Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
The Baptism That Changed Everything
Anna Morisi secretly baptizes the sick Edgardo, who survives. Seven years later, the report of the baptism gives Feletti a legal basis to remove the child from his Jewish family.
Key Events
-
Secret Baptism — Anna secretly baptizes the sick child, believing he may die and enter limbo. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Anna Morisi
Location: Bologna family home
-
Edgardo Survives — Edgardo survives, but the secret baptism later becomes legally decisive. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Anna Morisi
Location: Bologna family home
-
Baptism Is Reported — Anna tells Feletti about the baptism seven years after it occurred. Characters: Anna Morisi, Pier Gaetano Feletti
Location: Bologna Inquisition office
-
Removal Is Ordered — Feletti decides that Edgardo must be removed because baptized Christians cannot be raised by non-Christians. Characters: Pier Gaetano Feletti, Edgardo Mortara (child), Momolo Mortara, Marianna Mortara
Location: Bologna
A Child Taken to Rome
Edgardo is forcibly taken to Rome and placed in the Casa dei Catecumeni. His parents publicize the case, while Edgardo is absorbed into a Catholic educational environment.
Key Events
-
Forced Departure — Edgardo is forcibly taken from his family and sent toward Rome. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Momolo Mortara, Marianna Mortara, Pier Gaetano Feletti
Location: Mortara family home
-
Casa dei Catecumeni — Edgardo arrives at the Roman boarding school for children of converted Jews. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
-
Public Campaign Begins — Edgardo's parents publicize the case and provoke international indignation. Characters: Momolo Mortara, Marianna Mortara
Location: Bologna and European public sphere
-
Church Claims Edgardo — Edgardo is raised and educated within a completely Catholic environment. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Pier Gaetano Feletti
Location: Rome
The Visit and the Failed Rescue
Momolo and Marianna visit Edgardo, who privately reveals that he still recites the Shema. Visits are then forbidden unless the family converts, and an attempted kidnapping fails.
Key Events
-
Parents Visit Rome — Momolo and Marianna receive permission to visit their son months after his removal. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Momolo Mortara, Marianna Mortara
Location: Rome boarding school
-
Shema Revealed — Edgardo cries before Marianna and reveals that he secretly recites the Shema every night. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Marianna Mortara, Momolo Mortara
Location: Rome boarding school
-
Visits Are Forbidden — Future visits are forbidden unless the entire family converts to Catholicism. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Momolo Mortara, Marianna Mortara
Location: Rome boarding school
-
Kidnapping Attempt Fails — The Mortaras organize an attempted kidnapping, but the plan fails and their Roman Jewish support collapses. Characters: Momolo Mortara, Marianna Mortara, Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
Law, War, and Irreversible Choice
Political change brings Feletti to trial, but the court confirms that the baptism was valid and acquits him. Years later, Riccardo offers Edgardo a return home, which Edgardo rejects.
Key Events
-
Bologna Changes Rule — After the Second Italian War of Independence, Bologna leaves papal control. Characters: Pier Gaetano Feletti
Location: Bologna
-
Feletti Faces Trial — Feletti is arrested and tried while the Mortara case is reconstructed in court. Characters: Pier Gaetano Feletti, Momolo Mortara, Marianna Mortara
Location: Bologna courtroom
-
Baptism Is Valid — The hearings establish that Anna's baptism was valid and that Feletti followed the law. Characters: Anna Morisi, Pier Gaetano Feletti, Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Bologna courtroom
-
Feletti Is Acquitted — Feletti is acquitted because he acted according to the laws then in force. Characters: Pier Gaetano Feletti
Location: Bologna courtroom
-
Riccardo Offers Return — After Rome joins Italy, Riccardo finds Edgardo and tells him he can finally return home. Characters: Riccardo Mortara, Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
-
Edgardo Chooses Church — Edgardo refuses to return, declaring that the Catholic Church is now his real family. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Riccardo Mortara
Location: Rome
The Final Family Rupture
Edgardo returns when Marianna is dying and tries to baptize her. She refuses, and his siblings drive him away, completing the family's final separation.
Key Events
-
Papal Funeral Riot — After the pope dies, Edgardo impulsively joins rioters who want to throw the coffin into the Tiber. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
-
Edgardo Returns Home — Edgardo returns years later when his dying mother Marianna is near death. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Marianna Mortara
Location: Mortara family home
-
Mother Rejects Baptism — Edgardo tries to baptize Marianna, but she refuses and insists on dying as a Jew. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Marianna Mortara
Location: Mortara family home
-
Family Breaks Apart — Edgardo's siblings drive him away, marking the apparent final break with his family. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child), Riccardo Mortara, Momolo Mortara, Marianna Mortara
Location: Mortara family home
-
Priestly Life Continues — The closing credits state that Edgardo became a priest, missionary, and preacher before dying in Belgium. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: European monasteries