Plot Analysis Summary
The story examines how legal accountability confronts denial, narcissism, and public indifference to organized evil.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
The Tribunal Takes Shape
Göring's surrender prompts a plan for an international tribunal. Legal uncertainty and political resistance surround the effort, but support is gradually secured.
Key Events
-
Göring Surrenders — Hermann Göring surrenders to U.S. forces with his family. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Austria
-
Tribunal Proposal — Elsie Douglas discusses the uncertain legal basis for an international tribunal. Characters: Elsie Douglas
Location: United States government office
-
Moral Support Secured — Political support is pursued for an international war-crimes tribunal. Characters: Pope Pius XII
Location: Rome
-
Kelley Reaches Mondorf — Douglas Kelley arrives to assess detained Nazi leaders. Characters: Douglas Kelley
Location: Bad Mondorf, Luxembourg
-
First Göring Interview — Kelley conducts a civil initial interview with Göring. Characters: Douglas Kelley, Hermann Göring
Location: Bad Mondorf prison
Inside the Prison Cells
Kelley begins psychiatric evaluations in Bad Mondorf and develops an unusually warm rapport with Göring. Göring cooperates selectively when personal privileges are at stake.
Key Events
-
First Göring Interview — Kelley conducts a civil initial interview with Göring. Characters: Douglas Kelley, Hermann Göring
Location: Bad Mondorf prison
-
Prisoner Contempt — Streicher reacts with contempt during the prison assessments. Characters: Douglas Kelley, Julius Streicher
Location: Bad Mondorf prison
-
Göring's Narcissism — Kelley appraises Göring as intelligent and highly narcissistic. Characters: Douglas Kelley, Hermann Göring
Location: Bad Mondorf prison
-
Hess Examination — Göring helps Kelley examine Hess in exchange for correspondence privileges. Characters: Douglas Kelley, Hermann Göring, Rudolf Hess
Location: Bad Mondorf prison
-
Family Correspondence — Kelley acts as a courier for Göring's family correspondence. Characters: Douglas Kelley, Hermann Göring
Location: Bad Mondorf prison
-
Nuremberg Tribunal Opens — The International Military Tribunal formally charges the detainees. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
Evidence Against Denial
The tribunal opens, but the proceedings are shaken by suicide, hostile prisoners, and devastating footage of concentration-camp atrocities. Kelley's trust in Göring collapses.
Key Events
-
Nuremberg Tribunal Opens — The International Military Tribunal formally charges the detainees. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
-
Prisoner Suicide — A detained Nazi leader commits suicide before the trial begins.
Location: Bad Mondorf prison cell
-
Opening Statement — The prosecution argues that the tribunal must establish accountability. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
-
Not Guilty Pleas — Göring and the other prisoners plead not guilty. Characters: Hermann Göring, Julius Streicher
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
-
Camp Footage Shown — Atrocity footage causes Kelley to confront Göring's denials. Characters: Douglas Kelley, Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
-
Kelley Leaks Discussions — While drunk, Kelley reveals private discussions that are published. Characters: Douglas Kelley
Location: Nuremberg
-
Kelley Is Relieved — Kelley is relieved from duty and ordered to leave. Characters: Douglas Kelley
Location: Nuremberg detention complex
The Mind Behind The Defense
After losing his position, Kelley chooses to submit his notes to the prosecution. Göring then uses the courtroom to deny or redefine the regime's crimes.
Key Events
-
Kelley Is Relieved — Kelley is relieved from duty and ordered to leave. Characters: Douglas Kelley
Location: Nuremberg detention complex
-
Notes Reach Prosecutors — Kelley submits his private notes to the prosecution. Characters: Douglas Kelley
Location: Nuremberg prosecution office
-
Göring Takes the Stand — Göring uses his testimony to defend the regime's conduct. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
-
Final Solution Claim — Göring claims his decree concerned emigration rather than extermination. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
-
Vanity Exposed — A cross-examination exploits Göring's vanity and exposes his loyalty to the regime. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
-
Death Sentence — Göring is sentenced to death by hanging. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
Judgment And Aftermath
Göring receives a death sentence but avoids the gallows through suicide, while other executions proceed. Kelley returns home traumatized and spends the rest of his life warning against political indifference.
Key Events
-
Death Sentence — Göring is sentenced to death by hanging. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg courtroom
-
Cyanide Suicide — Göring ingests cyanide the night before his scheduled execution. Characters: Hermann Göring
Location: Nuremberg prison cell
-
Streicher's Execution — Streicher suffers a breakdown and must be weighed down on the noose. Characters: Julius Streicher
Location: Nuremberg prison gallows
-
Kelley Publishes Memoir — Kelley publishes a tell-all account but struggles to promote it. Characters: Douglas Kelley
Location: United States
-
Kelley's Final Decline — Traumatized and alcoholic, Kelley dies by cyanide suicide in 1958. Characters: Douglas Kelley
Location: United States