Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Shot Heard at Home
Doris shoots Warren after suspecting his affair, creating the criminal case. Adam and Amanda learn of the incident and immediately reveal opposing views about gender and responsibility.
Key Events
-
Doris Follows Warren — Doris follows Warren after suspecting he is having an affair. Characters: Doris Attinger, Warren Attinger
Location: Manhattan
-
Shots in the Room — Doris fires wildly and blindly at Warren and the couple with him. Characters: Doris Attinger, Warren Attinger
Location: Manhattan room
-
Warren Is Wounded — One bullet hits Warren in the shoulder while the other person escapes unharmed. Characters: Doris Attinger, Warren Attinger
Location: Manhattan room
-
Newspaper Case Debate — Adam and Amanda read about the shooting and argue over Doris's responsibility. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner apartment
The Marriage on Trial
Adam becomes the prosecutor while Amanda represents Doris. Their competing legal theories transform their private marriage into a public professional conflict.
Key Events
-
Adam Gets the Case — Adam learns that he has been assigned to prosecute Doris. Characters: Adam Bonner, Doris Attinger
Location: District attorney's office
-
Amanda Takes Doris's Case — Amanda seeks Doris out and becomes her defense attorney. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger
Location: Amanda's law office
-
Equal Standards Defense — Amanda argues that gender equality and Warren's conduct must shape the defense. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger, Adam Bonner
Location: Bonner apartment
-
Law Versus Excuse — Adam rejects any excuse for criminal behavior and accuses Amanda of contempt for the law. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner apartment
-
Courtroom Battle Begins — Adam prosecutes while Amanda defends Doris, turning their marriage into a courtroom contest. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger, Warren Attinger
Location: New York courtroom
Equality Under Cross-Examination
Amanda builds her defense around equal standards and Warren's alleged abuse. The courtroom battle becomes increasingly humiliating and personal for Adam.
Key Events
-
Gender Equality Argument — Amanda presents Doris's actions through equal standards for men and women. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Adam Bonner, Doris Attinger
Location: New York courtroom
-
Adam Is Lifted — Amanda encourages a woman weightlifter witness to lift Adam overhead, humiliating him during trial. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner
Location: New York courtroom
-
Marriage Explodes — Adam angrily rejects the idea of marriage to a liberated new woman and packs his bags. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner apartment
-
Adam Leaves Home — Adam storms out of the upper-floor apartment after their argument. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner apartment
The Verdict and the Prank
Amanda's closing appeal wins Doris's acquittal, but Adam leaves their apartment. His jealousy over Kip leads to a gun threat that becomes a licorice prank and a three-way fight.
Key Events
-
Adam Leaves Home — Adam storms out of the upper-floor apartment after their argument. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner apartment
-
Amanda's Jury Plea — Amanda asks the jury to judge the case as if the sexes were reversed. Characters: Amanda Bonner, Doris Attinger, Adam Bonner
Location: New York courtroom
-
Doris Is Acquitted — The jury accepts Amanda's argument and acquits Doris. Characters: Doris Attinger, Amanda Bonner, Adam Bonner
Location: New York courtroom
-
Kip Appears with Amanda — Adam sees silhouettes of Amanda and Kip apparently dancing and drinking together. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner, Kip Lurie
Location: Bonner apartment
-
Licorice Gun Prank — Adam points a gun at them, then bites it and reveals that it is made of licorice. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner, Kip Lurie
Location: Bonner apartment
-
Three-Way Fight — Amanda furiously reacts to the prank, and a three-way fight follows. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner, Kip Lurie
Location: Bonner apartment
Tears at the Farm
While arranging tax matters during their separation, Adam and Amanda remember their shared farm and mortgage. Their emotion brings them back together, though their debate about gender continues playfully.
Key Events
-
Tax Meeting Memories — During a divorce-related tax meeting, they recall their farm and burning its mortgage. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner
Location: Tax accountant's office
-
Return to the Farm — Amanda takes the tearful Adam to the farm, where they resume their intimate argument about sex and power. Characters: Adam Bonner, Amanda Bonner
Location: Bonner farm