Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
Vienna and the Lost Collection
The story introduces the claimant's youth in Vienna and the five Klimt paintings at the center of the dispute. The portrait later known as the Woman in Gold is identified as the collection's emblematic work.
Key Events
-
Vienna Before the War — The claimant's youth is presented against the cultural background of early twentieth-century Vienna.
Location: Vienna
-
The Five Klimt Paintings — The five paintings are established as the central objects of the dispute.
Location: Vienna
-
Adele Portrait Renamed — The portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer is identified as the painting later called the Woman in Gold.
Location: Vienna
-
Nazi Persecution Begins — The story connects the claimant's family history to the Nazi period.
Location: Austria
-
Escape From Austria — The claimant's escape from the Nazis becomes a defining part of the recovery story.
Location: Austria
Escape and Unresolved Ownership
The claimant's escape from the Nazis changes the course of the family story. The paintings remain connected to an unresolved ownership claim after the escape.
Key Events
-
Escape From Austria — The claimant's escape from the Nazis becomes a defining part of the recovery story.
Location: Austria
-
Paintings Remain in Dispute — After the escape, ownership of the five paintings remains unresolved.
Location: Austria
-
Legal Representation Chosen — The claimant selects a California lawyer with an Austrian background to pursue recovery.
Location: California
-
Journalistic Assistance Added — An Austrian journalist joins the effort and contributes investigative expertise.
Location: Austria
-
Wartime History Investigated — The journalist's earlier investigation into wartime activities is identified as relevant background.
Location: Austria
The Legal Campaign
A California lawyer is selected to represent the claimant, while an Austrian journalist contributes investigative assistance. The recovery effort develops into a major legal battle.
Key Events
-
Wartime History Investigated — The journalist's earlier investigation into wartime activities is identified as relevant background.
Location: Austria
-
Recovery Claim Escalates — The effort to recover the paintings develops into a major legal battle.
Location: United States
-
Austria Becomes Defendant — The legal action places Austria at the center of the ownership dispute.
Location: United States
-
State Department Enters — The claimant must also face opposition from the United States State Department.
Location: United States
-
Supreme Court Proceedings — The dispute reaches the United States Supreme Court.
Location: United States Supreme Court
Jurisdiction and Arbitration
The dispute reaches the United States Supreme Court and includes opposition from Austria and the United States State Department. Jurisdiction is granted, leading to an Austrian arbitration proceeding.
Key Events
-
Supreme Court Proceedings — The dispute reaches the United States Supreme Court.
Location: United States Supreme Court
-
Jurisdiction Granted — The Supreme Court gives jurisdiction over Austria in the dispute.
Location: United States Supreme Court
-
Arbitration Panel Convened — An Austrian arbitration panel is established to decide ownership of the paintings.
Location: Austria
-
Ownership Decision Reached — The arbitration panel decides that the five paintings belong to the claimant.
Location: Austria
-
Austrian Shock — The ruling shocks the Austrian public and government.
Location: Austria
A National Loss and New Homes
The arbitration panel awards ownership of the five paintings to the claimant, shocking Austria. The Woman in Gold goes to the Neue Galerie, while the other four works are sold to private buyers.
Key Events
-
Austrian Shock — The ruling shocks the Austrian public and government.
Location: Austria
-
National Treasure Debate — The paintings' loss is regarded in Austria as the loss of national treasure.
Location: Austria
-
Woman in Gold Acquired — The Woman in Gold is purchased for display at the Neue Galerie in New York.
Location: New York
-
Four Paintings Sold — The other four paintings are sold through Christie's to private buyers.
Location: Christie's