Plot Analysis Summary
A reckless man transforms through faith, suffering, family reconciliation, and a vocation to serve others.
Story Structure — 6 Plot Phases
A Restless Life Westward
Stu leaves Montana to pursue acting in Southern California, but his reckless behavior and strained family history follow him. Meeting Carmen introduces a new challenge centered on baptism and faith.
Key Events
-
Troubled Montana Beginning — Stu struggles with boxing, family tension, and hostility toward religion after a family death. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Bill Long, Kathleen Long
Location: Helena, Montana
-
California Acting Dream — Stu moves to California to pursue acting and takes a grocery store job. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Location: Southern California
-
DUI Arrest — Stu is arrested for DUI and attempts to take his father's truck to an audition. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Location: Southern California
-
Meeting Carmen — Stu meets Carmen while working and follows her to the Catholic parish. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Carmen
Location: Grocery store
-
Baptism Condition — Carmen refuses to date Stu unless he agrees to be baptized. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Carmen
Location: Catholic parish
Baptism Changes Course
Stu enters RCIA, forms a friendship with Ham, and is baptized so he can date Carmen. His brief acting success fails to resolve his dissatisfaction, leading to a devastating drunk-driving crash.
Key Events
-
Baptism Condition — Carmen refuses to date Stu unless he agrees to be baptized. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Carmen
Location: Catholic parish
-
RCIA Friendship — Stu begins RCIA and befriends Ham while entering parish life. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Ham
Location: Catholic parish
-
Baptism And Dating — After baptism, Stu and Carmen begin dating and he meets her parents. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Carmen
Location: Catholic parish
-
First Acting Role — Stu lands an acting role in an infomercial but remains discouraged. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Location: Southern California
-
Drunk Motorcycle Crash — Stu drives drunk, crashes into a car, and is run over after being thrown from his motorcycle. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Location: Southern California road
-
Mary's Vision — While near death, Stu sees Mary tell him that he cannot die in vain. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Mary
Location: Vision
A Vision And A Calling
After seeing Mary in a near-death vision, Stu recovers and begins to understand his survival as purposeful. His relationship with Carmen and his prayerful discernment lead him toward priesthood.
Key Events
-
Mary's Vision — While near death, Stu sees Mary tell him that he cannot die in vain. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Mary
Location: Vision
-
Miraculous Recovery — Stu recovers from severe injuries, and his parents reconnect with him. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Bill Long, Kathleen Long
Location: Hospital
-
Calling Beyond Marriage — Carmen visits Stu, and he discerns a stronger call toward priesthood than marriage. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Carmen
Location: Stu's home
-
Seminary Rejection — Stu applies to the seminary, is rejected, appeals, and is eventually accepted. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Location: Seminary
Suffering In Formation
Stu overcomes seminary rejection but is diagnosed with a progressive muscular disease. His physical decline threatens ordination and forces him to confront anger, dependence, and the meaning of suffering.
Key Events
-
Seminary Rejection — Stu applies to the seminary, is rejected, appeals, and is eventually accepted. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Location: Seminary
-
Disease Diagnosis — Stu collapses while playing basketball and is diagnosed with inclusion body myositis. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Ham
Location: Seminary grounds
-
Ordination Blocked — The rector says Stu cannot be ordained because he may be unable to celebrate the Sacraments. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Location: Seminary
-
Return To Montana — Stu returns home as his disease progresses and his parents provide extensive care. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Bill Long, Kathleen Long
Location: Montana
Ordination Against The Odds
Stu returns to Montana while his parents care for him, and Bill confronts his past neglect. A parish petition succeeds, allowing Stu to be ordained and begin ministry despite his illness.
Key Events
-
Bill Faces Neglect — Bill admits that his neglect and absence may have contributed to Stu's struggles. Characters: Bill Long, Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Location: Alcoholics Anonymous meeting
-
Petition For Ordination — Parishioners petition the Diocese of Helena, which agrees to ordain Stu. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Carmen, Ham
Location: Helena Diocese
-
Ordination And Ministry — Stu is ordained with loved ones present and begins building relationships through ministry. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Bill Long, Kathleen Long, Carmen, Ham
Location: Montana church
A Ministry Of Presence
Confined to a skilled nursing facility, Stu continues to minister to people who visit him. His final conversation offers reassurance about vocation before his death at age fifty.
Key Events
-
Final Confession — During confession, the fellow seminarian admits uncertainty, and Stu encourages another path of service. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long, Priest
Location: Skilled nursing facility
-
Stu's Death — Stu continues ministering to visitors and dies at age fifty. Characters: Father Stuart 'Stu' Long
Location: Skilled nursing facility