Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
Fresh Beginnings, Old Tensions
Dave and Greta attempt to make a new place into a home. Their discussion of fresh beginnings exposes the difficult reality of their marriage, while Cal presents a radically different view of intimacy.
Key Events
-
A New Home Begins — Dave and Greta try to turn a new place into a home. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: The couple's new place
-
Fresh Beginnings Discussed — A conversation about fresh beginnings opens the story. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: The couple's new place
-
Marriage Reality Emerges — The discussion shifts from optimism to the difficulties of marriage. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: The couple's new place
-
Cal Defends Open Sex — Cal argues that outside sex can strengthen a relationship. Characters: Cal Scoppa, Dave Segel
Location: Unspecified conversation setting
-
Cal Describes Emily — Cal boasts that sex with Emily is best after another encounter. Characters: Cal Scoppa, Emily, Jake Elovitch
Location: Unspecified conversation setting
-
Jake Questions Cal — Jake questions their friendship and Cal's attitude toward women. Characters: Jake Elovitch, Cal Scoppa
Location: Unspecified conversation setting
The Marriage Breaks Open
Dave discovers Greta in bed with Lily and learns that Greta sees the situation as an identity crisis. Anger, hurt, and Cal's crude comments push the marriage toward separation.
Key Events
-
Jake Questions Cal — Jake questions their friendship and Cal's attitude toward women. Characters: Jake Elovitch, Cal Scoppa
Location: Unspecified conversation setting
-
Greta Found With Lily — Dave discovers Greta in bed with Lily. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel, Lily Kildear
Location: Dave and Greta's bedroom
-
Greta Explains Crisis — Greta calls the situation an identity crisis. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: Dave and Greta's home
-
Cal Deepens Tension — Cal's crude comments intensify Dave and Greta's conflict. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel, Cal Scoppa
Location: Dave and Greta's home
-
Greta Leaves — Greta leaves after the marriage crisis becomes unavoidable. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: Dave and Greta's home
Separation and Moral Fallout
Greta leaves and Dave receives divorce papers, but his confrontation with the divorce handler changes nothing. Jake also rejects Cal and tries to approach Emily with greater accountability.
Key Events
-
Divorce Papers Arrive — Dave is served divorce papers and struggles to accept the separation. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: Dave's home
-
Dave Confronts Divorce Handler — Dave confronts the woman handling the divorce, but changes nothing. Characters: Dave Segel
Location: Unspecified setting
-
Jake Rejects Cal — Jake turns against Cal and throws him out of his apartment. Characters: Jake Elovitch, Cal Scoppa
Location: Jake's apartment
-
Jake Approaches Emily — Jake admits he feels like a jerk and tries to talk with Emily. Characters: Jake Elovitch, Emily
Location: Unspecified setting
-
Greta Returns — Greta returns to collect her belongings. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: Dave and Greta's home
The Truth After Reconnection
Greta returns for her belongings, and she and Dave briefly reconnect through shared memories and intimacy. Greta then states that she is a lesbian, forcing Dave to face the marriage's final end.
Key Events
-
Shared History Remembered — Dave and Greta discuss their history and admit that they miss each other. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: Dave and Greta's home
-
The Couple Reconnects — Dave and Greta become intimate, briefly suggesting reconciliation. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: Dave and Greta's home
-
Greta States Her Identity — Greta tells Dave that she is a lesbian and cannot change who she is. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: Dave and Greta's home
-
Dave Rejects Explanation — Dave reacts with disbelief and tries to connect her decision to Lily. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: Dave and Greta's home
-
Marriage Finally Ends — Their renewed closeness cannot undo the end of their marriage. Characters: Dave Segel, Greta Siegel
Location: Dave and Greta's home