Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Baptism That Changes Everything
A secret baptism is administered when Edgardo is believed to be dying. Years later, its disclosure activates the legal machinery that separates him from his family.
Key Events
-
Secret Baptism — Anna secretly baptizes the seriously ill child, fearing he will die without Christian salvation. Characters: Anna Morisi, Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Bologna household
-
The Child Survives — Edgardo survives the illness, while the secret baptism remains hidden for several years. Characters: Anna Morisi, Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Bologna household
-
Baptism Disclosed — Years later, Anna reports the baptism to the head of the local Inquisition. Characters: Anna Morisi
Location: Bolognese Inquisition office
-
Removal Ordered — The authorities decide that a baptized Christian child cannot be raised by non-Christians. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Papal States
The Child Taken To Rome
Edgardo is forcibly removed and placed in a Catholic boarding school. His family responds by turning the private tragedy into a public campaign.
Key Events
-
Forced Separation — Edgardo is forcibly taken from his family and transported to Rome. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Bologna
-
Roman Boarding School — Edgardo is placed in a boarding school for children of converted Jewish families. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Casa dei Catecumeni
-
Public Campaign Begins — Edgardo's family seeks public attention, provoking international indignation over his removal. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Bologna and European newspapers
-
Political Crisis Deepens — The case intensifies criticism of papal authority during a broader political crisis.
Location: Papal States
-
Personal Supervision — The pope personally takes responsibility for Edgardo's education in a Catholic environment. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
Faith Beneath The Silence
A permitted family visit exposes Edgardo's continuing attachment to Jewish prayer. Institutional authorities then prohibit further contact unless the family converts.
Key Events
-
Public Catholic Reception — A second public baptism or reception is performed to affirm Edgardo's Catholic identity. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Roman Catholic institution
-
Family Visit Granted — After months in Rome, Edgardo's parents receive permission to visit him. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome boarding school
-
The Secret Prayer — Edgardo reveals that he still secretly recites the Shema Yisrael every night. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Roman boarding school
-
Visits Prohibited — Further visits are forbidden unless the entire family converts to Catholicism. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
-
Failed Kidnapping Attempt — The family organizes an attempt to take Edgardo back, but the plan fails. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
-
Support Withdrawn — The failed attempt causes the family to lose the remaining support of Rome's Jewish community. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome Jewish community
Law And Political Rupture
Political change brings the case before a new court, where the original baptism is validated and the removal is judged lawful under the earlier system. Edgardo remains in Rome and enters clerical formation.
Key Events
-
Support Withdrawn — The failed attempt causes the family to lose the remaining support of Rome's Jewish community. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome Jewish community
-
Bologna Changes Hands — After the Second Italian War of Independence, Bologna passes from papal control to new authorities.
Location: Bologna
-
The Baptism Validated — Hearings reconstruct the case and confirm that Anna's original baptism was legally valid. Characters: Anna Morisi
Location: Bologna courtroom
-
Acquittal Under Old Law — The official who ordered the removal is acquitted because he followed the laws then in force.
Location: Bologna courtroom
-
Clerical Formation — Edgardo remains in Rome, studies for the priesthood, and adopts a clerical identity. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome religious institution
-
Rome Occupied — The Kingdom of Italy occupies Rome, ending the temporal rule of the Papal States. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Porta Pia, Rome
A Family Beyond Return
After Rome joins Italy, Edgardo rejects the chance to return and identifies the Church as his true family. His later attempt to convert his dying mother results in permanent estrangement.
Key Events
-
Return Offered — An older brother serving in the occupying army tells Edgardo that he can finally return home. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
-
Church Chosen — Edgardo refuses the offer, declaring that the Catholic Church is now his real family. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
-
Revolt At The Funeral — After the pope's death, Edgardo impulsively joins rioters who want to throw the coffin into the Tiber. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
-
Remorse And Flight — Edgardo regrets joining the attack and runs away from the rioters. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Rome
-
Mother's Final Illness — Years later, Edgardo returns when his mother is dying, after previously refusing to attend his father's funeral. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Mortara family home
-
Baptism Refused — Alone with his mother, Edgardo tries to baptize her, but she refuses and asserts her Jewish identity. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Family home
-
Final Family Break — Edgardo's siblings drive him away after the attempted conversion, ending the family's relationship with him. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: Mortara family home
-
Missionary's Final Years — Edgardo becomes a priest, works across Europe as a missionary and preacher, and dies in a Belgian monastery. Characters: Edgardo Mortara (child)
Location: European monasteries
The story of Edgardo Mortara, a young Jewish boy living in Bologna, Italy, who in 1858, after being secretly baptized, was forcibly taken from his family to be raised as a Christian. His parents’ struggle to free their son became part of a larger political battle that pitted the papacy against forces of democracy and Italian unification.