Plot Analysis Summary
Traces the creation, theatrical failure, decades-long loss, and eventual rediscovery of Orson Welles's unfinished 1938 silent comedy.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
Cinematic Genesis
The narrative traces the origins of William Gillette's 1894 play and its early 20th-century adaptations. Orson Welles subsequently develops the silent comedy in 1938 as a component for a live stage production.
Key Events
-
1894 Original Play — William Gillette writes the original 1894 comedy that inspires later adaptations.
Location: Theater
-
1919 Paramount Adaptation — A feature-length Paramount version is produced, starring Lois Wilson and Bryant Washburn.
Location: Studio
-
1938 Film Production — Orson Welles writes and directs the silent comedy three years before Citizen Kane.
Location: Studio
Theatrical Disaster
Plans to integrate the film sequences into the Mercury Theatre presentation collapse due to technical limitations. The Stony Creek Theatre lacks projection facilities, causing severe plot confusion and the production's failure.
Key Events
-
Stage Integration Plan — Film sequences are shot to be integrated into a live Mercury Theatre stage presentation.
Location: Mercury Theatre
-
Projection Failure — The venue lacks projection facilities, making it impossible to screen the film sequences.
Location: Stony Creek Theatre
Historical Vanishing
Following the stage failure, the film disappears into obscurity and is presumed lost for decades. It remains a forgotten artifact of early cinema history.
Key Events
-
Theatrical Collapse — Missing film sequences cause severe plot confusion, leading to the stage production's failure.
Location: Stony Creek Theatre
-
Decades of Obscurity — The film is believed lost and disappears from public view for decades.
Location: Archive
Rediscovery & Legacy
A print is unearthed in an Italian warehouse in 2008, ending its long disappearance. The film finally sees public screening at a 2013 festival and subsequent digital preservation.
Key Events
-
2008 Warehouse Discovery — A print of the film is discovered in a warehouse in Pordenone, Italy.
Location: Pordenone, Italy
-
2013 Festival Premiere — The film premieres publicly on October 9, 2013, after its long absence.
Location: Pordenone Silent Film Festival
-
Digital Archiving — The work print and a modern edit are released online by the National Film Preservation Foundation.
Location: Online