Plot Analysis Summary
A student-teacher relationship becomes emotionally complicated through bullying, romantic feeling, protection, and repressed trauma.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
An Expatriate Meets a Student
Maurice is introduced as a gay French expatriate living in North Bay, Ontario. He takes a job tutoring Allan in French, establishing the film's central student-teacher relationship.
Key Events
-
Maurice Lives in North Bay — Maurice is introduced as a gay French expatriate living in North Bay. Characters: Maurice Lesmers
Location: North Bay, Ontario
-
Maurice Seeks Tutoring Work — Maurice takes a job tutoring a high school student in French. Characters: Maurice Lesmers
Location: North Bay, Ontario
-
Allan Enters the Story — Maurice begins tutoring Allan in French. Characters: Maurice Lesmers, Allan
Location: Tutoring setting
-
French Lessons Begin — The student-teacher relationship develops through French tutoring. Characters: Maurice Lesmers, Allan
Location: Tutoring setting
Protection Against Bullying
Allan faces bullying at school because he is gay. Maurice becomes drawn to protecting and defending him, giving their tutoring relationship a stronger emotional charge.
Key Events
-
Allan Faces School Bullying — Allan faces bullying at school because he is gay. Characters: Allan
Location: High school
-
Maurice Protects Allan — Maurice is drawn to protect and defend Allan from school bullying. Characters: Maurice Lesmers, Allan
Location: High school
-
Trust Grows Between Them — Tutoring becomes complicated by Maurice's protective concern for Allan. Characters: Maurice Lesmers, Allan
Location: Tutoring setting
-
Maurice Auditions for The Miser — Maurice auditions for a stage production of Moliere's The Miser. Characters: Maurice Lesmers
Location: Stage audition setting
Love Complicates the Bond
Maurice continues auditioning for a production of Moliere's The Miser while his relationship with Allan grows more complicated. Allan's romantic feelings transform the meaning of their student-teacher connection.
Key Events
-
Maurice Auditions for The Miser — Maurice auditions for a stage production of Moliere's The Miser. Characters: Maurice Lesmers
Location: Stage audition setting
-
Two Personal Pressures Intersect — Maurice's theatrical ambitions coexist with his growing involvement in Allan's life. Characters: Maurice Lesmers, Allan
Location: North Bay, Ontario
-
Allan Falls in Love — Allan falls in love with Maurice. Characters: Allan, Maurice Lesmers
Location: Tutoring setting
-
The Student-Teacher Bond Changes — Allan's love complicates the boundaries of their student-teacher relationship. Characters: Maurice Lesmers, Allan
Location: Tutoring setting
Repressed Memories Surface
Allan's love triggers Maurice's repressed memories of childhood sexual abuse. The film's central relationship becomes a confrontation between present emotional demands and Maurice's unresolved past.
Key Events
-
Maurice Remembers Childhood Abuse — Allan's feelings trigger Maurice's repressed memories of childhood sexual abuse. Characters: Maurice Lesmers
Location: Maurice's personal setting
-
Past Trauma Enters the Present — Maurice's unresolved childhood trauma becomes part of the relationship's emotional conflict. Characters: Maurice Lesmers, Allan
Location: North Bay, Ontario
-
Protection Meets Emotional Boundaries — Maurice's wish to defend Allan is placed alongside Allan's romantic feelings and Maurice's trauma. Characters: Maurice Lesmers, Allan
Location: North Bay, Ontario
-
Their Complicated Bond Remains Central — The film's central bond is defined by tutoring, protection, love, and trauma. Characters: Maurice Lesmers, Allan
Location: North Bay, Ontario
What We Have is is the tale of Maurice, a prisoner of his past who is unable to connect with the people in his new Northern Canadian small town, a community that is only too ready to welcome this European misfit into their arms.