Plot Analysis Summary
A murder investigation becomes increasingly unstable as Herbert's psychological theories, suspicious behavior, and a series of unexplained deaths blur the line between investigation and involvement.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
The Murder Pattern Emerges
A young woman is attacked after accepting a ride from a stranger. Her death is connected to six earlier murders committed in the same manner.
Key Events
-
The First Murder — A young woman accepts a ride, realizes the car is diverting, and is attacked by the driver. Characters: First Victim
Location: Car
-
Seven Similar Murders — Her death is identified as the latest in a series of seven murders committed in the same manner. Characters: First Victim
Location: Unspecified crime scenes
-
Edwards Opens Inquiry — Inspector Edwards leads the investigation into the repeated murders. Characters: Inspector Edwards, First Victim
Location: Police investigation
-
Witness Recalls The Bar — A witness remembers seeing the victim leave a bar with a man. Characters: Inspector Edwards, First Victim
Location: Interview setting
Suspicion Falls On Herbert
A witness identifies Herbert as the man who left the bar with the victim. The Barman confirms Herbert's presence, forcing him to revise his initial denial.
Key Events
-
Herbert Is Identified — The witness identifies Herbert Lyutak, a psychiatrist, as the man seen with the victim. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Inspector Edwards, First Victim
Location: Investigation setting
-
Herbert Denies Memory — Herbert initially claims that he does not remember the woman. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Inspector Edwards
Location: Interview setting
-
The Barman Confirms Herbert — The Barman confirms Herbert's presence, undermining Herbert's initial denial. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Barman, Inspector Edwards
Location: Bar
-
Herbert Recalls The Victim — Herbert suddenly recalls the victim and begins offering psychological opinions about the killer. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, First Victim
Location: Investigation setting
The Psychiatrist Intervenes
Herbert offers theories about the murderer and claims that he might understand or cure him. His prediction of a pool attack leads Edwards to prepare a police operation.
Key Events
-
Marcia Fears Herbert's Obsession — Marcia worries as Herbert becomes increasingly absorbed in understanding the murderer. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Marcia Lyutak
Location: Lyutak household
-
Herbert Promises A Cure — Herbert insists that he may understand or even cure the murderer. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Inspector Edwards
Location: Investigation setting
-
The Pool Prediction — Herbert predicts another crime at a park swimming pool, prompting Edwards to prepare an operation. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Inspector Edwards
Location: Park swimming pool
-
Police Prepare Bait — Edwards prepares an operation using a woman as bait for the predicted attack. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Inspector Edwards
Location: Park swimming pool
Deaths And Hidden Evidence
Miss Heindrich dies in circumstances resembling suicide, while an open window, a breeze, and bloodstained gloves complicate the inquiry. A drugged woman and an accusation against Herbert deepen the uncertainty.
Key Events
-
A Man Is Followed — Herbert claims to have a man followed, apparently suspecting a parking valet. Characters: Herbert Lyutak
Location: Street and parking area
-
Miss Heindrich Dies — Miss Heindrich dies under unexplained circumstances made to resemble suicide. Characters: Miss Heindrich, Inspector Edwards
Location: Miss Heindrich's residence
-
The Breeze Explanation — Herbert explains how an open window and slight breeze could have caused the fatal fall. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Miss Heindrich
Location: Miss Heindrich's residence
-
Gloves Become Evidence — Gloves containing hair and blood become important evidence, but the hidden motive remains unknown. Characters: Inspector Edwards, Miss Heindrich
Location: Investigation setting
-
A Drugged Woman Found — A disturbing episode reveals a woman who has been drugged. Characters: Herbert Lyutak
Location: Unspecified interior
The House Of False Screams
Herbert returns to a house filled with frightened women and apparent murder screams. The screams come from a tape, but Laurel disappears and the final telephone call remains unanswered.
Key Events
-
Herbert Is Accused — A man confronts Herbert, accusing him of killing his girlfriend and trying to frame him. Characters: Herbert Lyutak
Location: Unspecified interior
-
Recorded Screams — Herbert returns to frightened women and strange screams that initially sound like a murder. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Marcia Lyutak, Joaquine
Location: Lyutak household
-
The Tape Is Revealed — The apparent screams are revealed to be a recording rather than a live murder. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Marcia Lyutak, Joaquine
Location: Lyutak household
-
Laurel Disappears — Laurel disappears, causing Marcia to panic and fear that the end has come. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Marcia Lyutak, Laurel
Location: Lyutak household
-
The Unanswered Call — Herbert orders surveillance of the doors, while the final telephone call initially goes unanswered. Characters: Herbert Lyutak, Marcia Lyutak
Location: Lyutak household