Plot Analysis Summary
A poor teenager enters Dutch Schultz's criminal world, witnesses its violence, and survives its final collapse under Luciano's authority.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Door Into Power
Dutch draws a poor teenager into his organization and presents criminal life as a route to success. Billy witnesses Dutch's violent treatment of suspected disloyalty and theft.
Key Events
-
Bronx Poverty — The story begins against the background of poverty and organized crime in 1935. Characters: Dutch Schultz
Location: The Bronx
-
Dutch Notices Billy — Dutch notices a poor teenager and draws him toward his organization. Characters: Dutch Schultz
Location: The Bronx
-
Billy Enters The Mob — Billy takes work as a gofer and views the mob as his path upward. Characters: Dutch Schultz
Location: Dutch's organization
-
Bo Faces Suspicion — Dutch suspects trusted lieutenant Bo of secretly meeting rival bosses. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Bo Weinberg
Location: Dutch's organization
-
Bo Gets Cement Shoes — Dutch has Bo dumped into the water wearing cement shoes. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Bo Weinberg
Location: The water
-
Julie Claims Entitlement — Julie is accused of stealing $50,000 and defiantly claims he is entitled to it. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Julie Martin
Location: Dutch's organization
-
Julie Is Shot — Dutch shoots his top enforcer over the alleged theft. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Julie Martin
Location: Dutch's organization
The Trial Town Masquerade
Dutch relocates to an upstate community while facing tax-evasion charges. He charms residents through charity and a carefully constructed public image.
Key Events
-
Trial Relocation — Dutch relocates with his entourage while facing tax-evasion charges. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Drew Preston, Otto Berman
Location: An upstate New York community
-
Dutch Charms Locals — Dutch performs charitable acts and presents himself as easygoing to residents. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Drew Preston
Location: The local community
-
Drew Is Watched — While Dutch attends court, Billy is assigned to watch Drew. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Drew Preston
Location: The local community
Drew's Narrow Escape
Billy is assigned to watch Drew and discovers that Dutch plans to kill her for infidelity. Drew is removed from danger before Dutch's men can act.
Key Events
-
Drew Faces Danger — Billy realizes Dutch intends to have Drew murdered for cheating on him. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Drew Preston
Location: The local community
-
Drew Escapes — Drew's husband takes her away before Dutch's men can reach her. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Drew Preston
Location: A private plane
-
Dutch Wins Acquittal — A sympathetic jury acquits Dutch of the tax-evasion charges. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Drew Preston
Location: Upstate New York court
A War Against Authority
After a second indictment, Dutch plans to assassinate the state prosecutor. The Commission rejects the plan and refuses the bribe sent to secure approval.
Key Events
-
Second Indictment — Dutch is indicted again and struggles to finance his legal defense. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Otto Berman
Location: Dutch's organization
-
Dewey Assassination Plan — Dutch decides that the state prosecutor should be assassinated. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Otto Berman
Location: Dutch's organization
-
Commission Rejects Request — The Commission rejects the assassination plan because it would attract excessive attention. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Otto Berman
Location: The Commission
-
Bribe Is Refused — A Commission member refuses the bribe sent by Dutch. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Otto Berman
Location: The Commission
The Restaurant Execution
Otto fires Billy but lets him keep the bribe money. Luciano's men then attack Dutch's safe haven, kill Dutch and Otto, and force Billy into silence.
Key Events
-
Billy Is Fired — Otto fires Billy, but lets him keep the bribe money as a gift. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Otto Berman
Location: Dutch's organization
-
Commission Ambush — Luciano's gangsters ambush and beat Billy after he leaves Dutch's organization. Characters: Lucky Luciano, Otto Berman
Location: The street
-
Restaurant Massacre — Luciano's men storm the restaurant and gun down Dutch, Otto, and two henchmen. Characters: Dutch Schultz, Otto Berman, Lucky Luciano
Location: A safe-haven restaurant
-
Lucky Issues A Threat — Lucky warns Billy that speaking about Dutch will endanger his family. Characters: Lucky Luciano
Location: A meeting place
-
Cash And Silence — Lucky releases Billy with the cash and a warning to remain silent. Characters: Lucky Luciano
Location: A meeting place