harry surrenders to authorities. Characters: Harry Fertig
Location: Clement Hospital
The Defense Takes Shape
Jack hires Roy to defend Harry and presses for an insanity argument. Roy finds that grief, religious conviction, and Harry's public strategy make the case unusually complex.
Key Events
-
Jack Requests Representation — Jack asks Roy to defend Harry and offers a large retainer. Characters: Jack Renoble, Roy Bleakie, Harry Fertig
Location: Roy's office
-
Insanity Defense Proposed — Jack expects Roy to argue that Harry is not guilty by reason of insanity. Characters: Jack Renoble, Roy Bleakie, Harry Fertig
Location: Roy's office
-
Grief Complicates the Case — Roy recognizes that Harry's grief and religious conviction complicate the seemingly straightforward case. Characters: Roy Bleakie, Harry Fertig
Location: Interview room
-
Harry Uses the Trial — Harry deliberately uses the trial to attract public attention. Characters: Harry Fertig, Roy Bleakie
Location: Interview room
-
Sarah Explains Harry's Withdrawal — Sarah says Harry withdrew after Stevie's death and no longer knows how to be her husband. Characters: Sarah Fertig, Roy Bleakie
Location: Fertig home
Contracts Beneath the Water
Roy secures testimony about Harry's journey while uncovering a political scheme involving Jack, water deterioration, and a proposed filtration plant. Suspicious payments connect the legal case to wider corruption.
Key Events
-
Cabbie Agrees to Testify — A cabbie agrees to testify about Harry's journey from the hospital. Characters: Roy Bleakie
Location: Taxi
-
Filtration Plant Scheme — Roy discovers a political scheme linking water deterioration to a lucrative public contract. Characters: Jack Renoble, Roy Bleakie
Location: Business office
-
Suspicious Payments Questioned — Roy questions an associate about suspicious payments and the Zarus group. Characters: Roy Bleakie, Jack Renoble
Location: Business office
The Moral Reckoning
Harry reveals Roy's sexual relationship with Sarah, forcing Roy to confront his own wrongdoing. Harry's note and final request leave the story's resolution uncertain.
Key Events
-
Roy's Affair Revealed — Harry reveals that Roy slept with Sarah, transforming the legal case into a personal moral crisis. Characters: Harry Fertig, Roy Bleakie, Sarah Fertig
Location: Interview room
-
Harry's Suicide Note — Harry's note tells Roy that he must confront his own wrongdoing and define the right action. Characters: Harry Fertig, Roy Bleakie
Location: Interview room
-
Harry Makes a Final Request — Harry asks Roy to do something for him, but the available events do not reveal the final resolution. Characters: Harry Fertig, Roy Bleakie
Location: Interview room