Plot Analysis Summary
A marital and legal conflict explores gender equality, professional rivalry, and eventual reconciliation.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
The Shooting and Assignment
Doris shoots her husband in a jealous rage, prompting legal assignments for the Bonners. The couple debates the case while navigating their opposing professional roles.
Key Events
-
Shooting Incident — Doris fires wildly, hitting her husband during a jealous rage. Characters: Doris Attinger
Location: Manhattan Apartment
-
Newspaper Reading — Amanda and Adam read about the shooting and debate the case. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner Residence
-
Legal Assignment — Adam learns he is assigned to prosecute the shooting case. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: DA Office
-
Defense Retainer — Amanda agrees to defend Doris against the attempted murder charges. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger
Location: Doris's Office
Courtroom Ideology
Amanda defends Doris on gender equality grounds while tensions rise at home. Witness testimonies and strategic arguments escalate the legal and personal stakes.
Key Events
-
Defense Retainer — Amanda agrees to defend Doris against the attempted murder charges. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger
Location: Doris's Office
-
Courtroom Strategy — Amanda outlines a gender equality defense strategy to the court. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger
Location: Courtroom
-
Weightlifter Witness — Amanda's witness lifts Adam overhead, escalating courtroom tension. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger
Location: Courtroom
-
Home Argument — Tension builds at home as professional rivalry spills into personal life. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner Residence
-
Adam Leaves — Adam packs his bags and storms out of the apartment in anger. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner Residence
-
Neighbor Taunt — Kip repeatedly taunts Adam, highlighting his romantic interest in Amanda. Characters: Kip Lurie, Amanda Bonner
Location: Apartment Hallway
Verdict and Confrontation
Doris is acquitted, triggering a dramatic apartment standoff with a licorice gun. The prank reveals underlying marital frustrations and leads to a chaotic altercation.
Key Events
-
Adam Leaves — Adam packs his bags and storms out of the apartment in anger. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner Residence
-
Verdict Returned — The jury acquits Doris following Amanda's plea to reverse gender perspectives. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger
Location: Courtroom
-
Silhouette Discovery — Adam observes silhouettes of Amanda and Kip dancing through the window. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Kip Lurie
Location: Apartment Window
-
Gun Confrontation — Adam breaks in and points a gun at the pair, demanding accountability. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Kip Lurie
Location: Apartment
-
Licorice Reveal — Adam bites the gun, revealing it is made of licorice and was a prank. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Kip Lurie
Location: Apartment
-
Three-Way Fight — Amanda reacts furiously to the prank, triggering a physical altercation. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Kip Lurie
Location: Apartment
-
Courtroom Plea — Amanda urges the jury to judge the case as if the sexes were reversed. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger
Location: Courtroom
Reconciliation and Reflection
The couple processes their relationship through shared memories and financial reviews. They revisit their past, acknowledge their bond, and find renewed understanding.
Key Events
-
Three-Way Fight — Amanda reacts furiously to the prank, triggering a physical altercation. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Kip Lurie
Location: Apartment
-
Tax Meeting — The couple reluctantly reunites to review their financial expenses. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Accountant Office
-
Mortgage Recall — Adam tearfully recalls burning their farm mortgage years ago. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Accountant Office
-
Farm Visit — Amanda gently takes her sobbing husband to their shared farm property. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Farm
-
Judge Nomination — Adam announces his selection as the Republican nominee for County Court Judge. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Farm
-
Gender Debate — Amanda jokes about running as the Democratic candidate, sparking debate. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Farm
-
Crocodile Tears — Adam demonstrates how men can use manufactured tears to manipulate. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Farm
-
Curtain Close — Adam closes the curtains, symbolizing the end of their marital conflict. Characters: Amanda Bonner
Location: Farm
A woman's attempted murder of her uncaring husband results in everyday quarrels in the lives of Adam and Amanda, a pair of happily married lawyers who end up on opposite sides of the case in court.