BoJack, Todd, and Ana Spanakopita go on tour in New York City, where he meets playwright Jill Pill, who asks him to check on an associate of theirs named "Cuddlywhiskers". J.D. Salinger ends his game show, leaving Mr. Peanutbutter without a job, and he returns to pitching costly, nonsensical business ideas. BoJack almost has sex with a reporter against Ana's wishes and becomes uncomfortable, vaguely alluding to the incident in New Mexico and admitting his role in Secretariat is fake, which the r
In 2007, BoJack is dating Princess Carolyn, the secretary to his agent who later takes his job when he quits, and is refusing to take new roles, unable to move on from the success of Horsin' Around. Todd has his first kiss with his friend Emily and the two date, but he becomes uncomfortable when she posits the idea of having sex and flees her house when her dad comes home. Mr. Peanutbutter's second wife Jessica Biel leaves him, and he meets Diane while she caters an event he is speaking at. BoJa
Jill asks BoJack to retrieve a love letter from Cuddlywhiskers's house, but he and Diane find an orca stripper dead in his pool. The use of BoJack's name in her last text lead him and Diane to believe he is being framed for murder, but they learn that "BoJack" is actually the name of a brand of heroin being distributed by a former Horsin' Around actor, which the stripper overdosed on. Todd and Mr. Peanutbutter get sprayed by a skunk and end up setting fire to Mr. Peanutbutter's yard while trying
BoJack attends a film festival in the Pacific Ocean, where he cannot understand the native tongue and is forced to wear a helmet that prevents him from speaking. He spots Kelsey Jannings there for her new film and writes a halfhearted apology note for getting her fired, but is swept onto a bus by a school of minnows and taken out of the city before he can deliver it. On the bus, BoJack watches a seahorse give birth and accidentally leave one of his babies behind. BoJack forms a kinship with the
Secretariat premieres publicly and is met with overwhelmingly positive reviews. BoJack and Todd celebrate at a hotel, where they bump into Emily, who is there for her best friend's rehearsal dinner. Sensing Emily's attraction to Todd, BoJack sets them up with a room so they can have sex, but Todd is again uncomfortable and leaves Emily alone. BoJack accidentally causes one of the brides to have doubts about her marriage, and he reinvigorates her by talking about his own feelings on love, which d
Diane and Mr. Peanutbutter agree to get an abortion, and she accidentally tweets that she is getting one from pop star Sextina Aquafina's account while talking to BoJack. Princess Carolyn and Sextina embrace it when it gains her popularity and plan to fake an abortion on live television, which Diane is disgusted with until she realizes the music is inspiring young women getting their own abortions. Sextina actually gets pregnant and plans to keep it, and Diane and Princess Carolyn start plotting
BoJack calls a newspaper that keeps delivering to his door despite trying to get it cancelled, and recounts recent events to the representative as she tries to convince him to keep his subscription. Margo Martindale is revealed to have been hiding in the Escape From L.A. and stealing food from his kitchen, and eventually takes the boat to flee from the law. Emily and Todd start a female cab service with women drivers, but BoJack and Emily are visibly uncomfortable around each other, and she even
Diane and Mr. Peanutbutter go to the Labrador Peninsula to be with his family for the New Year's. Diane believes Mr. Peanutbutter's older brother is expressing distaste for her abortion when he makes several morbid statements about mortality around her. He instead reveals to Mr. Peanutbutter that he actually has a twisted spleen that requires surgery to fix, which worries him. BoJack is contacted by the actor who played his son on Horsin' Around, Bradley Hitler-Smith, who wants to do a sequel se
BoJack has dinner with Princess Carolyn at the restaurant he owns, where he fires her for her inability to handle Bradley and Kelsey. The head waiter mistakes this for him being fired and gets almost the entire staff to quit, and BoJack and Princess Carolyn fight over the history of their relationship. As BoJack and the only remaining staff member try to figure out how to cook for a food critic, Princess Carolyn briefly leaves, but cannot resist coming back to save him. They order the food criti
Mr. Peanutbutter is given the opportunity to host the Oscar nomination announcements, but loses the envelope containing the nominees after he gets distracted when he learns that his brother is recovering well from surgery. He and Todd try to come up with a new list of nominees from scratch, and while Mr. Peanutbutter picks BoJack for a Best Actor slot, Todd is reluctant. Princess Carolyn's competent assistant Judah Mannowdog suggests that she use the agency's financial struggles as an excuse to
BoJack convinces Sarah Lynn to break her sobriety and go on a bender with him. They binge Horsin' Around and goes to one of her sobriety meetings, where he rambles about his misdeed with Penny before blacking out. Through a series of blackouts, he tries to make amends with all of the people in his life, including Ana, who tells him a story where the moral is that some people cannot be saved. He and Sarah Lynn drive to Oberlin to see if Penny Carson is alright, but his appearance only distresses
In 2007, BoJack approaches Sarah Lynn after a show, and she vents to him before he uncaringly asks her to guest star on The BoJack Horseman Show, visibly wounding her. In the present, Sarah Lynn dies of an overdose, leaving BoJack guilt-stricken, and he decides to do Bradley's show. Princess Carolyn decides to open the agency back up but work as a manager instead of an agent. Diane gets a job at a company run by Ralph's sister, who hires her because she is impressed by her speaking out against H