Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
The House on the Hill
Five graduate students living together in Iowa introduce their academic backgrounds and liberal perspectives. Their peaceful routine is shattered when veteran Zack arrives for dinner and reveals extreme racist views.
Key Events
-
Graduate Students Gather — Five graduate students introduce themselves and their academic backgrounds. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Iowa House
-
Zack Arrives for Dinner — Desert Storm veteran Zack helps move a car and is invited inside. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Iowa House
-
Heated Political Debate — Zack reveals racist and Holocaust-denying views, sparking intense arguments. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Dining Room
-
Zack's Violent Outburst — Zack snaps, holds a knife to Marc's throat, and threatens Paulie. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Dining Room
-
Zack's Fatal Stabbing — Marc fatally stabs Zack in the back after he releases Marc. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Dining Room
Blood on the Dining Table
Zack's violent outburst forces the students to defend themselves, resulting in his fatal stabbing. The group decides to cover up the murder and systematically targets other conservatives.
Key Events
-
Zack's Fatal Stabbing — Marc fatally stabs Zack in the back after he releases Marc. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Dining Room
-
Murder Decision Made — The group decides to systematically murder other conservatives to improve the world. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Iowa House
-
Ritual Protocol Established — They lay out procedures: offer recantation, serve poisoned wine if refused. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Iowa House
-
First Guest Eliminated — A homophobic reverend is served the wine and dies after refusing to recant. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Dining Room
The Serial Ritual
The students establish a murder protocol involving poisoned wine and recantation opportunities. They successfully eliminate ten guests while burying bodies in their garden.
Key Events
-
Serial Murders Continue — The group murders nine more guests including a Neo-Nazi and anti-abortion activist. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Iowa House
-
Bodies Buried in Garden — The group covers their tracks by burying victims in the backyard. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Vegetable Garden
-
Group Misgivings Surface — Infighting and guilt emerge as some members question the moral justification. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Iowa House
-
Teenage Guest Spared — Despite Luke and Pete's protests, the group spares a teen opponent of sex ed. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Dining Room
Cracks in the Facade
Internal guilt and infighting emerge as the group spares a teenage guest. Sheriff Alice Stanley arrives to investigate a missing person case, increasing the pressure on the students.
Key Events
-
Teenage Guest Spared — Despite Luke and Pete's protests, the group spares a teen opponent of sex ed. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Dining Room
-
Sheriff Stanley Investigates — Sheriff Stanley questions the students regarding missing girl Jenny Tyler. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Luke, Sheriff Alice Stanley
Location: Iowa House
-
Luke Kills the Sheriff — Luke kills Stanley after finding her trespassing, hiding it from the others. Characters: Luke, Sheriff Alice Stanley
Location: Backyard
-
Norman Arbuthnot Invited — Luke and Pete meet famous conservative pundit Norman and invite him to dinner. Characters: Luke, Pete, Norman Arbuthnot
Location: School Break Location
The Pundit's Gambit
Luke and Pete invite conservative pundit Norman Arbuthnot to dinner. Norman outsmarts them intellectually, discovers their crimes, and leaves them defeated while he plans a political future.
Key Events
-
Norman Arbuthnot Invited — Luke and Pete meet famous conservative pundit Norman and invite him to dinner. Characters: Luke, Pete, Norman Arbuthnot
Location: School Break Location
-
Norman's Persuasive Defense — Norman stymies the group with moderate arguments and admits to performing for attention. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke, Norman Arbuthnot
Location: Dining Room
-
Kitchen Altercation — Luke insists on killing Norman, but the group dissuades him and he breaks down. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke, Norman Arbuthnot
Location: Kitchen
-
Norman Discovers the Truth — Norman examines the home and pieces together the group's murderous activities. Characters: Norman Arbuthnot
Location: Iowa House
-
Norman's Counter-Toast — Norman offers them wine, refuses to drink, and reveals he knows about the bad wine. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke, Norman Arbuthnot
Location: Dining Room
-
Students Collapsed — A closing painting shows all five students collapsed on the floor. Characters: Jude, Pete, Paulie, Marc, Luke
Location: Dining Room
-
Norman's Presidential Speculation — Audio plays of Norman speculating about a presidential bid to a cheering crowd. Characters: Norman Arbuthnot
Location: Unknown
-
Final Ironic Resolution — Norman stands next to the blue bottle, smoking, having outsmarted his pursuers. Characters: Norman Arbuthnot
Location: Unknown
A group of idealistic but frustrated liberals succumb to the temptation of murdering right-wing pundits for their political beliefs.