Plot Analysis Summary
A political murder and conspiracy prosecution expose the hostility, factionalism, and institutional power struggles surrounding Italian immigrants in New Orleans.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
Immigrants Under Pressure
The story establishes hostility toward Italian immigrants and recalls the journey from Sicily during famine. Market and dock control reveal divisions within the immigrant community.
Key Events
-
Anti-Immigrant Hostility — The story opens with open hostility toward Italian immigrants in New Orleans.
Location: New Orleans
-
Arrival from Sicily — A young immigrant recalls arriving from Sicily with his family during a famine.
Location: New Orleans
-
Exploitation in America — The immigrants encounter racist abuse and exploitation despite expecting work and a better life.
Location: New Orleans
-
Factional Market Control — One Italian faction controls the French Market while another dominates the docks.
Location: French Market
-
Hidden Vendetta — An old vendetta between the factions remains hidden on Decatur Street.
Location: Decatur Street
Power Around the Docks
Joseph Macheca protects his business while Chief Hennessy tries to maintain order. Mayor Joe Shakspeare and William Parkerson suspect a campaign to disrupt and seize the docks.
Key Events
-
Macheca Protects Business — Joseph Macheca tries to protect his business as tensions surround the docks. Characters: Joseph Macheca
Location: Docks
-
Hennessy Maintains Order — Chief Hennessy attempts to maintain order amid factional and political tension. Characters: Chief Hennessy
Location: Docks
-
Dock Control Suspicions — Shakspeare and Parkerson suspect violence is being used to seize control of the docks. Characters: Mayor Joe Shakspeare, William Parkerson
Location: Docks
-
Demand for Arrest — Shakspeare pressures Hennessy to arrest Macheca over the suspected dock violence. Characters: Mayor Joe Shakspeare, Chief Hennessy, Joseph Macheca
Location: New Orleans
-
Police Authority Dispute — Hennessy refuses and reminds the mayor that the police answer to the state rather than the city. Characters: Mayor Joe Shakspeare, Chief Hennessy
Location: New Orleans
Murder Changes Everything
Political conflict intensifies when Shakspeare pressures Hennessy to arrest Macheca. Hennessy's murder converts the dispute into mass arrests and a conspiracy case.
Key Events
-
Houston Trains a Fighter — James Houston cultivates a ruthless young fighter and teaches confidence and willingness to kill. Characters: James Houston
Location: New Orleans
-
Promise of Belonging — Houston appears to promise Vincent Provenzano a future and the chance to become American. Characters: James Houston, Vincent Provenzano
Location: New Orleans
-
Hennessy Murdered — Chief Hennessy is murdered, transforming political suspicion into a criminal prosecution. Characters: Chief Hennessy
Location: New Orleans
-
Mass Arrests — Authorities arrest Macheca and many Italians for conspiracy, lying in wait, and murder. Characters: Joseph Macheca, Gaspare Marchesi
Location: Police custody
The Prisoners Fight Back
Dominic O'Malley and Thomas Semmes investigate and defend the prisoners. The accused offer alibis and report abuse, but a disturbed prisoner's outburst strengthens the prosecution.
Key Events
-
Defense Investigation Begins — O'Malley agrees to investigate and joins Semmes in defending the prisoners. Characters: Dominic O'Malley, Thomas Semmes, Joseph Macheca
Location: New Orleans
-
Alibis and Abuse — The accused insist they are innocent, provide alibis, and report being beaten in custody. Characters: Gaspare Marchesi, Joseph Macheca
Location: Police custody
-
Prisoner Outburst — A disturbed prisoner's outburst implicates Macheca and the Italian organizations. Characters: Joseph Macheca, Thomas Semmes
Location: Courtroom
-
Competence Examination Ordered — Semmes challenges the outburst while Judge Baker orders a medical evaluation before ruling on competence. Characters: Thomas Semmes, Judge Baker
Location: Courtroom
An Unshown Verdict
O'Malley is arrested while raising defense funds, and the prosecution presents Hennessy's death as a conspiracy. The film ends with an appeal for guilty verdicts, without showing the result.
Key Events
-
O'Malley Arrested — Dominic O'Malley is arrested while trying to raise money for the defense. Characters: Dominic O'Malley
Location: New Orleans
-
Conspiracy Case Presented — The prosecution presents Hennessy's death as the product of a criminal conspiracy. Characters: Joseph Macheca, Gaspare Marchesi, Thomas Semmes, Judge Baker
Location: Courtroom
-
Appeal to the Jury — The available testimony ends with an appeal to reject alleged Mafia influence and return guilty verdicts. Characters: Thomas Semmes, Joseph Macheca, Gaspare Marchesi
Location: Courtroom
-
Verdict Withheld — The final verdict is not shown, leaving the prisoners' legal fate unresolved. Characters: Joseph Macheca, Gaspare Marchesi, Judge Baker
Location: Courtroom