A rejected suitor uses an unconventional scheme, but the resulting romantic triangle ends with Frances choosing the conventional Edward.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
Rejected Proposals
Edward worships Frances, but she repeatedly refuses his proposals. Her hint about caveman tactics gives Edward a possible new approach.
Key Events
Edward Worships Frances — Edward is devoted to the romance-loving Frances. Characters: Edward Andrews, Frances RaymondLocation: Social setting
Frances Rejects Edward — Frances repeatedly turns down Edward's proposals. Characters: Edward Andrews, Frances RaymondLocation: Social setting
A Strange Romantic Hint — Frances hints that caveman tactics might win her. Characters: Edward Andrews, Frances RaymondLocation: Social setting
Edward Forms A Plan — Edward decides to pursue the hinted strategy. Characters: Edward AndrewsLocation: Social setting
The Unusual Scheme
Edward hires the reporter Michael Rudder to kidnap Frances. Michael takes her to Edward's country home, where a chaperoned arrangement has been prepared.
Key Events
Michael Is Hired — Edward hires reporter Michael for the scheme. Characters: Edward Andrews, Michael RudderLocation: Not specified
The Kidnapping Scheme — Michael is assigned to kidnap Frances. Characters: Edward Andrews, Michael Rudder, Frances RaymondLocation: Not specified
Frances Is Taken Away — Michael takes Frances to Edward's country home. Characters: Michael Rudder, Frances RaymondLocation: Not specified
The Country Home — The unconventional courtship continues at the country home. Characters: Edward Andrews, Michael Rudder, Frances RaymondLocation: Edward's country home
The Unexpected Wooer
Michael courts Frances with ardent lovemaking, and she is won over. She then suggests that they marry immediately.
Key Events
A Chaperoned Arrangement — Edward has arranged for a chaperon at the country home. Characters: Edward Andrews, Frances RaymondLocation: Edward's country home
Michael Courts Frances — Michael begins an ardent romantic courtship of Frances. Characters: Michael Rudder, Frances RaymondLocation: Edward's country home
Frances Falls For Michael — Frances is won over by Michael's ardent lovemaking. Characters: Michael Rudder, Frances RaymondLocation: Edward's country home
An Immediate Marriage Proposal — Frances suggests that she and Michael marry at once. Characters: Michael Rudder, Frances RaymondLocation: Edward's country home
The Vanishing Reporter
Michael runs away when Frances proposes marriage, leaving her inconsolable. Edward takes responsibility for finding the missing wooer.
Key Events
Michael Runs Away — Michael flees after Frances proposes immediate marriage. Characters: Michael Rudder, Frances RaymondLocation: Edward's country home
Frances Becomes Inconsolable — Frances is left inconsolable by Michael's disappearance. Characters: Edward Andrews, Frances RaymondLocation: Edward's country home
Edward Searches For Michael — Edward goes in search of the missing reporter. Characters: Edward Andrews, Michael RudderLocation: Not specified
Edward Brings Him Back — Edward returns with Michael after finding him. Characters: Edward Andrews, Michael RudderLocation: Not specified
The Conventional Choice
Edward brings Michael back, and Michael reveals his wealth, title, and English estate. Despite this revelation, Frances chooses the conventional Edward.
Key Events
Michael Reveals His Status — Michael reveals his wealth, title, and English estate. Characters: Michael Rudder, Edward Andrews, Frances RaymondLocation: Not specified
A Rivalry Reconsidered — Michael's status makes him a serious romantic alternative. Characters: Edward Andrews, Michael Rudder, Frances RaymondLocation: Not specified
Frances Chooses Edward — Frances decides in favor of the conventional Edward. Characters: Edward Andrews, Michael Rudder, Frances RaymondLocation: Not specified
The Conventional Ending — The romantic competition ends with Frances choosing Edward. Characters: Edward Andrews, Frances Raymond, Michael RudderLocation: Not specified
Story Breakdown
Edward's Unrequited Love — Edward admires Frances but cannot initially overcome her repeated refusals.
Persistent Proposals — Edward repeatedly proposes to Frances, and she turns him down.
Romantic Frustration — Frances's rejection establishes Edward's central emotional problem.
The Caveman Hint — Frances suggests that a more forceful romantic approach might succeed.
A Strange Suggestion — Frances hints that caveman tactics could win her over.
Edward's Decision — Edward responds by creating an unconventional courtship plan.
The Kidnapping Plan — Edward recruits Michael to carry out the plan and move Frances to the country home.
Reporter Hired — Edward hires Michael Rudder, a reporter, for the operation.
Frances Transported — Michael kidnaps Frances and takes her to Edward's country home.
Michael's Courtship — The hired reporter unexpectedly becomes the strongest romantic force in the story.
Ardent Lovemaking — Michael courts Frances passionately at the country home.
Frances Is Won — Frances responds to Michael and suggests immediate marriage.
The Vanishing Wooer — Michael's sudden flight transforms the romantic success into a crisis.
Marriage Proposal — Frances proposes that she and Michael marry at once.
Michael Flees — Michael runs away, leaving Frances inconsolable.
Edward Restores Contact — Edward searches for Michael and brings him back to address the emotional crisis.
Search For Michael — Edward goes in search of the missing reporter.
The Return — Edward returns with Michael so the romantic matter can be settled.
Status And Final Choice — Michael reveals his wealth and title, but Frances still selects Edward.
English Estate Revealed — Michael says he is wealthy and has a title and estate in England.
Conventional Edward Chosen — Frances decides in favor of Edward despite Michael's advantages.
Edward Andrews, a generous but fainthearted young man, loves Frances Raymond, who believes herself to be an incurable romantic. Edward realizes that Frances would love to be whisked off and romanced, but because he is too timid to abduct her himself, he hires Michael Rudder, a breezy young Irish reporter, to do the deed. Michael's dashing manner entrances Frances, but the Irishman prefers the unencumbered life of a rover to that of a husband, and after he delivers her to the home of Edward's grandmother, he wanders away to a gypsy camp. Frances is so downhearted from losing Michael that the kindly Edward finds the reporter and convinces him to propose to the girl. Frances, moved by Edward's goodness, decides that he is the man she really loves and returns to him.