Plot Analysis Summary
A military investigation uncovers how wartime brutality, guilt, and unresolved grief culminate in an ambiguous act of revenge.
Story Structure — 5 Plot Phases
A Shooting Without Answers
A retired colonel is shot in France, but the police cannot solve the case. A young army officer is assigned to investigate.
Key Events
-
Colonel Is Shot — A retired colonel is shot in his home in France in 1993.
Location: The retired colonel's home
-
Police Investigation Stalls — The police are unable to explain the shooting.
Location: France
-
Officer Joins Investigation — A young army officer is brought in to assist with the investigation.
Location: France
-
First Diary Pages — A letter arrives containing diary pages from a missing wartime lieutenant.
Location: The investigating officer's workplace
Pages From A Buried War
Diary pages begin arriving and transport the investigation into the Algerian war. The lieutenant's service under the colonel is shown through black-and-white flashbacks.
Key Events
-
First Diary Pages — A letter arrives containing diary pages from a missing wartime lieutenant.
Location: The investigating officer's workplace
-
Diary Reveals Wartime Past — The diary recounts military service during the Algerian war.
Location: Algeria, 1955
-
Flashback To Command — Black-and-white flashbacks show the lieutenant serving under the colonel.
Location: Algeria
-
Torture Is Witnessed — The lieutenant witnesses torture carried out during the war.
Location: Algeria
-
Public Executions — The diary describes public executions and their moral impact.
Location: Algeria
-
Peace Versus Brutality — The lieutenant is torn between seeking peace and rejecting brutal methods.
Location: Algeria
The Cost Of Obedience
The diary describes torture, executions, and the lieutenant's conflict between peace and military brutality. His accidental disclosure may contribute to a shopkeeper's murder.
Key Events
-
Peace Versus Brutality — The lieutenant is torn between seeking peace and rejecting brutal methods.
Location: Algeria
-
Information Reaches Rebels — The lieutenant unintentionally reveals information to a friend sympathetic to the rebels.
Location: Algeria
-
Shopkeeper Is Murdered — A shopkeeper providing information to the French army is murdered.
Location: Algeria
-
Firing Squad Order — The colonel orders the lieutenant to command a firing squad.
Location: Algeria
-
Order Is Defied — The lieutenant resolves to disobey his superior's order.
Location: Algeria
A Message Delayed
The lieutenant decides to disobey a firing-squad order and leaves the diary with a friend for his father. A later television appearance finally causes the pages to be delivered.
Key Events
-
Order Is Defied — The lieutenant resolves to disobey his superior's order.
Location: Algeria
-
Diary's Intended Recipient — The diary was left with a friend for delivery to the lieutenant's father.
Location: Algeria
-
Television Appearance — A recent television appearance prompts the friend to deliver the letter.
Location: France
-
Letter Reaches Father — The friend finally delivers the diary material to the lieutenant's father.
Location: France
-
Father Admits Sending Pages — The father admits that he has been sending the diary pages.
Location: The father's home
The Father's Reckoning
The father admits sending the diary and killing the retired colonel. The officer cannot arrest him and leaves with the case morally unresolved.
Key Events
-
Father Admits Sending Pages — The father admits that he has been sending the diary pages.
Location: The father's home
-
Murder Confession — The father confesses to murdering the retired colonel.
Location: The father's home
-
No Remorse Explained — The father says the colonel showed no remorse for his son's death and called him a traitor.
Location: The father's home
-
Uncertain Departure — Unable to arrest the father, the officer chooses lunch with her commander instead of returning immediately to work.
Location: The road back to the office
'Reformed Colonel' Raoul Duplan is found dead in Paris, a couple of decades after Algeria's struggle for independence was won from France. Assigned to investigate, Lieutenant Galois receives the diary of Lieutenent Guy Rossi, who served under Duplan in Algeria in 1956, and has been reported as MIA since 1957. The revelations in Rossi's diary far surpass Duplan's actions in Algeria, and give insight on how dirty Algeria's War for Independence really was.