Plot Analysis Summary
Marjie's romance with Bill develops amid family resistance, separation, changing expectations, and the disruption of World War I.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
A New Home and New Neighbor
The Winfields move to a larger house, a change welcomed by George but not the rest of the family. Marjie meets Bill, home from Indiana University, and the two are immediately attracted to each other.
Key Events
-
The Winfields Move — The Winfields move to a larger house in a nicer neighborhood; George alone welcomes the change. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield, George Winfield, Alice Winfield, Wesley Winfield, Stella
Location: A larger house in an Indiana town
-
A Tomboy Meets Bill — Marjie meets neighbor Bill, who is home from Indiana University. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield, William 'Bill' Sherman
Location: The Winfields' new neighborhood
-
An Immediate Attraction — Marjie and Bill are immediately attracted to each other. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield, William 'Bill' Sherman
Location: The Winfields' new neighborhood
-
Marjie Changes Her Focus — Marjie shifts her attention from baseball toward becoming a proper young woman. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield
Location: The Winfield household
Courtship and Unconventional Views
Marjie's interest in Bill shifts her focus away from baseball and toward becoming a proper young woman. Their relationship develops, while Bill's views on marriage and money reveal a difference in outlook.
Key Events
-
Their Courtship Develops — Marjie and Bill develop a romantic relationship. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield, William 'Bill' Sherman
Location: The Indiana town
-
Bill Rejects Convention — Bill's unconventional views include disbelief in marriage and a low regard for money's role in society. Characters: William 'Bill' Sherman, Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield
Location: The Indiana town
-
Bill Returns to School — Bill returns to his studies, bringing distance into the couple's relationship. Characters: William 'Bill' Sherman, Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield
Location: Indiana University
-
Distance Tests Their Romance — Bill's absence at university becomes one of the obstacles to a happy life together. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield, William 'Bill' Sherman
Location: The Indiana town and Indiana University
Distance and Family Resistance
Bill's return to school separates the couple. George's disapproval and preference for another suitor, along with Wesley's meddling, hinder their hopes.
Key Events
-
George Disapproves — Marjie's father's disapproval hinders her relationship with Bill. Characters: George Winfield, Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield, William 'Bill' Sherman
Location: The Winfield household
-
A Preferred Suitor — George's preference for another suitor adds to his opposition to Marjie's romance. Characters: George Winfield, Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield
Location: The Winfield household
-
Wesley Meddles — Wesley's continual meddling creates complications for Marjie's relationship. Characters: Wesley Winfield, Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield
Location: The Winfield household
-
Marjie Seeks Respectability — Marjie's attempts to become a proper young woman remain part of the obstacles surrounding the romance. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield
Location: The Winfield household
Wartime Uncertainty and Reconciliation
The nation's entry into World War I adds another obstacle to Marjie and Bill's future. George eventually softens and becomes more receptive to their relationship.
Key Events
-
Marjie Seeks Respectability — Marjie's attempts to become a proper young woman remain part of the obstacles surrounding the romance. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield
Location: The Winfield household
-
The Nation Enters War — The nation's entry into World War I becomes another obstacle to the couple's happiness. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield, William 'Bill' Sherman
Location: The United States
-
George Softens — George eventually softens and becomes more receptive to Marjie's relationship with Bill. Characters: George Winfield, Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield, William 'Bill' Sherman
Location: The Winfield household
-
A More Hopeful Future — George's changed attitude eases one of the major barriers to Marjie and Bill's romance. Characters: Marjorie 'Marjie' Winfield, William 'Bill' Sherman, George Winfield
Location: The Indiana town