Plot Analysis Summary
A romantic comedy about divided love, unexpected parenthood, and the difficult reconstruction of a family.
Story Structure — 6 Plot Phases
A Complicated First Encounter
Connor receives Greg's encouragement to approach Jenny after her date is canceled. A group night of drinking and dancing culminates in a threesome, creating the central romantic entanglement.
Key Events
-
Connor's Romantic Infatuation — Connor is infatuated with an emotionally guarded woman. Characters: Connor
-
Greg Suggests Jenny — Greg encourages Connor to approach Jenny after her date is canceled. Characters: Connor, Greg, Jenny
-
Jenny's Interrupted Date — Connor approaches Jenny, a graduate student living with her parents. Characters: Connor, Jenny
-
Jealous Interruption — Connor's romantic interest inserts herself into his flirtation with Jenny. Characters: Connor, Jenny
-
Drinking And Dancing — The group drinks and dances together. Characters: Connor, Jenny, Greg
Location: A bar and dance venue
-
The Threesome — The evening culminates in a threesome involving Connor and two women. Characters: Connor, Jenny
The Promise Of A Future
Connor pursues a relationship with his original romantic interest, and their first date develops into six blissful weeks together. Her pregnancy initially inspires love, excitement, and shared future planning.
Key Events
-
Early Morning Departure — Connor's emotionally guarded romantic interest leaves early in panic. Characters: Connor
-
Connor Sleeps With Jenny — Despite his other feelings, Connor has sex with Jenny. Characters: Connor, Jenny
-
Connor Asks For A Chance — Connor tracks down his romantic interest and asks for a relationship. Characters: Connor
-
Whirlwind Relationship — Their first date goes well, followed by six blissful weeks together. Characters: Connor
-
First Pregnancy Revealed — Connor learns that his romantic partner is pregnant. Characters: Connor
-
Future Plans Begin — Connor's elation helps the couple affirm their love and plan a future. Characters: Connor
Two Pregnancies Collide
Jenny arrives at Connor's porch and reveals that she is also pregnant with his child. The revelation destroys Connor's idealized relationship and sends the couple toward separation and an abortion appointment.
Key Events
-
Jenny Arrives Pregnant — Jenny arrives and reveals that she is also pregnant with Connor's child. Characters: Connor, Jenny
Location: Connor's porch
-
Relationship Collapse — Connor's romantic partner ends the relationship and plans an abortion. Characters: Connor
-
Out-Of-State Appointment — Connor supports and drives his former partner to an abortion appointment. Characters: Connor
Location: An out-of-state clinic
-
Procedure Is Abandoned — Connor's compassionate behavior reignites her feelings, and she backs out. Characters: Connor
Location: The return drive
Divided Loyalties
Connor supports Jenny while struggling with his unresolved love for his former partner. Their conflict intensifies through insensitive decisions, a family charade, and a painful discovery about a former partner.
Key Events
-
The Text Message — Connor sees a message from his former partner's one-night stand. Characters: Connor
Location: The return drive
-
Connor Supports Jenny — Connor begins supporting Jenny more during her pregnancy. Characters: Connor, Jenny
-
Doctor's Office Conflict — Connor takes Jenny to the other woman's doctor, causing conflict. Characters: Connor, Jenny
Location: A doctor's office
-
The Family Charade — Connor agrees to pretend that he and Jenny are together. Characters: Connor, Jenny
Location: Jenny's parents' home
-
Love Reconsidered — Connor cannot overcome his continuing infatuation with his former partner. Characters: Connor
Births And Uncertain Fatherhood
A paternity question remains unresolved when labor begins. Jenny and the other pregnant woman give birth on the same day, and Connor learns which child is biologically his.
Key Events
-
Possible Paternity Revealed — A married former partner admits he may be the father of the pregnancy. Characters: Connor
-
Labor Before Results — The pregnant woman goes into labor before receiving the test results. Characters: Connor
Location: A hospital
-
Two Births Same Day — Jenny and Connor's former partner give birth on the same day. Characters: Connor, Jenny
Location: Two hospitals
-
Biological Father Confirmed — Connor learns he is not the father of the other child and attends Jenny's birth. Characters: Connor, Jenny
Location: A hospital
A Rebuilt Family
Connor and Jenny establish successful co-parenting, while Jenny prepares to move into her own house. Connor's former partner returns with her daughter, and Connor agrees to try their relationship again before Greg recounts the story at the wedding.
Key Events
-
Successful Co-Parenting — Months later, Connor and Jenny are successfully co-parenting. Characters: Connor, Jenny
Location: Jenny's new house
-
Moving Day Reunion — During Jenny's move, Connor's former partner returns with her daughter. Characters: Connor, Jenny
Location: Jenny's new house
-
Relationship Rekindled — Connor accepts a renewed attempt at a relationship with his former partner. Characters: Connor
Location: Jenny's new house
-
Wedding Toast — Greg recounts Connor's complicated romantic history during his wedding toast. Characters: Connor, Greg
Location: Connor's wedding reception