Dawson returns from spending the summer in Philadelphia with his mother, and on the journey home meets a beautiful blonde girl, Eve (Brittany Daniel), who takes a liking to him. He hasn't spoken to Joey all summer. Jen gets an unexpected offer after she stands up to the school's popular crowd. Mitch becomes the new coach of the high school football team, and leaves for a coaching conference. Eve shows very clear interest in Dawson, and he takes her out on Mitch's motorboat with the intent of imp
As Pacey and Joey leave Capeside to collect Andie from hospital, Dawson is manipulated by his father and the new school principal, Howard Green (Obba Babatunde), to produce a film about football for the upcoming pep rally. However, the ultimate stars of the film, which is seen by many students and teachers, are Dawson and Eve, who inadvertently appear semi-clothed. The same night, Jen is revealed to be the new head cheerleader and Jack, the new star of the football team, two facts which stun Pac
Dawson is stunned when Eve presents him with an advance copy of the PSAT exam he and his friends will be taking shortly. The entire gang are tempted to cheat for various reasons, and when the test goes missing, it becomes obvious that one friend in particular was unable to resist the temptation. In the quest to discover who stole the paper, Dawson gets into a fight with Pacey, who is still reeling from his break-up with Andie. As the gang takes the exam, the thief is revealed to be Andie, who is
Mitch and Dawson clash over Gail's offer for Dawson to produce a news report featuring Jack, Capeside's first gay football star, as Mitch worries it may affect the upcoming game. Joey and Pacey receive an unusual punishment for skipping classes together, but Pacey's personal project of restoring a boat helps mend their rift. Andie fears being caught for cheating when Principal Green requests to speak with her. Jen decides to quit as head cheerleader, but faces resistance from her teammates, espe
Dawson grows frustrated with Eve's secrecy about her life in Capeside after catching her breaking into Jen's house. He and Pacey investigate further. Dawson discovers she is not registered at their school. He then steals a photograph from Eve's residence, resulting in her confession that she's searching for her biological mother. Joey distrusts her boss, Rob, because of his constant sexual harassment and eventually he fires her. Jack's attempts to set Jen up with Henry involve deception, and Daw
Dawson grapples with whether to disclose Eve's truth to Jen, who has already left town. Meanwhile, his mother's return to Capeside sparks curiosity. Jen reluctantly agrees to participate in a homecoming event, persuaded by Henry, who later asks her to be his date. However, Jen rejects his advances, causing tension between them. Dawson accompanies his mother, a former homecoming queen, to the event and discovers her career struggles. Andie reaches out to Joey in distress at a party with Rob, clai
In an effort to add excitement to a dull school project, Dawson decides to make a documentary, enlisting the help of Joey, Pacey and Jen. The group head to a small island near Capeside, rumoured to be haunted by the ghosts of thirteen girls killed in the 17th century after being accused of witchcraft. Joey finds similarities between her own life and that of one of the dead girls, which provokes some deep reflections on her strained relationship with Dawson. After some exploratory conversations,
When Jen's mother, Helen, unexpectedly arrives in Capeside to spend Thanksgiving with her mother and daughter, Dawson tells her what he knows about Eve. She asks him not to tell Jen, but a poignant speech at the dinner table forces Helen to think again, and she eventually tells Jen that she has a half-sister. Upset and confused by her mother's confession, Jen attempts to change her relationship with Pacey to the more physical, but finds comfort in another unexpected way. It also allows her to ma
To secure a college scholarship, Joey enrolls at a local dance school, choosing Pacey as her partner. Pacey, blackmailed into joining by Joey, struggles with his own romantic pursuits, attempting to tryst with Jen but finding no chemistry. Dawson's return leads to misunderstandings, as he mistakes Joey as Pacey's partner due to their dance teacher's remarks about unresolved tension. Eventually, Pacey and Jen acknowledge their lack of chemistry and return to friendship. Meanwhile, Jack seeks to c
Dawson, Joey, Jack, and Andie embark on a weekend trip to a Boston university to explore college life. Dawson faces criticism for his documentary at a student film festival, while Joey forms a connection with English major and Teaching Assistant A.J. Moller. Andie seeks advice for an advanced admissions interview and finds inspiration from an unexpected source, while Jack explores the local gay community and bonds with a returning Capeside resident, Ethan Brody. The weekend ends with the promise
Dawson experiences an identity crisis when Nikki emerges as filmmaking competition, and Joey experiences her own crisis when Dawson won't open up to her about the pain of his parents' divorce. Meanwhile, Jack's first efforts to hit on Ethan are rebuffed; Pacey and Andie uncomfortably find themselves involved in the same after-school activity (the school's theatre production of Barefoot in the Park) which Pacey, agreed to star in exchange for a passing grade in English; and Jen finally sees that
Joey's friends and their families come together to support the Potter family's new bed and breakfast venture. Tensions rise when Pacey invites a renowned critic for the opening weekend, leading to unexpected challenges like a malfunctioning furnace. Despite the setbacks, the warmth of their relationships shines through, leading to a positive review from the critic. Meanwhile, Jack and Andie find common ground, leading Jack to move back home. Jen and Henry work through issues, while Dawson seeks
Dawson, lacking inspiration, makes the radical move of dropping out of film class to spend some time re-evaluating his life. Back at the bed and breakfast, Joey is torn between attending Pacey's opening night and her date with A.J., who has come to Capeside for the evening. At the play, Andie must take over as director when Mr. Broderick falls ill. Jen agrees to meet Henry, but she throws him another block by bringing Grams as her date.
