Plot Analysis Summary
After moving to a new school, Cara becomes involved in efforts to include Grace, confronts the harm caused by a hurtful plan, and promises to share Grace's story.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Move and New Beginnings
Cara leaves her friends and is unhappy about moving and reuniting with her father. At her new school, she meets Grace and Brandon and gets to know Skyler.
Key Events
-
Cruel Car Prank — Cara and her friends pull a cruel prank on a girl's car. Characters: Cara
Location: A car
-
Last Night Together — Cara and her friends celebrate their last night together before she moves away. Characters: Cara
Location: Unspecified gathering place
-
Reluctant Move — Cara is unhappy about moving and reuniting with her father after six months apart. Characters: Cara
Location: Unspecified
-
New School Acquaintances — Cara settles into a new school and meets Grace and Brandon. Characters: Cara, Grace, Brandon
Location: New school
Making Room for Grace
Grace reveals that nobody has asked her to the dance, and Cara and Brandon promise to help. Cara and Skyler support Grace's efforts to feel included and become homecoming queen.
Key Events
-
Skyler's Senior Goals — Cara gets to know Skyler, who sets goals and hopes to secure a homecoming date. Characters: Cara, Skyler Harris
Location: New school
-
Grace Shares Her Wish — Grace says nobody has ever asked her to the dance. Characters: Grace, Brandon, Cara
Location: Unspecified
-
Promise to Help Grace — Brandon and Cara promise to find Grace a date and encourage her to take her medication. Characters: Brandon, Cara, Grace
Location: Unspecified
-
Brandon Seeks Advice — Brandon seeks advice from Ben about helping Grace. Characters: Brandon, Ben
Location: Unspecified
-
Homecoming Queen Effort — Cara and Skyler support Grace's bid to become homecoming queen. Characters: Cara, Skyler Harris, Grace
Location: School
Butterflies and Celebration
At Grace's home, Cara learns about her butterfly interests, her talk, and her secret project. The homecoming celebration turns painful when Grace is laughed at.
Key Events
-
Butterfly Princess Dream — Grace talks about butterflies and her wish to look like a butterfly princess. Characters: Cara, Grace
Location: Grace's home
-
Preparing Grace — Cara helps Grace get ready and learns about her talk and secret butterfly project. Characters: Cara, Grace
Location: Grace's home
-
Laughter at Celebration — Grace is laughed at after being told she won homecoming queen because her friends voted for her. Characters: Cara, Grace
Location: Homecoming celebration
Hospital Truths
Grace is hospitalized, and her mother explains that Grace's heart is failing while she waits for a donor. Skyler admits she devised the hurtful plan, and Grace's mother confronts the girls about the harm caused.
Key Events
-
Grace Hospitalized — Grace is hospitalized, and her mother explains that her heart is failing while she waits for a donor. Characters: Grace, Cara, Skyler Harris
Location: Hospital
-
Skyler Admits Her Role — Skyler says the hurtful plan was her idea and insists Cara was not responsible. Characters: Skyler Harris, Cara, Grace
Location: Hospital
-
Grace's Mother Confronts Them — Grace's mother tells Cara and Skyler that their actions hurt Grace. Characters: Cara, Skyler Harris
Location: Hospital
An Apology and a Promise
Cara visits Grace with roses and balloons and apologizes for what happened. Grace reassures Cara and asks her to share the butterfly talk if she remains in the hospital; Cara promises to share Grace's story.
Key Events
-
Cara Apologizes — Cara brings roses and balloons, apologizes, and Grace welcomes her warmly. Characters: Cara, Grace
Location: Grace's hospital room
-
Promise to Share the Story — Grace asks Cara to give her butterfly talk if she remains hospitalized; Cara promises to share Grace's story. Characters: Cara, Grace
Location: Grace's hospital room