Story Structure — 6 Plot Phases
The Anthill Order
Senior command orders an attack on a heavily defended position. Promotion pressure transforms hesitation into commitment, while the attack is delegated to a protesting field officer.
Key Events
-
Order to Take the Anthill — A senior general orders a subordinate to capture the heavily defended Anthill.
Location: French headquarters
-
Promotion Changes the Decision — A possible promotion persuades the reluctant general to support the attack.
Location: French headquarters
-
Shell Shock Rejected — A private showing shell shock is expelled from the regiment.
Location: French trenches
-
Attack Planning Delegated — The attack planning is left to a colonel despite his protests.
Location: French trenches
Fear in No Man's Land
A night reconnaissance mission ends in an accidental death caused by panic. The surviving scout confronts the officer responsible, but a false report conceals the truth.
Key Events
-
Night Scouting Mission — A drunken lieutenant leads a night reconnaissance mission with two soldiers.
Location: No man's land
-
Scout Killed by Grenade — The frightened lieutenant throws a grenade and accidentally kills the forward scout.
Location: No man's land
-
False Scouting Report — The surviving scout confronts the lieutenant, who denies wrongdoing and falsifies his report.
Location: French trenches
A Failed Assault
The French attack collapses under enemy fire, and later waves refuse to advance. An artillery order against the troops is withheld because written confirmation is missing.
Key Events
-
Attack on the Anthill — French soldiers advance under intense rifle and machine-gun fire.
Location: The Anthill
-
Waves Refuse to Advance — The first wave fails to reach the German trenches and later waves refuse to attack.
Location: No man's land
-
Artillery Order Refused — The commander refuses to fire on French soldiers without written confirmation.
Location: French artillery position
Scapegoats for Defeat
Commanders redirect responsibility toward the soldiers and select three men for court martial. The selections include a targeted witness, a socially disliked soldier, and a decorated soldier chosen by lot.
Key Events
-
Blame Shifted to Soldiers — The senior field commander blames the failed attack on alleged cowardice.
Location: French headquarters
-
Court Martial Reduced — A higher commander orders the number of accused soldiers to be reduced.
Location: French headquarters
-
Three Soldiers Selected — One soldier is selected from each company, including one by random lots.
Location: French military units
The Mockery of Justice
A defense lawyer challenges a court martial lacking basic procedural safeguards. The court rejects favorable evidence, and the defense denounces the proceedings.
Key Events
-
Defense Volunteer Steps Forward — A colonel with civilian legal experience volunteers to defend the accused soldiers.
Location: French headquarters
-
Court Martial Begins — The trial begins without a formal indictment or a court stenographer.
Location: Military courtroom
-
Evidence Rejected — The court refuses evidence that could support an acquittal.
Location: Military courtroom
-
Indignant Closing Statement — The defense lawyer angrily denounces the unfair proceedings.
Location: Military courtroom
-
Artillery Evidence Revealed — The defense lawyer informs the senior commander that artillery was ordered against French troops.
Location: French headquarters
Executions and Aftermath
The condemned soldiers are executed despite the defense effort. Subsequent arguments expose military cynicism, while a song by a captive briefly restores quiet reflection among the soldiers.
Key Events
-
Artillery Evidence Revealed — The defense lawyer informs the senior commander that artillery was ordered against French troops.
Location: French headquarters
-
Execution by Firing Squad — The death sentences are confirmed and the condemned soldiers are executed.
Location: French military grounds
-
Command Betrayal Exposed — The senior commander announces an investigation into the artillery order.
Location: French headquarters
-
Command Offered and Rejected — A vacant command is offered to the defense lawyer, who rejects the cynical assumption behind it.
Location: French headquarters
-
Soldiers Mock Captive Singer — Soldiers jeer at a captive German singer during an evening at an inn.
Location: An army inn
-
The Faithful Hussar Sung — The captive sings a sentimental German folk song, quieting the soldiers.
Location: An army inn
-
Return to the Trenches — New orders arrive, but the soldiers are allowed to remain briefly before returning.
Location: An army inn
A commanding officer defends three scapegoats on trial for a failed offensive that occurred within the French Army in 1916.