Joey disapproves when Dawson is persuaded by Pacey to attend an illegal Valentine's Day party. Despite her initial reservations, Joey ultimately decides to join the party along with Jack and Andie, accompanied by their childhood friend Kate. The party, hosted by local troublemaker Matt Caulfield, quickly spirals into chaos, leading to the group getting rounded up by Doug and thrown into the drunk tank. They are later rescued by Mitch, except for Pacey. During a heart-to-heart with Doug, Pacey re
Joey is selected to paint a mural at school, but it gets vandalized, leading to Pacey taking matters into his own hands and facing consequences. Matt Caulfield is expelled after being identified as the culprit. Andie achieves top scores on her PSAT but feels guilty for cheating and confesses to Principal Green. Pacey's home becomes crowded with his sister and her children, prompting him to consider moving in with Doug. Pacey and Joey's bond strengthens as Dawson inadvertently tests Pacey's genui
Joey mobilizes her friends to protest Principal Green's forced resignation over Matt Caulfield's expulsion. Gail and Dawson collaborate on a counter-report to challenge biased news coverage, leading to a job offer for Gail, which she declines in favor of pursuing her dream of starting a restaurant. Pacey's growing feelings for Joey prompt him to seek advice from Jen. In an effort to support Joey's creativity, Pacey rents her a public wall for painting. Principal Green stands firm against the sch
Pacey drives Joey to the train station for her date with AJ in Boston, cautioning her not to get too hopeful. Meanwhile, Jen, Jack, and Andie help out at Dawson and Gail's restaurant. Dawson eventually seeks his father's help, much to his mother's initial resistance. Pacey mentors a young boy named Buzz, seeing similarities to his own past. At the train station, Joey meets AJ's friend Morgan, who confesses her unrequited love for him during AJ's reading. Drawing from her own experiences, Joey en
After their kiss, Joey and Pacey discuss the situation with their siblings. Pacey receives encouragement from Doug and attempts to confess his feelings to Dawson during a camping trip, but they are interrupted. Jen discovers Henry has lied about his birthday party and confronts him, leading to reconciliation. Joey has a girls' night with Jen and Andie, realizing her own confusion. They visit a roller rink where Jen and Henry reconcile. Jack invites Ethan to stay, but his father cancels his trip.
Jen and Henry go through a bumpy time when she is consumed with jealousy over his friendship with waitress Shelley (Sarah Lancaster) at Gail's restaurant. Dawson, Joey, Andie, Pacey and Will Krudski (Rodney Scott), a childhood friend of the gang who has remained close with Pacey (Will appears in two subsequent episodes as an introductory character for Young Americans, a backdoor pilot and spin-off for Dawson's Creek), head to the house of Dawson's Aunt Gwen (Julie Bowen) to spend their school ho
The day Pacey and Joey's relationship goes public is played out four times, each time revealing a little more of what happened, a structure inspired by the film Go: * As Pacey christens True Love, he promises Joey that he will tell Dawson about their relationship. He encounters Andie and Will at the library, where Will asks advice on asking Andie out on a date. As Pacey goes up the steps to Dawson's house, Joey intercepts him to stop him, and the two get into an argument until Dawson hears them
Capeside prepares for its annual boat racing regatta. Pacey has entered with Will as his crew and Leery's Fresh Fish, Mitch and Gail's new restaurant, as his sponsor. Dawson decides to compete as well, bringing in Jack and Mitch as his crew and with Potters' Bed and Breakfast as his sponsor. Both Joey and Pacey realize Dawson is trying to make Joey the prize, though Dawson himself is oblivious; during the race, he breaks the rules by cutting off True Love, and is disqualified despite being first
Dawson, Joey, and Andie organize a counter-cultural prom after Jack faces discrimination over his prom date, Ethan. Dawson asks Joey to be his date, while Andie asks Pacey, hoping to win back their exes. However, Joey and Pacey share a moment on the dance floor, overshadowing their dates' intentions. The next day, Joey tells Dawson she's not ready to make decisions. Jen learns that Henry will spend the summer at football camp without informing her, leading to their breakup. Jack's date with Etha
Gail and Mitch prepare for their wedding, with Dawson as the best man and Joey as the maid of honor. Despite news of Pacey planning to leave for a three-month trip, Joey pushes through the festivities for Dawson's sake. At Pacey's farewell party, Jen and Jack express regrets about their recent relationships, prompting Grams to encourage seizing the moment. Jen reconciles with Henry and Jack kisses Ethan, facing his fears. Meanwhile, Jack's father expresses pride in his son's identity. As the day