In 1992, Mr. Peanutbutter stumbles onto the set of what will become his show and gets the lead role by accident. Three months after BoJack's disappearance, Mr. Peanutbutter does not get the signatures required to run for governor, but Diane unintentionally encourages him to challenge current governor Woodchuck Coodchuck-Berkowitz to a ski race for the position. Woodchuck easily triumphs over Mr. Peanutbutter in the race, but Todd, who was gifted a "drone throne" by Emily using her share of the c
In the 1940s, Beatrice Horseman's brother Crackerjack is killed in World War II, and her mother Honey has a breakdown during a celebration of the end of the war. Drunk, she has Beatrice drive them home, but she crashes the car. Her father Joseph has Honey lobotomized, and she asks Beatrice to never love anyone as much as she loved her son. In the present, BoJack almost joins the wild horses, but is distracted by a call from Diane (which he ignores) and watches as they pass by him. He drives out
Todd barely makes it to his part as a triangle player in an orchestra, and afterwards, the members tell tales of his exploits, the oboe player wishing he would take time off from all his responsibilities. Todd accidentally registers Mr. Peanutbutter as pro-fracking against Diane's wishes, and encourages her to stay true to her honest career path when she expresses doubts about her journalism. Princess Carolyn asks him to pose as the boyfriend of actress Courtney Portnoy, and he accidentally star
BoJack and Hollyhock visit the president of his fan club who he had sex with, and Hollyhock takes her list of women BoJack has slept with while he has sex with the woman to distract her. As they go through the list, BoJack unintentionally insults Hollyhock while degrading himself, causing her to run off and forcing him to look through the list to find her. He lies about her mother still being out there to get her to stay, and invites her to live with him. Princess Carolyn buys a watch that infor
Courtney's new action movie is jeopardized by a series of mass shootings. Diane is initially anti-gun, but after Courtney uses her handgun to fend off a creepy guy in front of her, she quickly becomes pro-gun against Mr. Peanutbutter's wishes and popularizes the idea of women owning them, causing them to again have sex after a publicized debate. When a woman perpetrates a shooting, the California Legislature votes on banning all guns rather than helping women feel more safe. BoJack and Hollyhock
BoJack's self-loathing thoughts follow him throughout the day, represented by crudely animated sequences depicting what he is imagining. He is wounded to see Beatrice caring for a horse doll and throws it over his deck in a rage, causing her to fall into a depression. He has Mr. Peanutbutter pick up its scent and gets it back from his neighbor Felicity Huffman, on the condition that he appears on her show. Princess Carolyn and Courtney's agent, Rutabaga Rabitowitz, learn that Meryl Streep is ret
The foundation of Mr. Peanutbutter's house collapses during a fundraiser, sending the house underground with only Todd and Princess Carolyn not trapped inside. Enraged that Mr. Peanutbutter continued to frack, Diane locks herself in her bedroom with BoJack, who she has not seen since he returned, and drinks excessively with him while admitting how unhappy she is. Woodchuck tunnels in to save the occupants, but they accidentally cause a rockslide that cuts off their exit and crushes his hands. Wh
BoJack guest stars on "Felicity Huffmans' Booty Academy L.A." to fulfill his favor, and Hollyhock immediately falls for an intern that BoJack distrusts. He tries to expose the intern's supposed scumminess by getting a contestant to sleep with him, but she goes to the wrong person and BoJack is fired from the show. The intern approaches him and promises to leave Hollyhock alone if BoJack reads a script of his, leading BoJack to realize he was right about him all along. Todd starts a new venture i
In the distant future, a cat named Ruthie tells her class of the worst day of her ancestor Princess Carolyn's life for a school project. Courtney fires Princess Carolyn for mishandling her action movie and the wedding, the clasp on her family heirloom necklace breaks, and she miscarries again but does not have the heart to tell Ralph. She learns that her necklace is actually cheap jewelry, and that Judah Mannowdog rejected an offer to merge with another agency on her behalf, prompting her to fir
Woodchuck nearly loses the race when his new hands are discovered to be those of a serial killer, but Diane has lunch with Biel and leaks to the public that she hates avocados, tanking her popularity and winning Woodchuck the seat of governor. Princess Carolyn is visited by screenwriter Flip McVicker who pitches a thriller series called Philbert, the name of the hypothetical son she and Ralph were going to have, and Todd uses his clown dentists to get her a meeting with Lenny Turtletaub. He requ
Beatrice re-experiences important events of her life through disoriented, dreamlike flashbacks as BoJack drives her to the nursing home. After Honey's lobotomization, Beatrice contracts scarlet fever and Joseph burns her baby horse doll to stop the spread of infection. As a young adult, he attempts to force her into a relationship for business reasons at her debutante ball, where she meets Butterscotch Horseman, a drifter and aspiring novelist that she falls for and engages in a one night stand
Princess Carolyn gets Philbert picked up by the website WhatTimeIsItRightNow.com and gets BoJack's approval to have him star in it. Todd and Yolanda discover that the clown dentists have contracted rabies, which Todd turns into another business venture that gets cleared by Yolanda. Having developed feelings for him, she reveals she is also asexual and asks him out on a date. After buying a new house, Diane and Mr. Peanutbutter go on a road trip, where she reveals she always wanted a Beauty and t