Plot Analysis Summary
A Czech officer survives captivity by assuming a dead comrade's identity, forging a deep bond with the man's wife, and ultimately choosing truth over deception.
Story Structure — 4 Plot Phases
Escape and Identity Theft
Captain Karel Hašek escapes Dachau and assumes the identity of dead British officer Geoffrey Mitchell. He is captured and faces immediate suspicion from fellow prisoners, but Major Dalrymple intervenes to protect him.
Key Events
-
Escape from Dachau — Hašek escapes Dachau and reaches France during the German invasion. Location: France border
-
Assuming Mitchell's Identity — Hašek assumes the identity of the dead British officer Geoffrey Mitchell. Location: France
-
Captured by Germans — Hašek becomes a prisoner of war after the German victory. Location: POW Camp
-
Suspicion by British POWs — Prisoners suspect Hašek of being a spy due to his German fluency. Location: Camp Barracks
-
Dalrymple's Intervention — Dalrymple hears Hašek out, believes him, and protects him from lynching. Location: Camp Office
Correspondence and Surveillance
Hašek begins writing to Mitchell's wife Celia to maintain his cover, but their letters gradually foster a genuine emotional bond. Meanwhile, Gestapo agent Forster visits the camp multiple times, growing increasingly suspicious of Hašek's true identity.
Key Events
-
Dalrymple's Intervention — Dalrymple hears Hašek out, believes him, and protects him from lynching. Location: Camp Office
-
Forster's First Visit — Gestapo agent Forster visits, compliments Hašek's German, and eyes him suspiciously. Location: Camp Yard
-
Celia's First Letter — Mitchell's wife writes to him, mentioning their children and hoping to reconcile. Characters: Celia Mitchell
Location: Celia's Home / Camp
-
Hašek's Decision to Reply — Hašek decides to respond as Mitchell to maintain his cover and return affection. Location: Camp
-
Correspondence Begins — They exchange many letters, developing a genuine emotional relationship. Characters: Celia Mitchell
Location: Camp / Celia's Home
-
Forster's Second Visit — Forster visits again, seeming to recognize Hašek but unable to place him. Location: Camp
The Repatriation Gambit
Forster finally confronts Hašek with his knowledge of the impersonation. When Hašek is unexpectedly left off the repatriation list, Dalrymple, Hardy, and Mathews devise a risky plan to break into the Kommandant's office and swap names on the official documents.
Key Events
-
Forster's Second Visit — Forster visits again, seeming to recognize Hašek but unable to place him. Location: Camp
-
Forster's Revelation — Forster tells Hašek he knows he is not Mitchell and sent his photo to Berlin. Location: Camp Office
-
Repatriation Announcement — Announcement that some prisoners will be repatriated. Location: Camp Yard
-
Medical Exam Rejection — Hašek is turned away from the medical exam, realizing he is not on the list. Location: Camp Clinic
-
Mathews Volunteers — Private Mathews volunteers to let Hašek go in his place on the repatriation list. Location: Camp Barracks
Truth and Reunion
Hašek returns to Britain and confesses the truth to Celia, causing her initial devastation. After time passes, Celia rereads the letters, realizes her love for Hašek, and eagerly reconnects with him on V-E Day.
Key Events
-
Mathews Volunteers — Private Mathews volunteers to let Hašek go in his place on the repatriation list. Location: Camp Barracks
-
Breaking into Kommandant's Office — The trio breaks in to replace Mathews with Mitchell on the official list. Location: Kommandant's Office
-
Successful Swap — They successfully alter the documents, securing Hašek's release. Location: Kommandant's Office
-
Hašek's Return to Britain — Hašek is returned to Britain, leaving the camp behind. Location: British Port
-
Celia's Confusion — Celia waits for her husband but is baffled when he does not appear. Characters: Celia Mitchell
Location: Meeting Point
-
Hašek's Confession — Hašek explains his impersonation and breaks the news of Mitchell's death. Characters: Celia Mitchell
Location: Celia's Residence
-
Celia's Devastation — Celia is devastated by the truth and Hašek leaves her home. Characters: Celia Mitchell
Location: Celia's Residence
-
Rereading the Letters — After recovering, Celia rereads the letters and realizes she has fallen in love with the writer. Characters: Celia Mitchell
Location: Celia's Home
-
V-E Day Reunion — On V-E Day, Celia eagerly answers Hašek's call, ready to reconnect. Characters: Celia Mitchell
Location: Telephone
A series of stories about the lives and loves of men in a Prisoner of War camp over five years. The main story is of Hasek (Redgrave) a Czech soldier who needs to keep his identity a secret from the Nazis. To do this, he poses as a dead English Officer and corresponds with the man's wife. Other inmates’ stories are also revealed. Location shooting in the British occupied part of Germany adds believability.